9 ms·
OSM is orders of magnitude worse than Apple's current data set in my area, and I doubt that's unusual. So the question for Apple is why tie themselves to a 3rd
by macintux 8y ago
OSM is orders of magnitude worse than Apple's current data set in my area, and I doubt that's unusual.
So the question for Apple is why tie themselves to a 3rd party platform? If they're going to go to this massive level of effort to generate the best data set they can achieve, they'll want to control the full stack for quality and predictability.
They could feed the OSM-relevant data they create to the platform, but that means a lot more work to create and maintain the integration tools and manage the workflow, along with potentially reduced revenues if they make OSM too good.
I doubt they'll care about any threat from OSM, but I doubt they'd see the overall effort as a good business investment. This isn't as straightforward as open sourcing some software.
- saturn_vk 8y agoYou could fix your spotty coverage yourself. The areas I've been at had exceptional detail.
- macintux 8y agoI spent some time starting to do so, but the gaps are cavernous, and I decided I had I other priorities.
- __sr__ 8y agoYeah, I’ve nothing better to do than roam around fixing maps. It’s not like I have a daily job or anything. /s It the same argument when someone talks about an issue with an open source software. The response is, “The source code is available, go fix it yourself.” It doesn’t work that way for anything but trivial issues.
- 394549 8y ago> Yeah, I’ve nothing better to do than roam around fixing maps. It’s not like I have a daily job or anything. /s No one said it has to be your job or passion. I've fixed a couple of areas in OSM, but I've probably spent no more than a few hours working on it in total. > It the same argument when someone talks about an issue with an open source software. The response is, “The source code is available, go fix it yourself.” It doesn’t work that way for anything but trivial issues. Fixing a map for a locale you're familiar with is orders of magnitude easier than fixing a bug in an unfamiliar codebase potentially built with unfamiliar technology. That's assuming you know how to code in the first place.
- __sr__ 8y ago> No one said it has to be your job or passion. I've fixed a couple of areas in OSM, but I've probably spent not more than a few hours working on it in total. That doesn’t work unless everyone else is doing it. And for that to work, everyone should be using it in the first place. It’s a catch 22 problem. To be fair, it is possible that people do this where you live - which may be a reason why it is usable there, but I have not found that to be the case at the places I have visited. Perhaps it is not as complicated as fixing a software bug, but the idea is same - the data is available publically, go fix it.
- macintux 8y agoIt's not as complicated as fixing a software bug, but it's not trivial for the first-time user either. Create an account, figure out how to navigate the interface, figure out what rules apply to your update, apply update, get reprimanded because you followed the explicit rule for "I'm not quite sure what to do with this".
- 394549 8y ago> That doesn’t work unless everyone else is doing it. And for that to work, everyone should be using it in the first place. It’s a catch 22 problem. If that were actually true, Wikipedia would be no more than four stub articles written by Jimmy Wales. The real barrier is people looking at a volunteer project and asking themselves "how can I take from this what I want?" rather than "how can I contribute to this, even in a small way?" No one says anyone has to take on the herculean task of totally fixing all the problems they see in their area. But if you spend a little time fixing something, it will get better and perhaps even attain a high enough quality to satisfy you.
- JimDabell 8y agoThe most likely time for somebody to notice a problem is a) when they are on the move, and b) when it's a location unfamiliar to them. These are terrible circumstances to expect somebody to stop what they are doing and edit a map.
- yardie 8y agoI’ve made minimal corrections in OSM. It is nothing like working on code. If you can draw a line, point and click then even you can make difference.
- rmc 8y agoWith code you need to be able to programme. For OSM you just need to know something about an area. Do you know what the name of that street is? That there's an italian restaurant on that corner? What the house number of that building is? etc etc
- Animats 8y agoI've fixed a few things in Open Street Map. But, for example, the city line for Redwood City CA at its western edge is totally bogus. That needs to be fixed by automatic reference to some authoritative source, like the USGS database.
- rickycook 8y agoi think there was an article a while ago about the OSM community not liking the idea of bots and automation, and how it’s a big problem for people “graffitiing” the maps because it’s manual effort to reset
- maxerickson 8y agoIt's not so much vandalism that is the issue, it's that rampant automatic edits can end up removing meaning from the data (by smoothing out meaningful differences and the like) or if they aren't careful enough, create a giant mess.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ambicapter 8y ago"The problem with open source software is that you have to fix it yourself". Unreal.
- specialist 8y agoOne of my besties is the OSM guru & evangelist (day job) and Ingress fanatic (that annoying friend). He tried to dream up some notions to gamify improving OSM's data. While their current data quality trends are remarkable, better is better, right? (I don't have the gumption to find & link their conf proceedings slidedeck right now, sorry.) I have interest and experience with GIS, location-based stuff, games. So we tried to brain storm some game ideas. Sadly, we got nothing. But I'm confident someone will divine a MineCraft-esque smash hit game. Something simple, fun, engaging, cultural, that with 20/20 hindsight will leave a lot of people facepalming. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingress_(video_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingress_(video_game)
- pythonaut_16 8y agoI think it's kinda like Google working with Android as an open source project. Google makes money on Android primarily by using Android as a means of delivering the Google ecosystem. They don't care that it's open source because they don't make money by selling it. Apple could do the same thing with maps. Support a robust open mapping initiative to make sure their primary business (selling iPhones and other devices) has a solid platform for emerging technologies like AR. Making sure they have a solid maps offering supports the Apple (aka iPhone) ecosystem. Also similarly to Google, they can still push plenty of proprietary things on top of the open parts of the initiative.
- borgel 8y agoPlus it seems like this would weaken Google's partial stranglehold on the market is a side effect.
- oblio 8y agoCommoditize your complement.
- mikejarema 8y agoI like that line, is it yours or does it have some further history/examples behind it?
- mkl 8y agoIt's been around for a while. Here it is talked about by Joel Spolsky in 2002: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/ Gwern's article about it was recently discussed here on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17047348 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17047348
- gxs 8y agoThis is a great idea. I hope someone at Apple is reading. Makes perfect sense, they don't need to make money on it, just an alternative to google.
- Doctor_Fegg 8y ago> OSM is orders of magnitude worse than Apple's current data set in my area, and I doubt that's unusual. As ever, define "worse" and "my area". OSM is consistently worse worldwide (compared to Google, TomTom and Here) for geocoding. OSM is consistently worse for lane guidance. OSM is generally worse than Google worldwide for commercial POIs (shops, restaurants etc.), but on a par with TomTom and Here, and this is very location-dependent. OSM is better worldwide, by several orders of magnitude, for pedestrian and bicycle mapping. OSM is generally better for non-commercial POIs. OSM is very often better in all aspects (save geocoding) in rural locations, particularly in Europe. If you're an American motorist then Google is your best map right now. If you're a European cyclist then OSM is really the only game in town. It's not a black-and-white issue.
- yetanother1980 8y agoI was about to respond to the GP asking for details because where I am and as mainly a pedestrian and cyclist OSM is really the only decent solution (unless you like walking 30minutes in a large circle rather than 5).
- rubyn00bie 8y agoI think Apple sponsoring and improving OSM would actually be the smartest and best way out of this debacle. I think a perfect example of Apple doing this is: Webkit. Webkit gets back a lot from Apple (though I'm sure there's plenty of room to be miffed at Apple for being slow sometimes, but it still doesn't disprove the point) and it's a core part of their user-facing applications. Personally, I'd like to see them just open source what they have and let the world enjoy. Either approach would certainly remove the death grip Google has on mapping solutions right now. Edit: update for grammar and clarity fixes.
- krick 8y ago> Apple sponsoring and improving OSM would actually be the smartest and best way out of this debacle I like to be thinking that, but being aware of me liking that thought, I'm asking myself: would I actually do so being some Apple executive? And I'm not sure I would. I do think that being community-supported is really, really great, and OSM has a pretty good community too. I'm a big opensource proponent, so it's easy for me to say, but I also think having their maps (software and data) free (as in GNU, yeah) wouldn't harm Apple, given the map is not their unique product they are selling. And being a native supporter of something that could be wikipedia for maps would be huge. So, yeah… yay OSM? But, with all that said: IMO, OSM is a huge organizational mess. Giving them money & satellites, and then just expecting it will all "solve itself out" isn't really something I would do being responsible for Apple Maps. For starters, it's not like all OSM community members automatically become Apple employees, you're basically donating to somebody over whom you won't have any leverage. What's more important, it's not clear what it the goal of the donation, what OSM is expected to do with that? And how it will serve Apple? Their priorities seem to be quite off, OSM doesn't give a shit about any "product" whatsoever, they are just guys passionate about collecting all sorts of geo-data into databases nobody ever uses (at least, as far as OSM is concerned, they are the database: they don't make apps). And it's even questinable if such way of collecting data is the way to go in the age of imaging satellites, widely accepted spyware on every phone, ML and "big data". And it's not like this is cheap, any way it would be done. And, no offense, but "partnering" with OSM wouldn't be exactly partnering. OSM doesn't have managers, engineers or cartographers any better than Apple can hire, all they have is community, which wouldn't even be OSM community anymore, if Apple rolls out a better (and more accessible) open geo-spatial DB than OSM has. Which, I believe, they are capable of.
- hrktb 8y agoFor me the issue is more that they don’t seem to be able to pull it off. Sure if they could have a super high quality dataset they build themselves it would be stupid to share it, but they don’t have that data, and I wouldn’t bet on them to have it even putting all their weight in the effort. There is also the issue of motivation for the user to give feedback. If I do it in Google Maps I know it will benefit most users. In OSM it’s a pure gift to the community. Apple Maps ? it’s less clearcut.
- untog 8y agoThe key part in what you said is "my area". There are a great many areas in which Apple Maps is fantastic - usually well-populated cities or surrounding areas in the US. The reason to partner with OSM would be to cover the other 99% of landmass. It's very, very difficult to scale an operation like that otherwise.