3 ms·
The problem is that the economic argument is nonsensical unless you significantly raise taxes on people who are not in the 1%, as the amount of potential revenu
by jandrewrogers 8y ago
The problem is that the economic argument is nonsensical unless you significantly raise taxes on people who are not in the 1%, as the amount of potential revenue involved is a pittance. At least in the US, only 20% of the population pay net taxes (tax payments minus transfers from all sources), so even if you raised effective tax rates to 100% on the upper few percent, ignoring the immediate collapse of that tax revenue, the amount of new revenue would be underwhelming.
For the US, the policy challenge is that the distribution of net tax payers is significantly more biased toward the top end of the income range than in many countries in Europe (i.e. it is more progressive, ironically). There is no practical way to sustainably raise substantial tax revenues without expanding the number of people who pay net taxes. This means substantially raising taxes in the 2nd (60-80%) quintile, who have five-figure household incomes on average, and probably the 40%-60% quintile as well.
Any definition of "rich" that could generate substantial net tax revenue is going to come significantly out of the pockets of the middle class. Convincing someone earning $90k in California that they are so wealthy that they should downgrade their lifestyle would be an unenviable task for a politician.
- mcguire 8y agoThe economic effect is occurring. See the chart towards the end of the article. "From another perspective, the story of the last ten years has been one of huge success. At the time of the crash, 19 per cent of the world’s population were living in what the UN defines as absolute poverty, meaning on less than $1.90 a day. Today, that number is below 9 per cent. In other words, the number of people living in absolute poverty has more than halved, while rich-world living standards have flatlined or declined." The proposal is to make the effect explicit rather that political populism of trying to reverse the current trend for those at point B in the chart.
- emodendroket 8y agoI mean, the latest tax bill involved taking money away from those people to give it to people far richer than they are. In particular, look at the changes to deductions for mortgage interest.