6 ms·
>500px says that it reached out to Creative Commons in May, and explained at the time that the reason for the shift was that they weren’t seeing a lot of activi
by whatshisface 8y ago
>500px says that it reached out to Creative Commons in May, and explained at the time that the reason for the shift was that they weren’t seeing a lot of activity with Creative Commons images, that they still had a number of bugs when it came to searching for such images, and they only had outdated licenses for photographers. In short, there’s not enough activity for 500px to justify continuing it.
What? That doesn't make any sense. Creative Commons is not some kind of million page regulation that requires constant maintenance - it's just an option in a dropdown, or even just a note in the description. There has to be some hidden motivation behind disallowing it, although I can't imagine what that motivation could be.
- rbanffy 8y ago> I can't imagine what that motivation could be. Last time I checked, their revenue came from members. If they plan to act as middle-men, this move makes sense if they see CC as a no-profit scenario.
- djsumdog 8y agoYep. Same reason YouTube wanted to pull the Blender videos. Very popular content that's freely licensed costs them money. Hosting isn't free. We need more distributed platforms where everyone who views the content can help serve it to their neighbours as well.
- wmil 8y agoStripe just cut off Bitchute, so distributed platforms are facing some clear hostility from Silicon Valley insiders.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoDecentralization is great for disrupting existing incumbents, and has the added benefit of creating an opportunity for a company to re-centralize the culture. GitHub is a great example of this, as are the many attempts to chip away at email
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoGitHub is a great example of decentralization? In what way? I view GitHub as a centralized service.
- cwyers 8y ago> has the added benefit of creating an opportunity for a company to re-centralize the culture
- rgbrenner 8y agosilicon valley and stripe don't live in a bubble separate from the rest of the world. The credit card processing rules against file sharing sites like Bitchute were imposed by visa et al several years ago. They sent out a notice to everyone years ago.. I remember reading it. It really is out of stripe's hands if stripe wants to stay in business. If you want to start a company like that you can't use credit cards. They have to use bitcoin, etc. These were the rules years before Bitchute even wrote the first line of their code.
- cannonedhamster 8y agoBitchute is also primarily far right wing/white power vloggers and conspiracy believers. That's probably a second reason that they would get cut off by an established player. They would really need to diversify their user base to become more palatable.
- ckdarby 8y agoI am not up to times, what are the Blender videos?
- Haydos585x2 8y agoBlender is a 3D model tool and they have a lot of free video content showing users how to use the software. YouTube wanted to monetize the content but Blender repeatedly said no. YouTube then wanted them off the platform and Blender moved themselves to PeerTube. The story has a bit more nuance than that but that's a simplified run down.
- larkeith 8y agoTo be specific: YouTube blocked all of Blender's videos, globally, and only restored them after Blender published a blog post on it and moved to PeerTube.
- fapjacks 8y ago... While also silently pushing their "service agreement" across the table. That agreement explicitly enables ads from which Google takes 45% of the revenue. [0] [0] http://download.blender.org/institute/Contract%20between%20Google%20and%20Blender%20Foundation.pdf http://download.blender.org/institute/Contract%20between%20G...
- jonknee 8y agoGoogle takes 45% of the revenue that they go out and get for you while they cover 100% of all expenses... Not the worst deal I've heard of. Seems like a better deal than app stores that take 30% of the revenue that you go out and get yourself.
- fapjacks 8y ago... Is this reply for real? This is absurd and disingenuous. Google is one of those 30% app stores. Google/Youtube also absolutely does not cover 100% of the expenses and certainly doesn't "go out and get for you" the revenue. Google/Youtube doesn't pay anybody shit for creating the content that populates their network. Google should be on its knees thanking these content creators, not clubbing the altruistic creators of free software over the head with their insidious racket. This must be what it's like talking to Apple fanboys about paying double for overpriced garbage hardware.
- neotek 8y ago>Same reason YouTube wanted to pull the Blender videos. What? Blender was a victim to The Algorithm, not to some nefarious plot by YouTube to rid itself of the billions upon billions of free and unmonetised videos currently hosted on its platform.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoThat doesn't make it any better for YouTube.
- neotek 8y agoOf course it does, don't be ridiculous. The difference between a faceless, directionless algorithm miscategorising videos and performing actions without direct oversight from a human being, and an underhanded (and, frankly, nonsensical) plot to rid the site of one particular set of videos out of the literally billions and billions of free videos that already exist on the site is palpably obvious.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoThe difference is certainly worth knowing, but it doesn't affect the situation one bit for anyone who wants to watch those videos but can't.
- Buge 8y agoIt does effect the people who want to watch those videos, because once the humans at youtube are alerted about the problem, the videos are put back up, as in the case of the blender videos. But if it was an intentional human takedown, the videos wouldn't be put back up. It also has implications on the future of all other videos. If it's actually an intentional plan to take down free videos, then that means we can expect the people who made this decision on blender to continue their plan and take down other free videos. But if it's an algorithm mistake, we don't expect it to become more widespread, and hopefully the algorithm will be tweaked so that it will actually become less widespread. This thread is about a company (500px) intentionally taking down free content for business purposes to make more money. Saying that youtube is doing the same thing is false.
- zodiakzz 8y agoHow come Khan Academy are allowed on YouTube then?
- phoe-krk 8y agoPerhaps they allowed monetization?
- ReverseCold 8y agoGoogle funds KA (https://www.google.org/our-work/education/khan-academy/ https://www.google.org/our-work/education/khan-academy/). Also, most KA videos have views in the thousands (usually less than 10k). Most Blender videos have views in the tens/hundreds of thousands. (Also I would like to point out that I don't think anyone at Google had an evil plan to delete Blender, it was probably "The Computer".)
- gregknicholson 8y agoThe Computer is Google's most valuable employee.
- lettergram 8y agoSeems like all around a poor decision.
- sandov 8y agoBasically the same thing that Youtube did to Blender and MIT: Monetize your videos or we're taking them down.
- dublinben 8y agoAs discussed previously[0], 500px has been purchased by a major Chinese photography licensing company. They are now migrating their entire catalog to be used for commercial licensing. Any photos which can't be exploited in this way are not welcome on their platform any longer. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16467347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16467347
- waitnoemail 8y agoA Chinese company making money via licensing and copyright has got to be the sweetest irony I have ever seen.
- ycombinete 8y agoThe ironies and weirdnesses in Chinese economics are so common as to be banal
- coldtea 8y agoSo, just like with an American company today? The US was a notorious "copyright breaker" back when it was bootstrapping... E.g.: The U.S. was long a net importer of literary and artistic works, especially from England, which implied that recognition of foreign copyrights would have led to a net deficit in international royalty payments. The Copyright Act recognized this when it specified that “nothing in this act shall be construed to extend to prohibit the importation or vending, reprinting or publishing within the United States, of any map, chart, book or books … by any person not a citizen of the United States.” Thus, the statutes explicitly authorized Americans to take free advantage of the cultural output of other countries. As a result, it was alleged that American publishers “indiscriminately reprinted books by foreign authors without even the pretence of acknowledgement.” The tendency to reprint foreign works was encouraged by the existence of tariffs on imported books that ranged as high as 25 percent. The United States stood out in contrast to countries such as France, where Louis Napoleon’s Decree of 1852 prohibited counterfeiting of both foreign and domestic works. Other countries which were affected by American piracy retaliated by refusing to recognize American copyrights. Despite the lobbying of numerous authors and celebrities on both sides of the Atlantic, the American copyright statutes did not allow for copyright protection of foreign works for fully one century. As a result, American publishers and producers freely pirated foreign literature, art, and drama. https://eh.net/encyclopedia/an-economic-history-of-copyright-in-europe-and-the-united-states/ https://eh.net/encyclopedia/an-economic-history-of-copyright... So, that's like a parent telling a high schooler not to drink, when they had a fake id and everything in their age...
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoif a feature isn't beneficial to your platform and you can remove the code that implements that feature, well, removing code is beneficial.