3 ms·
The presumption to all these discussions is, that we're actually capable of detecting intelligent life if its out there. Which is probably silly. We're looking
by JoeAltmaier 8y ago
The presumption to all these discussions is, that we're actually capable of detecting intelligent life if its out there. Which is probably silly. We're looking for radio waves. If we were talking about this in the 1800's, we'd be looking for what? Telegraph signals?
In future, spacefaring civilizations will use something other than broadcast EM fields to communicate. Maybe soliton lasers through the interstellar plasma. Maybe highly encrypted light bursts that are actually indistinguishable from noise (like, you know, the internet does now). And our chance of intercepting point-to-point signals depends entirely on our planet wandering into the path of one of these signals (if they were so stupid as to even send it where they knew Earth would be later). And recognizing it as a signal. And we're way out on the edge of things, so not actually between anybody and anybody else.
Maybe, its a silent galaxy because nobody is talking to us.
- armada651 8y agoThe Drake equation assumes there are no limits to technology and that without some kind of great filter the Universe would be so permeated with advanced civilizations that signs of their existence is inescapable. I find it more likely that the speed of light is the great filter and that interstellar travel is so difficult that the rare instances of life are unlikely to leave their star system never mind their galaxy group (which would require faster-than-light travel).