8 ms·
The Tyranny of the Rocket Equation (2012)
- woodandsteel 8y agoSpaceX’s BFR plans to overcome the propellant problem for getting to Mars by refueling in orbit. I am surprised the article didn't mention the refueling possibility. Maybe NASA didn't want to admit they are making a mistake putting all their cash into the SLS. Also, the economic implications of the equation don't matter so much when you have a reusable rocket, and the BFR is supposed to be able to reuse both stages.
- neolefty 8y agoI am surprised the article didn't mention the refueling possibility. NASA source is from 2012, before BFR was fleshed out.
- Robotbeat 8y agoSpace refueling is way older than 2012.
- woodandsteel 8y agoOk, but it still should have been included as a theoretical possibility.
- drostie 8y agoIn six years nobody has corrected the fact that one of the propellants listed is not "Methane-Oxygen" but "Earth orbit to near-Earth asteroids", and the following is not "Methane-Oxygen" but "Hydrogen-Oxygen."
- maxxxxx 8y agoWhat amazes (and saddens) me is that we don't seem to have not even a far fetched theoretical approach to dramatically improve rockets within the next few decades.
- cookingrobot 8y agoThere are catapults: https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/22/spinlaunch-2/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/22/spinlaunch-2/
- zyxwvu 8y agoI'm pretty sure that would lead to a near absolute zero survivability for anyone on board a system like that.
- 2trill2spill 8y agoYea, but a catapult or railgun would be fine for water, certain foods and other durable goods. Then the crew could take a smaller, cheaper rocket up.
- zyxwvu 8y agoThat's true. I wonder what the energy use would be in comparison to chemical rockets. And if it would be inherently safer since it wouldn't be moving via a controlled explosion.
- mickronome 8y agoIt's a bit sad, I do long for the stars and planets. However, rramatically improving rockets might be like trying to improve the carriage to get a much faster personal transport, while keeping the horse. It seems to be the case, that the cost of launching commercial payloads are still "low" enough compared to the cost of the payloads since there are few big budget ventures that tries to make lifting much cheaper through alternative methods. I'm not saying that space elevators or other alternative lift devices are feasible, but we tend to get huge investments even into tech that seems absolutely implausible if there is a big market. The lack of these makes investments makes it plausible that the current launch costs are actually acceptable for all current, and expected near future commercial actors.
- 8y ago
- ilugaslifk 8y agoThe tyranny of the rocket equation has done an order of magnitude less damage to the progress of human space exploration than the mind-blowing waste of the Shuttle program.
- klodolph 8y ago> As humans, we are powerless to change this number. We simply have to accept its consequences. I like to think of this as the travel cost. This is selling rocket science a little short, I think. The availabilty of gravity assists and aerobraking make it possible to achieve large variations in delta V necessary for a trip, as long as you can make the right tradeoffs elsewhere (travel time, etc). See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_Transport_Network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_Transport_Netwo...
- koverda 8y agoNice that we live on a planet with low enough gravity to get off of it. The article states that if the Earth was about 50% bigger, chemical rockets wouldn't be able to achieve escape velocity. Any species on a planet like that has a much much harder time getting into space.
- Symmetry 8y agoOn the other hand those green men on Mars can get off their planet pretty easily with just a single stage.
- Florin_Andrei 8y agoWe almost had a nuclear space program. It got cancelled for non-technical reasons. On a planet with harder take-off, that program would get all the funds it could possibly need.
- knodi123 8y ago> We almost had a nuclear space program. built on the success of a rocket-based program! no way would a country fund a vehicle that spews out a constant stream of nuclear bombs as their species' first foray into orbit!
- glandium 8y agoWhat if they're immune to radiation?
- Florin_Andrei 8y ago> a vehicle that spews out a constant stream of nuclear bombs That's not how the NERVA was supposed to work. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA
- extrapickles 8y ago‘Project Orion’ is the spew out a stream of nuclear bombs propulsion technique.
- hackerpacker 8y agothere are more tyrannical equations if you are promoting space colonization. I mean if you compare earth to a petri dish, what do you think a small domed shelter on some other planet will be?!? I like space, lots of neat things to learn, but the discussion always seems to get a little religious and doomsday-ish, and I find it less than genuine. Like have people thought about where the energy to get massive numbers of people off the planet will come from, and how that will leave the planet in even worse shape for those that can't leave? It is folly to think technology can fix everything, and I sometimes wonder if it has actually "fixed" anything, aside from helping to enable overpopulation.
- groby_b 8y agoThe energy to get a human off the planet is relatively small. Let's call it an MWh. (It's 9.1 KWh/kg) A billion people is a PWh. That's 0.5% of the earth's annual energy use. It's a blip on the radar, especially since it will subsequently reduce annual consumption in the 10% range.
- hackerpacker 8y agofactoring in Tsiolkovsky's equations, it seems more like 30mwh, and that is just one person, and just the fuel, not the processing or the preparation or even building a rocket, without any life support, or landing plan. plus where are you going to send %10 of the population where they will be immune to human nature, whatever that is.
- ur-whale 8y agoSince I first got interested in science, I've been presented a number of times with this idea (that lifting things in orbit is subject to very simple physics that have harsh economic implications). I've always felt uneasy about this, as it seems to imply that the only way to put things in orbit is via rockets. For example, there is the idea of a space crane (assuming it can be built) that is simply a very, very tall building, assembled one chunk at a time, and that once built can simply lift things in orbit. Would a space crane be slave to the same equations?
- frahs 8y agoMost of the energy of getting a rocket to orbit is in achieving orbital velocity, not orbital altitude :/. Unless you accelerate your satellite really really fast, it'll just fall back to the earth.
- ohazi 8y agoIf you could build a proper space elevator, a payload could be lifted to the geostationary point and then released. At that point it's already at orbital velocity, and can use much less fuel (compared to an Earth launched rocket) to get back down to low earth orbit. But again, this is still a materials science problem.
- ohazi 8y agoNo, it wouldn't, but "assuming it can be built" is a pretty tall order. We don't really know how to reliably manufacture materials that can sustain the loads required for something like this.
- watersb 8y ago> a pretty tall order . . .
- ur-whale 8y agoYes, I do understand that we have an unsolved material science problem for the space elevator, but my question was more theoretical (hence the "assuming that") and boiled down to: "doesn't the hypothetical space elevator break the tyranny of the rocket equation?" (which you did answer).
- mrfusion 8y agoKeep in mind this equation only applies if you insist on bringing all your fuel with you.
- neolefty 8y agoWhere else would you get it? Unless it's beamed in the form of light, I don't know of many options. The challenge is to get from the Earth's surface, to orbit. Yes, there's oxygen along the way, but the speeds you have to go will wreck you if you stay in the atmosphere at all. So you get into vacuum ASAP. Once you're in orbit, you have a lot more options. For example, you don't need a high-thrust engine—instead, high-efficiency is fine, even if it's low thrust. Etc.
- dangerbird2 8y agoHe's probably implying mining or synthesizing fuel on smaller gravity wells like Mars. Being able to synthesize fuel for the return trip could massively cut back on initial launch weight. Energizing propellant with a microwave beam (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beam-powered_propulsion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beam-powered_propulsion) has been hypothesized, while a solar sail is much more realistic with modern technology.
- mrfusion 8y agoHere are just a few: Beam microwave or laser energy to ship Launch loop Sky hook Launch fountain Some company is even working on a launch slingshot. I’d provide Wikipedia links but I’m on my palm pilot. Look them up though. Interesting stuff.
- pasabagi 8y agoIt's occurred to me that a rocket is perhaps the perfect metaphor for a pessimistic reading of the fermi paradox. It's a device that perfectly encapsulates how much easier it is to destroy society, than it is to pull society out of a gravity well. In the first instance, by blowing up on the launchpad. In the second, by providing the means for competing societies to nuke the whole world into a mass extinction. The problem is the same for all of the ideas like space-elevators, or asteroid mining, or spacetravel as a normal thing - given our current politics, there's no way you'd avoid occasional rock-droppage with catastrophic consequences for people still stuck on earth. It would just be too easy. If you start thinking along the lines towards nuclear-fueled rockets, the problem just gets worse. Non-weapon rockets are high-energy, fiddly devices - and their dumb purely-destructive siblings are far simpler. If launching rockets became cheap enough to put people on Mars, that would also mean they'd be cheap enough so even small states could afford ICBMs. Because rockets are ICBMs.
- neolefty 8y agohow much easier it is to destroy society Lots of modern technologies do that. Like a child growing up—at what age do you use sharp knives? a lawnmower? a car?—humanity has matured ethically alongside our technology. I agree we have to be careful not to Great Filter ourselves.
- pasabagi 8y ago>humanity has matured ethically alongside our technology That's exactly the problem. I don't think we have at all. We do no serious study of ethics in our schooling, and frankly don't devote serious thought to the subject. It's very uncommon to meet somebody who has read even a single book about ethics. We're a society of meat-eaters who consider people who harm animals to be scum, a society that simultaneously considers the protection of children fundamental, and where the most likely age to die on a world scale is in childhood. These are reflections of a deep lack of ethical maturity. Regardless of all of the inconsistency, I think it's hard to look at the times in which the world came to the brink of nuclear catastrophe in the cold war, and state confidently that this is a society with the maturity to hold nuclear weapons.
- AgentOrange1234 8y agoThis is really fascinating. I still don’t have an intuitive understanding of why getting into space takes so much more propellant than flying an airplane, but it seems like it’s definitely a hugely more difficult thing to do. Thanks for posting.
- yellowapple 8y agoIt's about speed. Getting into space is relatively easy (it does take a lot more propellant than flying an airplane, but it's understandable since spaceships tend to fly a lot higher than airplanes). Staying there means you have to be flying so fast that you fall continuously around Earth instead of into it. Even the fastest airplanes in the world can't get that fast on their own (at least not yet). More speed requires more fuel (and since that fuel makes you heavier, you need even more fuel to counteract the added weight - that's the rocket equation). Even more intuitively: it's about distance. Flying from Los Angeles to Salt Lake City requires less fuel than flying from Los Angeles to New York City. Flying from Los Angeles all the way around the world and landing again in Los Angeles takes even more fuel.
- AgentOrange1234 8y agoThat... makes perfect sense. Thanks!
- becomingknown 8y agoRelevant XKCD https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/126/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/126/
- marksbrown 8y agoAlternatively https://xkcd.com/1356/ https://xkcd.com/1356/