4 ms·
We just need a carbon tax that appropriately prices the pollution in. Just set up a market where people can trade carbon and companies can make money by sequest
by adrianN 8y ago
We just need a carbon tax that appropriately prices the pollution in. Just set up a market where people can trade carbon and companies can make money by sequestering carbon out of the atmosphere.
- gmueckl 8y agoSequestration should not be part of a market for CO2 certificates. Sure, you could earn money by sequestering CO2 and selling certificates generated by the process. But you will have to buy them back when the CO2 leaks. And it should diffuse out of the atirahe over time, albeit slowly. So you might eventually have to buy back the certificates instead of earning the money required to maintain the filled up CO2 storage for, well, virtually forever.
- vpribish 8y agothat sure seems like it's workable though. take the money, invest it, pay out later. like a bank, or an insurance company.
- Fjolsvith 8y agoSo a company that plants trees could earn money under this system?
- strommen 8y agoA company that converts clear-cut land to forest could earn money. There is an entire sector of the economy dedicated to voluntary carbon offsets, and re-forestation efforts are the primary supply. People and companies use these as a sort of carbon tax to offset the emissions they cause by taking airline flights, hosting events, or just living their daily lives.
- tengbretson 8y agoTrees are not a form of permanent sequestration.
- mchannon 8y agoTrees are a step that can either lead to permanent sequestration, or can lead to open-cycle sequestration, both of which are better than nothing. The carbon in a tree can get pulled out of the equation for decades while it grows, and partly slow-released as it rots on the forest floor, and partly adapted into the soil, some of which will eventually become a sequestered fossil fuel deposit. Alternatively, part of the tree can become food, or lumber, or paper, and whatever those eventually decay into may be, at least in part, things other than methane and CO2, safe in the ground as permanent sequestration. Trees aren't a panacea, but they're a tool we dare not discount out of hand.
- adrianN 8y agoYou can cut them down, turn them into charcoal and bury the coal. It is then sequestered for at least a few hundred years, likely much longer.
- amluto 8y agoIt’s not at all clear to me why carbon trading is useful. If a ton of CO2 emission is taxed $5 and a ton of capture is credited $5, what’s the point of trading certificates?
- phamilton 8y agoMy understanding is that with hard caps on CO2 emissions, a market rate for carbon will emerge. In other words, if you can buy a maximum of 100 tons of CO2 emission for $5/ton via a government agency, then at some point you'll have to buy credits from other parties, and that'll command a premium.
- earthboundkid 8y agoIt helps ensure that the financial sector controls everything in our economic system by giving them an excess of money that they can use to buy politicians.
- stevesimmons 8y ago... because the people doing the emitting are different from the people doing the capturing?
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoHow I understand it is this: Everyone creates 100 units of pollution together, say ten firms producing 10 units each. Then they say, you can only use 90 next year, 70 the next decade, 50 the decade after. Everyone needs to reduce pollution a bit, this is hard. Some have a 50 year investment in a factory that they can't remodel to pollute less. They'd need to shut down. Others are more flexible, they can remodel existing infrastructure, or shut down ones that are near the end of their lifetime. But why would they make investments in something more clean? Trading means one firm producing 10 units can invest in efficiency. Next year it's allowed to produce 9, but its new tech only produces 5. It can sell the other 4 to four factories which couldn't reduce their emissions from 10 to 9. Over time the polluting parties have funded the non-polluting parties' clean technology, while over time the total pollution has gone down. Moreover, it'll incentivise the lowest-hanging fruit approach, i.e. reduce emissions where it's cheapest to do so, first. That's why it's called cap-and-trade, not just trade.
- skosch 8y agoFortunately, the political will for carbon pricing is growing. The one obstacle is that conservative politicians are scared of using the word "tax" – so the current strategy is to push for a bill that would return all of the money to citizens ("carbon dividends" are an easier sell than "carbon taxes"). Here are the biggest organizations pushing for this — support them if you can: – https://citizensclimatelobby.org/ https://citizensclimatelobby.org/ (strictly bipartisan) – https://www.clcouncil.org/ https://www.clcouncil.org/ and their PAC, https://twitter.com/afcdividends https://twitter.com/afcdividends (conservative/industry-backed) – https://allianceformarketsolutions.org/ https://allianceformarketsolutions.org/ (conservative) – https://www.s4cd.org/ https://www.s4cd.org/ (campus-based)