3 ms·
A few years ago, there were several promising alternative mobile operating systems. WebOs, Ubuntu mobile, SailfishOS, Tizen (a continuation of Nokia's Maemo/Mee
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
A few years ago, there were several promising alternative mobile operating systems. WebOs, Ubuntu mobile, SailfishOS, Tizen (a continuation of Nokia's Maemo/Meego), and of course Firefox OS. Nokia also had another in house OS that was killed off before it got a chance to ship called Meltemi.
Most of these had a few things in common:
- they were linux based
- they were aimed at cheaper form factors where Android made less sense
- (mostly) web based development kits
- all of them struggled to get traction/market share
- at the core of their failures was the success off the android and apple app stores.
So, what has changed? App stores are less relevant than ever. People still install apps of course but mostly apps are struggling to compete for attention. It requires a huge marketing budgets to get anywhere near the top hundred of apps and if you are not in there, people won't find you. So, a good mobile web experience is key for a lot of services out there and with stuff like progressive web apps (which Firefox OS sort of pioneered) you can get away with not having a fully native app. Many 'native' apps are in fact partially web based these days.
So, KaiOs makes sense. Android is still expensive to run and producing hardware platforms in volume based on chipsets that were considered state of the art ten years ago is really cheap. Android never really ran well on those. Which is why you see these operating systems targeting cheap platforms. Web based development kits make total sense. Of course, mobile linux makes a lot of sense since it basically runs on all of these platforms and there is a huge existing investment in things like drivers.
Google investing in this also makes total sense. Android is not going to run well on these devices but they still want people to buy into the Google eco system. Fuchsia is not aimed at this space either and instead intended to replace Android, eventually. It may scale down better than Android of course but everything I'm reading about it suggests that's not the main goal. So investing in this is a low risk, high reward type situation for Google.
Apple of course never really cared about low end. The margins are too small for them. They only do high margin products.
- throwaway412432 8y agoSailfish had its chance with Intex. They hugely underestimated the opportunity they had with the launch of Jio, and pushed off on supporting VOLTE. Sailfish tanked despite being a great OS on a relatively cheap handset (< $100); lost the opportunity to gain a foothold.
- pjmlp 8y agoSymbian already had a Web runtime. In 10 years we will still be discussing how web will replace native apps, unless the browser has been rebooted into a general purpose VM running WebAssembly apps. I keep seeing this issue how it is hard to get attention in the store, the Web is no different. Other than whatever calls my attention on HN and Reddit, I only use the same 10 sites since the last decade.