3 ms·
> As long as no one is getting hurt, why can't a company choose its target demographic? They can, as long as they're not using public resources or imposing sig
by wpietri 8y ago
> As long as no one is getting hurt, why can't a company choose its target demographic?
They can, as long as they're not using public resources or imposing significant negative externalities. On the other hand, if you want to be part of the municipal transportation infrastructure, the stated goal of these scooter companies, cities may want a quid pro quo for that.
- rayiner 8y agoIf that is the rationale (it isn’t), then the externalities should be priced in fairly for everyone, including those driving private cars. Otherwise you distort the market.
- wpietri 8y agoI would encourage you to propose that you your rep, of course, as I'm all for better pricing of externalities. But there are a number of important differences between a person driving a private car for personal use and a company operating a business. An important one being that the business can possibly monetize the externalities, while individuals living their lives generally don't. As an example, when I park my bike at a municipal rack, I don't make any money directly from that. I at most use one space, and on average use zero. But if I can make a profit from putting a rental bike at a municipal rack, I have an incentive to consume as many spaces as are profitable. On average I might use hundreds.
- mmt 8y agoYou bring up an important distinction. I'd like to coin a term: externality arbitrage. Although an individual might be able to extract value, as you point out, the scale would be small. A business, especially a VC-funded one, is much more likely to be able to scale this on a massive level, across many markets.