5 ms·
And you think trusting MS is a better idea?
by shmerl 8y ago
And you think trusting MS is a better idea?
- dvtrn 8y agoIt may alleviate some cynicism to look at this as less a matter of implicit 'trust' and more a matter of 'best possible outcome'. At least IMO. As it is, Microsoft has been doing some pretty good, developer-centric work and I for one appreciate that. That isn't to say Google isn't, but again: best possible outcome? Like someone else brought up: I feel more comfortable with a product being owned by Microsoft and maintained for longer than 18 months before the devs get bored with and put it in front of a firing squad so they can go create yet another messaging platform (only to later kill that too)
- shmerl 8y agoI don't feel comfortable with MS owning it at all. I wouldn't feel comfortable with Google owning it either really, but MS is IMHO worse, especially if you consider issues relevant to FOSS (which should be important for users of Github obviously). Just see who was on what side in the dispute about copyrightability of APIs.
- on_and_off 8y agoof course ! Who can afford to remember more than the last 3 minutes ?
- devereaux 8y agoIt's funny, I find this attitude a lot with guys over 35. A quick example: I was at a conference last year in a group. Two people mentioned they worked for google. I mentioned an anecdote - how I had migrated parts of a research project from google maps to bing maps, because of a much better pricing for the simple things we needed (yet in a large volume, millions of API requests). They asked why, and I explained that besides the money saved, like a few friends, I tried to favor any credible alternative to google. They laughed it out with some arrogance :-) It's funny how the google of now reminds me of the Microsoft of the 1990s - a scary company I'd rather have nothing to do with.
- ravenstine 8y agoOne's an advertising company and the other is a software company. One is not seen as being reliable and ruthless in shutting down companies to harvest talent, whereas the other has a record of long-term support for its own products and appears to be putting forth a good faith effort in supporting FOSS. I choose the latter of two evils, which is Microsoft. MS isn't stupid, and they know that futzing with Github would mean generations of developers never trusting them with anything again. That's not to say that Microsoft won't do the wrong thing, but a lot of people see them as less likely to do the wrong thing than Google, and I happen to agree with them. EDIT: My first statement is oversimplistic. What I meant by that is Google is mostly interested in advertising and selling data, but Microsoft's business isn't build around advertising(i.e. Bing Ads doesn't appear to be critical to Microsoft's success). Granted, Microsoft is known for selling "data", but I don't see how much of that they would gain from GitHub.
- bb88 8y ago> MS isn't stupid, and they know that futzing with Github would mean generations of developers never trusting them with anything again. Have you forgotten about how Microsoft destroyed Nokia? MS bought Nokia in 2014, and then sold it in 2016 for pennies on the dollar for what it paid in 2014 [1] [2]. Meanwhile MS completely wiped out Nokia's brand and technology to push Windows Mobile down everyone's throat. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2016/05/18/nokia-phones-are-back-after-microsoft-sells-mobile-assets-for-350-million-to-foxconn-hmd.html https://www.cnbc.com/2016/05/18/nokia-phones-are-back-after-... [2] 5 pennies on the dollar to be exact.
- ravenstine 8y agoI'm not saying it never happens. Although Nokia doesn't surprise me because nobody has cared about Nokia for some time now. Microsoft was basically beating a dead horse. Yeah, they could have resurrected it, but Microsoft had less to lose by destroying Nokia than it does by destroying Github. (although this is really my gut talking without solid figures)
- bb88 8y ago
- bunderbunder 8y agoIn this particular case, yeah. It's not that I have zero concerns about Microsoft mining personal data. I just have even more concerns regarding Google. Google is, to an approximation, a personal data mining corporation. The rest is just ways of getting people to share that data.