6 ms·
The way I see it, logistics aside, Tesla has awesome cars that are loved by those that manage to get one delivered, customers are actually lining up to buy them
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
The way I see it, logistics aside, Tesla has awesome cars that are loved by those that manage to get one delivered, customers are actually lining up to buy them to the extent of paying just to get in line for that years ahead of time, and they are pretty much guaranteed to sell anything they ship for the foreseeable future.
Better still most of their would be competitors are either not shipping at all right now, years away from shipping at scale, just plain not even bothering to compete, or shipping limited volumes of not so great products, and generally being vague about timelines, volumes, etc. On top of that they and are struggling with over production of vehicles based on legacy petrol/diesel technology.
E.g. the Germans are doing a lot of hand waving around maybe shipping some electric cars in the next decade while the likes of BMW continue to ship seriously underwhelming electric cars. Ford just discontinued a lot of their petrol sedans. And diesel gate continues to impact most manufacturers involved with basically anything Diesel based.
The way I see it, Tesla will be essentially unchallenged for the next 2-3 years. That's a lot of time to get on top of some simple logistics. And that's assuming the existing car manufacturers actually get their act together. IMHO, most of them are at far bigger risk of bankruptcy than Tesla since they'll be bogged down in demand issues, layoffs, and restructurings for the next few decades.
I don't see the logistical situation as something that can't be resolved by Tesla. Kind of silly to short Tesla under the assumption that this won't be solved; cannot be solved; and that Tesla will perpetually be unable to solve this. The argument seems to be that it is simply impossible to produce the vehicles for Tesla.
If the latest rumors are to be believed, they are pretty much close to the promised rate of 5K cars/week. At 50K price (conservative) that means 250M per week in revenue, or 1 Billion per month. That sounds like a decent business to me. I'm assuming they are not stopping at 5K per week.
- catherinezng 8y agoTesla lost ~$2B last year, owes ~$10B in debt, and owes >$400M in interest payments per year alone. Moody’s downgraded Tesla’s bond rating because Tesla will need to raise more money this year, at least $2B (which is an extremely conservative figure), to avoid Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Elon Musk also owes >$600M in personal debt that he financed using Tesla stock as collateral. This means that if Tesla stock dips below around $233/share, Musk would face a margin call (sell Tesla stock, driving stock prices lower), or put down more Tesla stock as collateral to fund his debt. By the way, 90% of the Boring company’s funds come from Elon Musk himself, possibly funded by this personal debt. Other red flags are that shareholders sued Tesla board members for breaching their fiduciary duties by allowing Tesla to acquire Solar City, assuming an extra ~$3B in debt; and Tesla’s CFO Jason Wheeler left Tesla in 2017 with over half of his stock left to vest. The reason people are shorting Tesla is that beyond Elon Musk’s cult of personality, the numbers don’t add up. Tesla will need to raise more money this year to survive. Feel free to fact check all of this.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoSo, that's about 1 year of revenue at 5K cars per week or roughly equivalent to their revenue last year. Or half of that if they manage to double that to 10K per week, as they seem to have promised. That doesn't sound like an impossible situation to me. Unless I'm missing something, a default on these debts is unlikely and given the numbers, access to more capital should be feasible. I agree that these are high risk investments though. High risk and high reward go hand in hand of course. Elon Musk may owe a little money indeed but he's also a shareholder in SpaceX. I'm not up to speed on how much he owns of that exactly but I believe it is a fairly large chunk of that company. And given the amount of rockets going up lately, his shares are probably worth quite a bit at this point. Magnitudes more than the 600M you mention, I imagine. So, I don't think a personal bankruptcy is that likely for him any time soon. Tesla 'lost' money investing in production capacity, R&D, opening up a huge battery production facility, etc. That's not wasted money unless demand for utilizing these to full capacity disappears. As it is, the opposite seems to be the case. Tesla is talking about opening additional Giga factories even. That will cost more money of course but I think they can make a case for that being a good investment given demand in their products. That's perhaps why it's stock valuation is so high: shareholders are expecting these investments to translate into revenue and growth. People that shorted Tesla seem to be getting a bit nervous about maybe ending up on the wrong end of that bet, which could end up being an expensive mistake for some. Boring and Solar City are interesting wild cards. I think owning Solar City is not necessarily a bad thing for Tesla. Solar panels are in demand and Tesla seems to consider charging infrastructure as part of their strategy. Also up-selling batteries that they produce to people that install solar panels seems like a smart move. Unless there's something wrong with their product, I see no reason for that to fail. They do seem to have acquired a bit of a cost overhead problem, which they have been fixing through layoffs. But other than that, this could very well turn out to be a pretty good bargain. Boring seems like a weird project at first glance. But it wouldn't be the first side project that Elon Musk is involved in that turned into a real business.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- windexh8er 8y agoAll the major players operate under a debt and profit cycle. It's just that nobody else is also building a new car company and one that is a paradigm shift. https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/automobiles/nyse-gm/general-motors/news/is-general-motors-companys-nysegm-balance-sheet-strong-enough-to-weather-a-storm/ https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/automobiles/nyse-gm/general-... On top of the fact they were bailed out.
- misja111 8y agoIf you believe that there is not much of competition for Tesla right now, you should read this: https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/10/17096608/tesla-jaguar-porsche-audi-evs-geneva-motor-show-2018 https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/10/17096608/tesla-jaguar-por...
- davedx 8y agoNot right now: "One car alone doesn’t crowd the field. But Geneva was a showcase for a rush of coming EVs and hybrids." The i-Pace is almost out. The others... aren't. I'm particularly skeptical of Audi's gigantic marketing machine.
- misja111 8y agoThe Geneva expo was on March 1st, by now the i-Pace has arrived in the showrooms. The E-Tron Quattro is said to go in production in the upcoming months and to be deliverable by the end of the year.
- _ph_ 8y agoThe i-Pace is great and the first real competitor to Tesla, but they are making about 20k/year, so it is a welcome addition to the electric car offerings, but won't cut into Tesla sales. Actually the electric car market is going to grow in the next years faster than the worldwide production capacity for electric cars, so there won't be huge problems selling all the made cars.
- maherbeg 8y agoI think the question is whether or not this expands the market more than it takes away share from Tesla. I think it's a bit of both, but hoping that it leans more towards expansion than cannibalization.
- wpietri 8y ago> they are pretty much close to the promised rate of 5K cars/week They might hit that goal, but I'm very concerned about how they're getting there. Toyota was the company that really figured out how to make good cars economically. They came out of Japan's post-war economic devastation to kick the asses of US carmakers. Their thinking was so alien to traditional approaches that Detroit spent decades trying to catch on and catch up. That depite Toyota doing their best to help their competitors get it. [1] A pillar of Toyota's approach is patient, gradual, relentless improvement. There are a lot of signs that Tesla has never really warmed to that. Musk likes drama, action. But he's been overpromising and underdelivering for a while now. That he's sleeping at the factory might sound impressive, but to me it's a sign that he hasn't built an organization that can handle this. Even if they hit the arbitrary 5K goal, I'm concerned they'll will reach it not by building a great, reliable process, but through the sort of rushing and corner-cutting that leaves them in bad shape for the future. That's very common in the tech world, and we pay for it with high tech debt and low long-term productivity. Perhaps he's doing the same thing here. [1] e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NUMMI https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NUMMI
- davedx 8y ago> A pillar of Toyota's approach is patient, gradual, relentless improvement. There are a lot of signs that Tesla has never really warmed to that. I guess it depends how you interpret the news and what Musk has said in shareholder meetings. At the last one he explicitly said that they continuously improve the process at Tesla.
- wpietri 8y agoI'm sure he said that. But the US car industry has a long history of boldly declared but ultimately failed attempts to adopt Toyota's process in a way sufficiently deep to get Toyota's results. Rother's book "Toyota Kata" is a good dive into why: they adopted some of the rituals, but never made the deeper cultural and philosophical changes needed to get most of the value.
- windexh8er 8y agoToyota embraced Deming/Kaizen, it wasn't their idea. Beyond that Tesla is a more extreme version of those ideas. Toyota doesn't need to, but it's likely they also wouldn't, build an entirely new line to meet a goal. That would be out of the focal range of their 'softer' implementation of continual improvements. Musk on the other hand is not averse to continual improvements that are on the extreme end of the spectrum. This is very evident in how they've built the car. For example when Consumer Reports identified a braking issue with the Model 3 Tesla had an OTA software fix in days. What other manufacture would do that, let alone could?
- bjl 8y ago>The argument seems to be that it is simply impossible to produce the vehicles for Tesla. This is a complete straw man. The argument is that its impossible for TSLA to produce cars in the volume necessary, at the margins necessary, in the time frame necessary to both pay down their massive amounts of debt and justify their enormous valuation. And, looking at the numbers, that seems like a pretty solid argument.
- basch 8y agoIts pretty clear Chevy, Niassan, Hyundai/Kia, and Toyota are already competitive in many regards. Jaguar, Audi, and BMW arent three years behind. Right now its about perceived luxary and marketing, and a bit of a software / business model lead. I dont think any of those companies would be three years behind if they actually tried to deliver a market leading luxury car, although some might need to acquihire some better software divisions.
- codeulike 8y agoThey are all behind Tesla in cost per kwh for batteries.