2 ms·
Your post describes the logical error that the prisoner can claim that "he is surprised" or "he is not surprised" (ie. "extected it"). He cannot, in honesty, cl
by Fnoord 8y ago
Your post describes the logical error that the prisoner can claim that "he is surprised" or "he is not surprised" (ie. "extected it"). He cannot, in honesty, claim he wasn't surprised on the first 4 days. He can pretend that he was surprised, sure, and if he could get away with it thereby winning: by all means, all the good to him. But logically, he cannot for certain claim that he isn't surprised" because he cannot dismiss the other possible options. If you follow that logical route, he's only allowed once to claim he's surprised.
> The simple reality is that the judge can only promise you a surprise Monday thru Thursday.
Which means that the execution is on either monday/tuesday/wednesday/thursday but you don't know which one.
That'd result in a 1 in 4 (25%) chance of being right, if he's allowed to vote once. Which day he'd vote on, could be related to how much patience or how nervous he is, how eager he wants to live perhaps?