4 ms·
It's very easy to reconcile the child/adult treatment: If they wish to continue to follow traditional rules that lie outside what modern society accepts, they
by wodenokoto 8y ago
It's very easy to reconcile the child/adult treatment:
If they wish to continue to follow traditional rules that lie outside what modern society accepts, they cannot be part of modern society.
If they want to trade, share ideas and generally meet with the rest of the world, they must reconcile their traditions with things like human rights.
You might argue that China is not following human rights and they are a major player internally,but these tribes do not wield power like China does, and would be powerless against Brazilian authorities.
A good question, however, is who gets to make that deciSoon to include or exclude these tribes from modern society.
- dullgiulio 8y agoThe other big question is the role of the individual in these societies. If we are not relativistic about ethics we might think that being born in a society doesn't have to determine the way you live forever. This is a big can of worms. The simpler solution we know of is the Paradox of Tolerance, and regarding tolerance itself as more important than, for example, preserving tradition.
- hrktb 8y ago> If they want to trade, share ideas and generally meet with the rest of the world From what I get, they don't want that. In a sense I am fine with their reclusion, what's bugging me is the enforcement of a status quo in regard to their tradition. Even without external influence, it should evolve, and rules should naturally adapt to their environment. I mean, even their current tradition didn't fall fully formed from the sky, and some of the reasoning behind it is explained clearly (for instance population control). They must have started from a pragmatic point of view to build these traditions, and it seems the thinking process behind these just vanished or got "vanished" by people with an agenda going beyond preserving culture. I am thinking about the mormons, who aren't as secluse, but also think by themselves about what they want to ingest and what they won't embrace. Nobody's there saying "you don't have the right to go see mormons and tell them things, it would disturb them".