5 ms·
Sprawl taxes are badly needed for the environment. What needs to be financially incented is extremely dense urban population centers. As in Manhattan everywhere
by AtlasBarfed 8y ago
Sprawl taxes are badly needed for the environment. What needs to be financially incented is extremely dense urban population centers. As in Manhattan everywhere.
IIRC Japan has density patterns like this.
Basically, if an area adjacent to a high density population area wants to expand into the area, it accepts a very very high entry cost, either ongoing property tax or initial permit cost. That would force only very large and dense building development.
Transportation could be exempted as could parks and certain low income housing which is basically government controlled anyway at this point.
That might also incent vertical farms, although I haven't kept up with the viable economics of skyscraper-class vertical farming yet.
One of the primary challenges of modern environmentalism is just sprawl: people driving too far, people spreading out too much, people buying too big of houses that are energy inefficient, people buying yards that they use 1% of the time
- swebs 8y ago>extremely dense urban population centers. As in Manhattan everywhere Sounds like hell to me.
- droopyEyelids 8y agoThe point is, one should pay enough that infrastructure maintenance of their location is possible. StrongTown's thesis (that isn't really in question) is that suburban sprawl is financed by handouts from the government, but nothing finances the maintenance of that sprawl after the initial build out. StrongTowns does a lot of analysis proving that densely occupied areas generate enough revenue to repair their gas, electricity, transportation, sewage etc- but less dense suburban areas do not. If dense population is hell, then you better pay enough money for repairs that happen on 30+ year cycles, or else you're looking at another type of bad situation.
- claydavisss 8y agoMost of the US is sprawl and seems to be adequately handling maintenance. Density is not a necessary precondition for economical maintenance...NYC's subway system is in a shambles despite the highest density in the US, and mostly affluent residents. Only a few places in the US have both sprawl and very high labor costs. It would be a crisis if the entirety of the US resembled Palo Alto and had similar costs...but this isn't the case.
- woolvalley 8y agoYou can also have Barcelona everywhere. That is dense enough.
- francisofascii 8y agoPartially agree, but Manhattan goes to far. Go back to walkable towns and villages, 3-6 stories in height, surrounded by forests and countryside.
- fapjacks 8y agoSo, like... Europe.
- electricslpnsld 8y agoA good chunk of Manhattan is low to mid rise with pretty sweet parks interspersed -- the skyscraper madness that is midtown is fairly contained. Hell, I used to rent a floor in a two story house on a fairly bucolic street in Harlem.
- jimmaswell 8y agoAt the end of the day, our motive for serving the environment is so that it can serve us better in the future. Making the environment its own end instead of a means like this would be backwards - sprawl is much nicer to live in for a great number of people who don't want to be packed into tiny apartments and surrounded by concrete in every direction all day.
- zjaffee 8y agoI agree with this, but it's important that developing cities understand what makes Manhattan more family friendly than many of the urban centers being built up today, and that is family sized apartments (Something that you essentially never see in new larger apartment complexes where the largest apartment is a 800 sqft 2 bedroom apartments). This is in my opinion why so many people are resisting the destruction of single family home neighborhoods, namely because there is a huge lack of the diversity of housing types within apartments, especially at more affordable price ranges.
- woolvalley 8y agoIt's more an American thing. In China I think family sized apartments are common enough.
- baybal2 8y ago>800 sqft 2 bedroom apartments :) Tell that to Chinese. 300m² upscale apartments are not rare. The most extreme ones are mansion apartments of up to 500m²
- claydavisss 8y agoThe US is 95% sprawl is and still almost completely empty in terms of land use. Indeed pouring the concrete of your Coruscant fantasy would be more harmful than just maintaining our existing infrastructure, flawed as it might be.
- kileywm 8y agoInterestingly, there are parts of the world where building height regulations exist for aesthetic reasons. For example, in Madison, WI such a limit exists to preserve the view of the capitol building [1]. [1] https://host.madison.com/ct/news/local/writers/mike_ivey/by-design-madison-has-no-tall-buildings/article_64e73570-b5e1-11e3-9e53-0019bb2963f4.html https://host.madison.com/ct/news/local/writers/mike_ivey/by-...