3 ms·
The point is that systemic issues in society reduce opportunities of minorities/females that otherwise would be as competent or moreso than whites or males. Fo
by unethical_ban 8y ago
The point is that systemic issues in society reduce opportunities of minorities/females that otherwise would be as competent or moreso than whites or males.
For hundreds of years and most of recorded history, non-whites and females have been seen as inherently less capable and intellectual. Only in the past 20-40 years has Western society (as a whole) made explicit, respectable attempts at giving minorities credit for their capacity to lead and to learn.
I understand your point, and I don't think your opinion is of malice: I used to have the same one. And it is tough, because unlike some other societal issues, college admissions is a zero-sum game. Therefore, no matter how noble the idea, it seems pretty shitty that a smart, motivated and passionate white man would get passed over at an elite university in order to allow an equally passionate, motivated person of color who isn't as smart (on paper).
Diversity is useful for its own sake, and giving historically suppressed groups of people more opportunity is noble. How can we do it equitably? Perhaps use the government to better higher education instead of trillion dollar tax cuts for the uber-wealthy. But that wades further into politics.