5 ms·
I'll quote my reply from a similar comment... What choice do they have? Maps, location data, and the services they enable are critical to mobile devices today,
by macintux 8y ago
I'll quote my reply from a similar comment...
What choice do they have? Maps, location data, and the services they enable are critical to mobile devices today, and will only get more so with AR and devices without screens.
“Everybody but Google” isn’t good enough judging by the current state of affairs, and Google doesn’t play by the same privacy rules as Apple, so they seem to have few options.
- tibbon 8y ago> What choice do they have? Perhaps this would be too risky, but they could license it from Google?
- creyes 8y agoMake a trade maybe? Google already pays Apple a significant amount to be the default search engine
- macintux 8y agoThey did, originally, but Google reportedly wasn't willing to give them everything they wanted without sharing more user data in return. This seems better for consumers in the long run: better to have two maps apps on the device, both attempting to be comprehensive and accurate.
- puzzle 8y agoOriginally, they couldn't license the actual data, either, because at least the road network wasn't Google's to license. It came from TeleAtlas (after Nokia had bought NavTeq), Zenrin for Japan and a few more. Things were tricky like that before the Ground Truth project (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsbLEtS0uls https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsbLEtS0uls) covered enough of the planet. When Google launched navigation on Android, it lost money in countries not covered by Ground Truth, which I think was everywhere outside the US. That's because TeleAtlas and co. charged N times as much when the same data was used for real time directions.
- IBM 8y agoThat's what the relationship was before Google withheld turn by turn directions and wanted more data than Apple was willing to give [1]: >But multiple sources familiar with Apple’s thinking say the company felt it had no choice but to replace Google Maps with its own, because of a disagreement over a key feature: Voice-guided turn-by-turn driving directions. >Spoken turn-by-turn navigation has been a free service offered through Google’s Android mobile OS for a few years now. But it was never part of the deal that brought Google’s Maps to iOS. And sources say Apple very much wanted it to be. Requiring iPhone users to look directly at handsets for directions and manually move through each step — while Android users enjoyed native voice-guided instructions — put Apple at a clear disadvantage in the mobile space. And having chosen Google as its original mapping partner, the iPhone maker was now in a position where an archrival was calling the shots on functionality important to the iOS maps feature set. >And this caused Apple — which typically enjoys very tight control over its products — no end of philosophical discomfort, sources say. Apple pushed Google hard to provide the data it needed to bring voice-guided navigation to iOS. But according to people familiar with Google’s thinking, the search giant, which had invested massive sums in creating that data and views it as a key feature of Android, wasn’t willing to simply hand it over to a competing platform. >And if there were terms under which it might have agreed to do so, Apple wasn’t offering them. Sources tell AllThingsD that Google, for example, wanted more say in the iOS maps feature set. It wasn’t happy simply providing back-end data. It asked for in-app branding. Apple declined. It suggested adding Google Latitude. Again, Apple declined. And these became major points of contention between the two companies, whose relationship was already deteriorating for a variety of other reasons, including Apple’s concern that Google was gathering too much user data from the app. I think it was a major strategic mistake on Google's part. But this was the heyday of Andy Rubin, and during that era Google was letting the tail wag the dog in trying to differentiate Android. They've since come to their senses and Android is back to being what it was always designed to be, a vessel for Google's services that actually make money. But that forced Apple to enter this business when they otherwise wouldn't have and now it will serve as a core technology from autonomous cars to AR. And since they're already sinking the capital and doing the grunt work to make Maps from scratch, they might as well earn some incremental revenue from it [2]. [1] http://allthingsd.com/20120926/apple-google-maps-talks-crashed-over-voice-guided-directions/ http://allthingsd.com/20120926/apple-google-maps-talks-crash... [2] https://developer.apple.com/maps/mapkitjs/ https://developer.apple.com/maps/mapkitjs/
- megablast 8y agoThey would be fools to be beholden to another company for something so important.
- untog 8y agoThey could sponsor OpenStreetMaps and dedicate resources to it, donate satellite imagery etc. They'd get a lot of great data in return.
- macintux 8y agoOSM is orders of magnitude worse than Apple's current data set in my area, and I doubt that's unusual. So the question for Apple is why tie themselves to a 3rd party platform? If they're going to go to this massive level of effort to generate the best data set they can achieve, they'll want to control the full stack for quality and predictability. They could feed the OSM-relevant data they create to the platform, but that means a lot more work to create and maintain the integration tools and manage the workflow, along with potentially reduced revenues if they make OSM too good. I doubt they'll care about any threat from OSM, but I doubt they'd see the overall effort as a good business investment. This isn't as straightforward as open sourcing some software.
- saturn_vk 8y agoYou could fix your spotty coverage yourself. The areas I've been at had exceptional detail.
- macintux 8y agoI spent some time starting to do so, but the gaps are cavernous, and I decided I had I other priorities.
- __sr__ 8y agoYeah, I’ve nothing better to do than roam around fixing maps. It’s not like I have a daily job or anything. /s It the same argument when someone talks about an issue with an open source software. The response is, “The source code is available, go fix it yourself.” It doesn’t work that way for anything but trivial issues.
- 394549 8y ago
- dalbasal 8y agoWell... Maps, location data, and the services they enable were available on Apple devices before this project. They outsourced to Google, like everyone else. I can see how that's a strategically concerning position, especially considering that they are in a two-horse race against Google, but... you are going to have some uncomfortable dependencies in this business regardless. I mean chips are important.. nevermind.
- simonh 8y agoAre you aware of why Apple left the Google deal? Google was withholding the latest features from the Apple version, including vector map data and turn by turn directions. There's also indications Google wanted access to user location data in return for some of these features, something Apple was not willing to compromise on.
- dzhiurgis 8y agoBut giving away most of these features would mean Apple has to host Google's data, something Google wouldn't compromise either. Sure Google could've promised that they wouldn't collect which tile a phone requested by specific user agent, but that would be silly.
- bla2 8y agoThe usual play is "when behind, join up with others and promote openness". That's what Google and Microsoft are doing vs AWS in cloud, its what browsers did during IE 6.0's reign, it's what Apple did with it's OS kernel, and so on. It admittedly doesn't seem like a great fit for current Apple.
- StephenMelon 8y agoThe two future directions that Apple are heading in are AR (augmented reality) and AS (autonomous systems). Mapping is more than key to both of those domain. It’s a complete no-brainer for Apple.
- divbzero 8y ago> AR This is absolutely it. Maps, location data, and point clouds will power ARKit on the phone and perhaps in glasses. Apple’s mobile UX has always relied on vertical integration, from custom-built A* chips all the way up to iCloud-powered software. Similarly, mastering underlying AR technologies will give Apple maximal control over its AR user experience.