4 ms·
Lawyer who argued for Internet sales taxes admits he doesn't pay them
- gnicholas 8y agoNote: I'm the author. I used to be a tax lawyer, before getting into the startup life. Hopefully this piece appeals to non-lawyers and general-purpose readers. Would love to hear comments from fellow HNers!
- edbaskerville 8y agoI see this as a great argument for his side, actually. State governments need to be able to enforce taxation at the time of the transaction, because it's going to be impossible to collect otherwise. Without an effective collection and enforcement mechanism, of course individuals won't go out of their way to make extra payments! Even the tax lawyer arguing the case isn't going out of his way to pay! The question of whether states should be able to charge this tax in the first place is another conversation. But if you accept that levying these taxes is the right choice for society, there needs to be a viable collection mechanism.
- gnicholas 8y agoYeah good point, though probably one could make this point by showing statistics about how much tax is due versus paid. I’m sure the numbers are stark.
- chrisbennet 8y agoWhile the implementation of the tax may be poor (expecting everyone selling something on the internet to know the tax for 1000’s of addresses) it certainly seems fair that the tax should be paid. As a compromise, if the only the state tax was due, that would be something.
- gnicholas 8y agoThat does seem like a much fairer compromise. In the law at issue, a business could be required to charge and remit taxes if they had just 200 transactions with residents in the state. If this means compliance with dozens or hundreds of county laws, that could be burdensome.