3 ms·
As a former big wall climber I would add that articles like this forget to mention the difficulty factor. For some people a 5.10 is like walking on a sidewalk.
by sandworm101 8y ago
As a former big wall climber I would add that articles like this forget to mention the difficulty factor. For some people a 5.10 is like walking on a sidewalk. People who would be killed by falling off a sidewalk or down a set of stairs (old people etc) rarely use harnesses. Risk is inversely related to skill and ability.
At least a rock climber's fate is largely in their control. The well-traveled Yosemite stuff isn't going to shift under you. Death zone, or ice climbers, are the real crazies. They role the dice. Skill and ability means nothing when the mountain decides to collapse underneath you. And such climbers tend to die in groups, their fate linked to whoever else is on the rope. Free soloists die alone.
- st26 8y agoRisk is inversely related to skill and ability Ahem, objective hazard?
- Fricken 8y agoI personally consider the Fitz Roy Traverse to be Honnold's greatest ascent, which he did with Tommy Caldwell, and they certainly faced their share of subjective hazards on that climb: https://www.redbull.tv/video/AP-1MQAPEZX91W11/a-line-across-the-sky-part-i https://www.redbull.tv/video/AP-1MQAPEZX91W11/a-line-across-...
- gkanai 8y ago> The well-traveled Yosemite stuff isn't going to shift under you. Except when there are accidents. Like recently on El Capitan: https://www.climbing.com/news/eye-witnesses-recount-tragic-accident-on-el-caps-freeblast/ https://www.climbing.com/news/eye-witnesses-recount-tragic-a...
- foobarbecue 8y agoDoes anyone know what went wrong there yet, exactly? Just insufficient pro and unexpected fall?
- sandworm101 8y agoLooks like the pair were simulclimbing and might not have had any pro between them at a bad moment.
- foobarbecue 8y agoIn which case, gkanai is wrong -- the rock didn't "shift." This was almost certainly human error.
- foobarbecue 8y agoWow, you explained this very eloquently. Sometimes I've heard this called intrinsic vs extrinsic risk. Alex generally chooses activities with intrinsic risks instead of extrinsic, and mitigates them. It's more responsible than playing around in avalanche zones or at deadly altitudes. By the way, I talked to him about his recent antarctic expedition and he said it was pretty sketchy at times -- there were extrinsic risks he couldn't control, and he didn't like that.