4 ms·
I spent a lot of time fishing as a child, as my father was an avid fisherman. Some of my best memories are of stream and lake fishing in the Sierras, tuna fish
by colordrops 8y ago
I spent a lot of time fishing as a child, as my father was an avid fisherman. Some of my best memories are of stream and lake fishing in the Sierras, tuna fishing off boats in Cabo, and bass fishing of the coast near Del Mar.
And yet I can't get myself to do it as an adult, even though I have two young children who I know would love it. It's with very mixed emotion that I decide not to go. My social circle finds fishing repugnant, and while that's a factor, I could just do it and not tell them. But there is also the aspect of hooking a fish and dragging it in for sport. I eat meat and don't even find the act of fishing particular offensive, but I guess I do have some buddhist sentiments lurking in the back of my mind. It seems that if I wish to harvest fish I should do so in the quickest and least painful way, and not as a sport. I do wish I did not have this lingering concern as I would love to go fishing without guilt.
I do not take offense to anyone else fishing for sport, so forgive me if my comment sounds judgmental, as that is not my intent.
- everdev 8y agoI grew up fishing as well with the same wonderful memories, but can't enjoy it with my kids for the same reasons you mentioned. There is something beautiful about the slow, patience of fishing that feels refreshing. I just can't imagine someone stabbing a metal hook through my cheek and dragging me out of my home. But I'd love to find an activity that feels similar to fishing without enforcing my dominance over a wild animal.
- intruder 8y agoMeditating.
- lambdaphagy 8y agoThe cognitive modules that govern dominance and hunting are completely different things, in us as in all hunting species. We don't actually treat prey as we treat conspecifics we wish to dominate. Neither do cats or mantis shrimp.
- te0006 8y agoTry sailing. No need to have an expensive yacht - a sailing dinghy or a humble daysailer will do. (In fact, the smaller the boat the more direct and intense the experience will be.) Older but perfectly usable small boats are surprisingly cheap. What you do need of course is a quiet stretch of water, preferably without too much other maritime traffic. Read up a bit and have a try yourself, ideally on a smaller lake during a light breeze. Perhaps using a rented or borrowed boat first. And if fiddling with sails is not your thing, or your area has only rivers but no lakes, canoeing can be very relaxing too. Today you can buy light but sturdy inflatable canoes made from hi-tech drop-stitch material that take just 10mins to deploy. Of course, even when the risks are minimal, always think about safety - life vests etc., especially in case you take children with you.
- AlecSchueler 8y agoI feel the same way. I fished as a child and have some good memories of it. I also have some friends as an adult who I know would benefit socially from coming fishing with me. But ethically I just can't do it. I don't want to sound judgmental either, but I'd encourage anyone who feels this way and is still eating other animals to reconsider their positions.
- jeromenerf 8y agoI agree. Fish for food. Release or kill promptly the fish you catch. Beheading is simple, straight and mammals loves the fat of fish brains. If your kids don’t enjoy eating grilled trout, try raising chickens for eggs :)
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoMmm. Similar issues can arise. I never thought much about fishing until the day I had a large catfish flopping around on my kitchen floor (catfish live quite a while out of water). Having been mainly a catch & release type, this would be the first fish I ate in quite a while and I was acutely aware (obviously) that I had to kill a live animal before I could eat it. So I said a short prayer to the fish gods and plunged a knife into its brain and it died instantly. Tasted pretty good. Fast forward two decades or so later. Neighbor dogs broke into my chicken coop and killed most of the flock. Now I have a handful of bloody chickens lying around slowly dying. The only humane thing to do is to kill them quickly. So grab each one carefully, quickly snap its neck and it's dead. Although one of the situations was clearly not initiated by me, the feeling I had in both cases was essentially the same: regret, but that's how life goes sometimes.
- pvaldes 8y agoDon't haste to kill it. Chicken are prey birds and fight all the time with other chicken. Can cure serious injuries surprisingly fast and recover from grizzly attacks. Just apply Aloe vera in the damaged parts, feed well, keep it warm in a calm place isolated from other chicken and wait. They will benefit also if you allow them eat the remaining chunks of aloe (only the transparent gel, not the bitter green parts).
- gadders 8y agoIn terms of humaneness, I would say catching your own fish compares favourably with trawling and similar methods. I think fish there are mostly left to suffocate or freeze after being hauled up and chucked into the boat's hold.
- icantdrive55 8y ago"I do not take offense to anyone else fishing for sport, so forgive me if my comment sounds judgmental, as that is not my intent." 1. This is a website. Stand by your convictions. There's too many people here kissing ass for no reason. Do I care about my Karma--f--no. Do I care about being hellbanned--no. Like any hacker can't get around a hellband? 2. I'm in the same boat as you, but times are different. We have decimated most fish populations. Even in the Sierras, the fishing is terrible. Lot's of insects. Lot's of crystal clear water, but no fish? Or, at least not the fish I remember as a kid. 3. My last time fishing was on the bay. I caught a Batray. I pulled it to shore. My buddy said, it's crying like a baby. I let it go, and that was my last day of fishing. 4. And I'll go farther--I am keeping score on which ethnicities are raping the waters the most, and trying not to do business with them.