3 ms·
One of the things I always find frustrating about economists and economic writing is how often it completely and deliberately disregards the humanity of the act
by munificent 8y ago
One of the things I always find frustrating about economists and economic writing is how often it completely and deliberately disregards the humanity of the actors in the system. My hunch is that the people who are drawn to economics like it specifically because it attempts to offer a cleaner, more mechanical understanding of human behavior than humans actually demonstrate.
But, of course, using that model to then derive policy is obviously flawed since your model doesn't accurately capture the essential features of the objects being modeled.
If we let economists design furniture, every chair would be a miserably unpleasant cube whose dimensions match the median posterior.
Land value tax does have a lot going for it, but it overlooks one critical component:
Humans have a fundamental desire for stability, especially in where they live. I do not want my home to be a rectangle of maximum market efficiency. I want it to be a place where it's worth the effort to garden because I know I'll get to watch those plants grow over the coming years. I want it to be a calm respite, a sanctuary that I can rely on in the face of the chaos of the larger world. And, as I get older and my ability to generate revenue natural declines, I want some confidence that hard work I did when I was younger will enable me to live out the rest of my years with some degree of stability.
Of course, our desire for stability needs to be weighed against the desires of the larger community. But you do that by balancing those desires, not by completely ignoring one half of the equation.
I'm not sure what an ideal solution for housing is, but I'm certain it's not based on a slavish devotion to market efficiency.
- germinalphrase 8y agoWhy would land value tax undermine housing stability?
- prutschman 8y agoThe unimproved value of land is still a function of its proximity to other desirable things. Barring remodeling, it's not generally the value of the building on a piece of land that goes up over time.
- supertrope 8y agogentrification
- yonran 8y agoThere’s no insurmountable conflict between stability and efficiency. Just as landlords offer 10-year leases to commercial tenants who desire stability, the government can offer 10-year (or longer) insurance products against the risk of increased land value.
- opportune 8y agoThis is just “I got mine” as the economists. Meanwhile younger people who want to buy homes are unable to enjoy the way of life that you are, because you were able to buy a home before they had even graduated middle school Why should society have to slow down just to help you and your little old house? You can just move somewhere else with a garden. Everybody else is also trying to work and live their lives. This isn’t little house on the prairie, it’s quite selfish to buy a house in a city (an inherently dynamic landscape) and then expect the rest of the world to freeze in time
- watwut 8y agoWhen an elderly person want to live nearby family and keep social ties they were building whole life, it is "go away I want to live here too your relationship and you don't matter at all. Just go elsewhere, living among strangers as you are getting weaker and older is totally the same and I dont care about you at all. It is totally our right to kick you out of your house because the place where it is suddenly became in demand." Simultaneously we are collectively complaining that people don't communicate or form bonds as they used to and how community died yadda yadda and people are lonely, especially men and how sad it all is yadda. Guess what, this attitude kills any kind of in-person bonds or willingness to invest into them way more then much maligned social networks.
- opportune 8y agoCan you remind me what this has to do with land value tax? Also prop 13 is much more than just a proposition for seniors. It will maybe help the first couple generations of seniors, but it also allows property owning funds to secure low taxes in perpetuity My original point is that if you want to own land forever without “the neighborhood changing”, don’t buy a plot in a city or suburban area. You have no right to enjoy the benefits of living in a city while forcing everyone else to respect your rights of a homesteader on a ranch in unincorporated land. People had to deal with rising property prices and change to make the city a desirable place to live, but as soon as you get property all you can think of is keeping everything just the way it is. That’s why it’s selfish.
- supertrope 8y agoStability comes with a cost. Just like how individuals have to pay insurance premiums and fixed price plans cost more than metered for most people (assuming usage is the same). When prices cannot vary, businesses can use some non-price pricing like offering a free month (but not changing the list rent), lotteries, waiting lists, personal connections, tying to other services, etc. but eventually a shortage or glut must result if the price cannot vary to its more natural level. Rent control and other price controls favor one subset of consumers over everyone else. If we don't use prices to allocate housing and land, what makes one system better than another? Why not hold an essay writing contest or dance-off to determine who gets to live in a house or apartment? Home ownership is implicitly subsidized by the government. 30 year mortgages for the masses are only possible through government guarantees. Highways to enable urban sprawl are government built.