3 ms·
Since I first got interested in science, I've been presented a number of times with this idea (that lifting things in orbit is subject to very simple physics th
by ur-whale 8y ago
Since I first got interested in science, I've been presented a number of times with this idea (that lifting things in orbit is subject to very simple physics that have harsh economic implications).
I've always felt uneasy about this, as it seems to imply that the only way to put things in orbit is via rockets.
For example, there is the idea of a space crane (assuming it can be built) that is simply a very, very tall building, assembled one chunk at a time, and that once built can simply lift things in orbit.
Would a space crane be slave to the same equations?
- frahs 8y agoMost of the energy of getting a rocket to orbit is in achieving orbital velocity, not orbital altitude :/. Unless you accelerate your satellite really really fast, it'll just fall back to the earth.
- ohazi 8y agoIf you could build a proper space elevator, a payload could be lifted to the geostationary point and then released. At that point it's already at orbital velocity, and can use much less fuel (compared to an Earth launched rocket) to get back down to low earth orbit. But again, this is still a materials science problem.
- ohazi 8y agoNo, it wouldn't, but "assuming it can be built" is a pretty tall order. We don't really know how to reliably manufacture materials that can sustain the loads required for something like this.
- watersb 8y ago> a pretty tall order . . .
- ur-whale 8y agoYes, I do understand that we have an unsolved material science problem for the space elevator, but my question was more theoretical (hence the "assuming that") and boiled down to: "doesn't the hypothetical space elevator break the tyranny of the rocket equation?" (which you did answer).
- ChuckMcM 8y ago> Would a space crane be slave to the same equations? No it would not, it has its own cross to bear, tensile strength. If you start from the ground, then as the crane gets taller, the forces on its outer edges are the torque applied when a lateral force pushes against it (think wind). As with a stubborn nut, the longer the wrench handle the more force you can apply to the nut. If you think of the crane as your wrench handle, the taller it gets, the more force it will exert on its mounts when air moves past it. (this it true of sky scrapers as well). Eventually you move past the point where there is anything that can stay vertical (steels rip and bend, carbon fiber breaks, Etc.) There is a working solution, a pyramid, but to build a pyramid that reached low earth orbit requires a base that is larger than the state of Kansas and will sink down to bedrock. There is an entertaining discussion of this from 2011 here: https://www.wired.com/2011/07/does-the-slope-of-a-pyramid-really-matter/ https://www.wired.com/2011/07/does-the-slope-of-a-pyramid-re... We know from the Himalayas you can stack up a lot of rock into a really really tall mountain, but its really really a lot. This might occur naturally on some planet, Olympus Mons on Mars is 16 miles high (about 85,000 ft or almost 26 km) that is 25% of the way up to space (assuming the 100km is your line for 'space'). Eventually you hit the limit which is that gravity prevents you from having a feature stick out too far from a sphere. Another way to do this is to put a weight in geosynchronous orbit so it stays over the same spot all the time. If you start building a cable downward and adding mass further out you can keep the "effective" mass at the geosyncronous point. Eventually, (materials science not withstanding) the part you are lowering down to the planet reaches the surface and voila you have your jack and the beanstalk type beanstalk. As fantastical as that sounds, it should actually work, if, and it is a big if, you can make a material that can withstand the tensile force of being both pulled up from the counter weight, and down by gravity. Once built you could attach a vehicle that would ride up and down the cable moving things from ground level into geosynchronous orbit, with only the energy needed to climb up the cable. These "space elevators" are not precluded by physics so they show up in science fiction stories. But once you get away from building structures you are left with either chemical rockets or some how pushing against the Earth. Creative ideas there are balloons that take you part of the way up, and electrostatic systems that use an electric field to push against the charge on the Earth. These ideas start off far fetched and move right into crazysauce fairly quickly.
- colechristensen 8y agoTo get into a circular orbit with a crane you have to build a space crane as tall as the circumference of earth. The tallest structure ever built by humans is a little more than half a mile tall. A space elevator to geostationary orbit (required for a circular orbit with no rockets) would have to be 22,000 miles tall. Low earth orbit is a lot closer, what is considered LEO is pretty wide, but the ISS is at about 250 miles. If you get an crane ride up 250 miles, you aren't orbiting. You haven't even done half of the work, to be in orbit at that altitude means you have to accelerate to several miles per second. How orbital mechanics works is not very intuitive.
- Symmetry 8y agoA space elevator that goes all the way from the surface of the Earth to orbit would be very hard to build on Earth because Earth's gravity well is so deep - though it's pretty easy on the Moon. Something more feasible would be a Skyhook[1] which only provides part of the energy needed to get to space but which due to the exponential nature of the rocket equation could make a huge difference while being conceivable to build. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_(structure) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_(structure)
- wingspar 8y agoRead this space elevator book years ago, it was very interesting. I’m sure it needs an update after 15 years. https://www.amazon.com/Space-Elevator-Earth-Space-Transportation/dp/0974651710 https://www.amazon.com/Space-Elevator-Earth-Space-Transporta...