4 ms·
> Our current unemployment rate is virtually the lowest in 20yrs and it's hard to hire ANYBODY as a result. (1) This observation is so weird in the context of
by AlexandrB 8y ago
> Our current unemployment rate is virtually the lowest in 20yrs and it's hard to hire ANYBODY as a result. (1)
This observation is so weird in the context of flat wages and the proliferation of sub-minimum-wage "gig economy" jobs. If labor was really scarce, shouldn't that put upward pressure on wages? Perhaps what automation is doing is giving employers a way out of competing for labor. The long range consequences seem pretty obvious: massive, rising inequality.
- falcolas 8y agoThere's a second option I just recently understood in the "high employment == high wages" equation - employers can just wait longer for hires at the wages they're offering. And, based on the way employers keep the jobs posted for months or years, it seems to be working for them. I guess in a way it's just another signal that the jobs being filled aren't that critical.
- grigjd3 8y agoIn a lot of cases, a job opening listed for months or years reflects a company continuously hiring. I certainly know our office does that.
- protonimitate 8y agoI've always found it strange that the most 'critical' job positions are among the lowest paid / furthest down the totem pole. I work for a medium-sized established tech company. We've been running without a CTO and Director of HR for > 6 months. Everything has run smoothly. We've even had open positions for mid-tier management that have gone unfilled for long enough that they were deemed 'unnecessary' and the req was closed. However, we had two of our operations people (one step above entry level) leave, and our regional office almost tanked completely.
- tsunamifury 8y agoIt's almost as if a CTO is around to make sure stuff like that doesn't happen...
- trobertson 8y agoNo, it is literally operations people who are around to prevent that from happening. (facetious:) C-levels are around to look pretty and offer pleasant platitudes during board meetings.
- test6554 8y agoOr we might see employers paying for "professionalism" and "workplace etiquette" training. People can be taught that it's not just what they do, but also how they do it that makes them valuable. It just costs some money.
- smelendez 8y agoThe other challenging issue is that what training people need changes over time, and I think it's hard for people to pick up on that versus thinking they just hired poorly. For example, younger workers now may have never answered a shared phone line outside of a work setting, so they may need phone training previous generations would have gotten at home.
- ancap 8y agoThat's because wages aren't flat. All of the studies which claim wages are flat make one or more methodological errors. The errors primarily being 1) using different price deflators when calculating price inflation vs wage inflation and 2) not including the value of benefits in their calculation of wages. Studies which avoid those methodological errors have shown that wages have kept pace with inflation.
- pwinnski 8y agoWages keeping pace with inflation, but not rising above, are "flat."
- ancap 8y agoI think there's some confusion here because often when talking about "flat" or "stagnant" wages people are referring to the idea that inflation outpaces wage increases (which is wrong, and the point I was addressing). But even taking into account how you're referring to "flat" wages, the logic is still wrong. If we take a worker today who earns the same wage, in inflation adjusted dollars, as a worker in, say, 1985, today's worker has a hugely increased standard of living, better healthcare, longer life expectancy, etc.
- AlexandrB 8y ago> If we take a worker today who earns the same wage, in inflation adjusted dollars, as a worker in, say, 1985, today's worker has a hugely increased standard of living, better healthcare, longer life expectancy, etc. Is this actually true? In the US, healthcare costs in particular have outpaced inflation meaning that a worker earning the same in inflation-adjusted dollars is getting worse care. This is backed up by the fact that life expectancy has started to decline[1]. Finally, saying that "you're better off than 1985" does not address the fact that the economy has not just kept pace with inflation. That growth is going somewhere and it's not into the wages of the middle class. Inequality is not just bad for the people at the bottom. It has a tendency to destabilize politics as people realize that the game is rigged and swing towards the political extremes. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2017/12/21/health/us-life-expectancy-study/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2017/12/21/health/us-life-expectancy-stu...