5 ms·
> I think that's roughly what I meant; I'd like to see AMD dump resources into making a fully open, compatible-with-all-modern-GPUs toolchain to directly compet
by jcranmer 8y ago
> I think that's roughly what I meant; I'd like to see AMD dump resources into making a fully open, compatible-with-all-modern-GPUs toolchain to directly compete with and replace the CUDA one. For all I know, they already are?
There's OpenCL. Except OpenCL performance is worse than CUDA performance on NVidia, so anyone using NVidia's hardware (essentially, everyone) pretty much wants to use CUDA instead.
- claytonjy 8y agoExactly. We need something roughly on-par with CUDA, though it could be a bit below CUDA on Nvidia cards if it allows near-CUDA performance on non-Nvidia cards. Making all this easier to install/use/deploy could go a long way to winning user over, too; I'll gladly let a model run longer if I spent a lot less time getting things setup properly. The integration part is no small amount of work; it needs to be so smooth that I don't have to care what kind of card I have, and can run TF/Pytorch/etc. models in the same way regardless.
- pjmlp 8y agoOpenCL made the mistake of being C only in the beginning while CUDA embraced C, C++ and Fortran, plus any language that would bother to write a PTX backend. SPIR was too little, too late.
- microcolonel 8y agoMaybe we could have a PTX frontend for SPIR-V. ;- )