3 ms·
How are protests or account deletion a threat to free speech at all? Neither is government-sponsored. In fact, you could argue that the former is the healthy e
by smt88 8y ago
How are protests or account deletion a threat to free speech at all? Neither is government-sponsored.
In fact, you could argue that the former is the healthy exercise of the protestors' freedom of speech, and the latter is the exercise of a corporation's freedom of speech.
"Freedom of speech" != other people helping you broadcast your message or letting it go unchallenged
- snerbles 8y agoWhile some may agree with your defense of the heckler's veto [0], constraining the discussion of freedom of expression to government-conducted censorship is disingenuous. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler's_veto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler's_veto
- smt88 8y agoAgain, that only applies to public spaces. Not all protesters are at public universities. There is no (and never has been) an unequivocal right to free speech in a private space. Also, constraining the discussion of freedom of expression to government-conducted censorship is not disingenuous. It's the only context in which freedom of expression is guaranteed in the US.
- snerbles 8y agoYou are conflating implementation with philosophy. While the First Amendment is one such implementation of the notion of free speech, it is not the philosophy of freedom of expression itself.
- smt88 8y agoI'm not conflating those things. Don't put words in my mouth. I'm only talking about implementation. Philosophical discussion of free speech is a much broader scope and not, to my understanding, what anyone else was talking about in this thread. If they were talking about philosophy, then it wasn't clear to me and this became an argument of semantics.
- watwut 8y ago1.) Threat to free s peach does not have to be governmental. 2.) I agree that protests themselves are free speech and necessary part of functional society. Absolutely, people have right to loudly disagree with highly paid speakers and demagogues and pundits and politicians and what not. 3.) There are many people who don't believe 2. in particular when protesters are from opposite "side". Even if you see protest as something outside of free speech, murder is bigger threat. 4.) Murdering someone is large non-govermental threat to freedom. That point stands absolutely. "You are not careful enough if you criticise troll" is slimmy way to create situation in which you are totally for freedom, but also if they do exercise they are irresponsible and brought dead on themselves. Slimmy. 5.) I did not downvoted you.