3 ms·
Let's say you work for the movie industry. The union requires that union members only work on union productions. If a union member works on a non-union producti
by eesmith 8y ago
Let's say you work for the movie industry. The union requires that union members only work on union productions. If a union member works on a non-union production then they are kicked out of the union. Most people want to be in the union, which means most productions are unionized, even though the employer does not require union membership, the union cannot penalize the employer, and hiring a non-union member is not illegal.
Do you consider that arrangement to be ethical? If it's unethical, what is the basis by which you consider it ethical to force unionized employees to continue work with someone who is not a member of the union, instead of letting them quit their job?
I know this isn't what you asked, but it gets to the heart of the issue - unions are based on the free association right of employees to quit, and their free speech right to protest.
Current union power in the US is based on a compromise. Some union practices are banned, but in exchange they are also given some powers. For example, union members are not allowed to participate in 'wildcat strikes', that is, they cannot strike without permission of the union. On the other hand, unions are allowed to seek the monopoly right to negotiate on the behalf of all covered workers, including non-union ones.
I can well understand what people can think it's unethical to force people to be represented by the union, even if it's not wanted.
But ethics are not so simple. I strongly disagree with the Taft-Hartley Act, and the various so-called "Right-To-Work" laws, IMO correctly called "Right-To-Work-For-Less" laws.
I think wildcat strikes should not be illegal, just like I think jurisdictional strikes, closed shops, monetary donations by unions to federal political campaigns, and the other practices prohibited by Taft-Hartley should not be illegal.
More importantly, I can't see how any ethics which requires people be allowed to negotiate on their own doesn't also end up allowing many union practices which are now banned.
Can you explain to me why wildcat strikes should be banned?