3 ms·
Well, the hypothesis was tested on data... that data being drugs to reduce amyloid plaques, which have only recently been found to not work to ameliorate Alzhei
by jcranmer 8y ago
Well, the hypothesis was tested on data... that data being drugs to reduce amyloid plaques, which have only recently been found to not work to ameliorate Alzheimer's.
The amyloid hypothesis looks to be an open-and-shut case of "correlation does not imply causation." The problem is, we don't know what actually causes Alzheimer's, and for the longest time, the amyloid plaque correlation was the only thing that looked like it could be a cause. On top of that, actually testing these hypotheses takes a long time, especially if you take the not-unreasonable attitude that tackling them after on its onset (i.e., before it's readily detectable) may be too late.
- nonbel 8y ago>"Well, the hypothesis was tested on data... that data being drugs to reduce amyloid plaques, which have only recently been found to not work to ameliorate Alzheimer's." Right now I'm not even interested in how accurate the amyloid hypothesis turns out to be[1], but as you say its only recently the the hypothesis been tested. Sure, maybe it is just hard to test it, etc. But, why did people find it "unthinkable" to consider the hypothesis was incorrect before it was ever really tested? I feel like there is a really good example of philosophy/sociology of science fail to learn from here. The problem I'm interested in isnt with the hypothesis itself, its with the seemingly unwarranted very strong belief in the hypothesis amongst the "experts". [1] When I first learned amyloids are one of the most thermodynamically favorable states of polypeptides and the cell must devote constant resources to preventing their formation, I pretty much gave 99/1 odds amyloids are a symptom instead of cause.
- tim333 8y agoBeing a little cynical the reason for the "unthinkable" thing may be in the article: > “The government and the pharmaceutical industry have invested almost all their resources, and some of the brightest people have been in the amyloid area,” he says Not so much unthinkable but if you speak that thought those invested may attack you in the political "grant applications have negative feedback" sense. You see that quite a lot that when people have built careers based on hypothesis A they do not take kindly to the idea of A being wrong.
- jamesblonde 8y agoThis is far from the whole story. The pathology of alzheimers as predicted by the Amyloid Hypothesis is (year 0) imbalance in the production, (year 10-30) deposition of abeta causes Tau and other downstream complications that are symptomatic. Existing clinical studies started way too late, after the appearance of significant sympthoms - at least mild cognitive impairment. Personally, i take curcumin supplements, as it is known to bind to abeta even in the cerebrospinal fluid, then it gets cleared out over the blood brain barrier. If the abeta hypothesis is true, high dose curcumin should help delay its onset. Another thing to do is get your genome sequenced, even with 23andme. If you have apoe4, you should, IMO, take curcumin.
- exhilaration 8y agoWould you mind sharing which curcumin supplements you take? I'm currently taking one 750mg capsule of curcumin per day but I've been considering switching to theracurmin after reading about it in Hacker News comments.
- jamesblonde 8y agoI take biocurcumax. Curcumin with bioperine is also good - i wouldn't take theracurmin, though. Afaik, it has lots of downstream curcumin metabolites, and they aren't anti-inflammatory/abeta-binding.
- nonbel 8y agoFyi, I have no idea if your regimen (or any) of curcumin is good for you or not but amyloid beta may be protective in some way: >"Mice with excess beta-amyloid survived longer than the controls and had less bacteria in their brains. Mice lacking beta-amyloid (from the genetic removal of APP) died more often from infection." https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/alzheimers-protein-may-have-natural-antibiotic-role https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/alzheim...
- jamesblonde 8y agoCurcumin won't clear out all abeta. Just bind to some and clear it. It also dampens anti-inflammatory pathways (e.g., mild inhibitor of TNF-alpha production). I see the cost-benefit being overall positive for medium-dose curcumin (like 500mg-1g/day).