3 ms·
> One example, when they try to find counter-points and to challenge the person they interview the questions they ask often seem... again, the only word I have
by mistermann 8y ago
> One example, when they try to find counter-points and to challenge the person they interview the questions they ask often seem... again, the only word I have is "dumb". As if they take it from some catalog they were given back in journalist school with instructions for how to "challenge" someone, and they follow their script, but the result does not make any sense. I often feel they mistake simply annoying people for challenging them.
Can you give an example of one you thought was dumb? Personally, I took something entirely different away from the article....yes, it is almost a simple script you can follow....learn to recognize when the person is exhibiting symptoms of one of the many logical/psychological "flaws" of the human mind, and ask a followup question appropriate to get the person to notice and overcome that flaw themselves.
> I don't think "better discussions" actually help that much for a lot of topics - the actual solution - please bear with me! - may actually be not to discuss certain topics with everybody.
It seems to me that would be an improvement, but for the wrong reasons.
Your last paragraph is a good example of how asking bad questions can cause rifts, and how it may not be obvious that the question is bad (until you explain it). Rather than not discussing things, I'd rather at least make an effort to teach everyone this. Considering the state of politics in the world today, it's not exactly unimportant.
- ItsMe000001 8y agoI read an interview with a scientist just yesterday where I had exactly that feeling. Same almost every time they interview someone, could also be politicians. The questions they ask them are infuriating - infuriatingly stupid. They are told "you must challenge the person you interview and ask provocative questions", but since the journalists seem to have no clue about the subject they invent completely made-up unnatural and stupid questions. Sure, I'm sure that someone out there among their readership may actually have those questions, but that's the fringe 5% of the population. When they "challenge" politicians the main goal seems to be to be as annoying, as possible, as a measurement of how "good" their questions are at "challenging" the person. Even when I dislike the politician they interview, much of the time I pity him/her because not even people I dislike should have to answer such questions. Made-up scenarios like "but what if a meteorite hit that building", questions about things that have a 0.001% chance or less of happening take the center, more often not even the question itself makes sense because it depends on not understanding the subject by a long shot.
- mistermann 8y agoCan you give some examples from the original article that you consider dumb? I'm curious whether I agree or disagree with you, because this general subject is something I'm keenly interested in.