6 ms·
> Websites like Zillow and Apartments.com offer calculations for commute length and walkability to everyday destinations like grocery stores If I'm walking to
by paulddraper 8y ago
> Websites like Zillow and Apartments.com offer calculations for commute length and walkability to everyday destinations like grocery stores
If I'm walking to the store, do I (a) try to carry 20+ grocery bags home for my family of five or (b) make a grocery trip twice a week? I don't love either of those.
And that's only groceries, not shopping in general. My wife got a 50lb bag of fertilizer from Tractor Supply yesterday morning. How close does that store need to be for walking to make sense? At the end of my driveway?
Basically....if you have a crowded city of apartments, sure, don't do much for cars. If you have a city of single-family residences (and three quarters of Americans do live in single-family residences), it's really hard to not build for cars.
- oftenwrong 8y agoTo give you an idea: I have a 3 grocers within walking distance, and I will usually just go buy what I need for whatever I am going to make the same day. One bag is usually fine. I have never purchased that much fertilizer, but I have purchased a 50lb bag of sand at the hardware store on the corner. It is so close, I would be surprised if my walk home was not shorter than your wife's walk back to her car. Living in the dense city requires many sacrifices, but one of the best upsides is being able to walk places.
- LgWoodenBadger 8y agoWell, how many people can physically live as close to those things as you do without having a 1-hardware-store-per-100-feet or 3-grocers-per-square-mile density?
- oftenwrong 8y agoI don't really know, but I would say that, in areas where people largely walk and bike, businesses tend to have a smaller area that they draw regular customers from, and it is easy for a few businesses of the same type to coexist relatively close to one another. There are duplicates of many types of businesses in my neighbourhood. Walking is the most distance-sensitive major form of transportation. People who mainly walk tend to shop at the closest possible place. Nothing in walking distance will match the selection of a big store like Tractor Supply or Home Depot. I use Zip Car when necessary, but it is pretty rare, especially now that everything can be ordered online.
- jacques_chester 8y agoI'm on the Upper West Side. 42,000 per square kilometre. More people live in these 500 hectares than the hundreds of square kilometres of Darwin where I grew up. At the end of my street there is a cleaner, a hardware store, grocery store and restaurant. Within view of the grocery store is another grocery store. A street over from the hardware store is another hardware store. Two streets down? Another restaurant. You get the idea. And then if I need something really specialised, I hop on a train and go to one of the mini-districts where I can find a whole street of something. Or I ring them, or visit their website, and get it delivered. A month ago I was in a three-story cloth store with a friend. On a street full of cloth stores. I had no idea such things existed. But they do. There's a curtain district. A street where I find several places selling mattresses. Famously, a street of jewelers. Again: you get the idea. Living a middle-class life in a dense city is a kind of convenient normally reserved for the rich.
- spraak 8y ago> If you have a city of single-family residences (and three quarters of Americans do live in single-family residences), it's really hard to not build for cars. Yes, and how those cities are designed are a big part of the problem.
- takk309 8y agoDevelopment standards rarely satisfy everyone's needs/wants. It is more efficient to build at a high density, but that may not necessarily mean that we should all conform to that mentality. A lot of us don't want to live in dense urban environments.
- pchristensen 8y agoIn 99% of America (including many dense cities), it's illegal to build dense urban environments. So you cannot claim that the built environment reflects how most people want to live.
- lgregg 8y agoAlso, three-quarters (generalization) of America is rural. You're not going to implement this everywhere. I don't think that is the point of the article or OP.
- slededit 8y agoIts pretty great to get groceries the day of on your way home from work. Ingredients are fresh, and nothing sits around wasting away in your freezer or fridge. Your town has to be setup well for it though.
- pm90 8y agoThis exactly! I recently moved to SF and just love that on my walk back home I can just stop by and get the things I need to make dinner for the night. No more buying a ton of stuff and storing in the fridge. As for the heavy stuff: many stores offer home delivery. There are also other apps that have people deliver stuff to your home for a small fee. Definitely doable.
- toasterlovin 8y agoBeing able to store 2 weeks of groceries in the fridge is a feature for people with > 2 children. It's not a bug.
- lgregg 8y agoIf you live within walking distance, why would you carry 20+ grocery bags. Just shop for what you need in the next day, not an entire month.
- refurb 8y agoThat sounds incredibly inefficient.
- lgregg 8y agoNot really, I lived near a grocery store in two different cities. When I was in Chicago, I lived behind one for 3 years. When I lived in NYC, I was a block and half away. They were both between my commute route. I always knew what I needed, so I'd buy it fresh (i.e. Milk, fruits/veggies, and etc.) along with a few long-term items (i.e. bags of rice, canned goods, dish soap, and etc). Now, I'm not close and my cost per month has gone up because stuff spoils because I don't want to waste time driving to the grocery store so I buy too much. It really depends on what type of shopper you are, if you go into a grocery store and b-line to where you know everything is or if you're one to wander and mozy through the grocery store in a general direction and putting things in your cart per chance. When I was doing the daily or multi-weekly deal, most trips would be 10 mins or less depending on how busy the grocery store was.
- cimmanom 8y agoOther people have mentioned picking up a day's worth of groceries on the way home from work. And now and then when you need to buy more than you can carry? You use one of these: https://cdn.instructables.com/FP2/EECN/FRXUSVAV/FP2EECNFRXUSVAV.LARGE.jpg https://cdn.instructables.com/FP2/EECN/FRXUSVAV/FP2EECNFRXUS... And I think part of the point is that for a city we should be building for dense apartments, not single-family residences.
- paulddraper 8y agoCity. I live in a city (to be precise Lehi City, Utah [1] population 65k). If we're talking large cities, say pop 400k+ (San Fran is 870k), then sure assume apartments. I didn't see any qualifiers; it seems the author is advocating these ideas for all cities. And 70% of Americans live in city/town/village/hamlet/whatever of less than 100k. [2] (Perhaps that is solely because of the aforementioned urban planning issues, and they would all jump at the chance to live in a shared dwelling in a dense well-planned city. I suspect not, but perhaps.) [1] https://www.lehi-ut.gov/ https://www.lehi-ut.gov/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b... 94m of 325m live in city of 100k+
- pchristensen 8y agoSaying that you live in Lehi, a small town, without mentioning that it's near the geographic center of a region of nearly 2 million is a little disingenuous. You're talking like you live in Logan, a similar sized town that's geographically and economically distant. Lehi is, in all ways but politically, a subdivided neighborhood of SLC-Provo. Given the businesses around I-15 and the train stations, it would definitely benefit from allowing (not mandating) denser development in and around the central areas. But those can't be built regardless of whether people want them or not, due to zoning. 40% of the US population lives in the 48 largest metro areas, and 80% live in "urban areas" - https://www.citylab.com/equity/2012/03/us-urban-population-what-does-urban-really-mean/1589/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2012/03/us-urban-population-w.... Just because your municipality has a low population doesn't mean you live in a small town.
- jacques_chester 8y agoIn NYC, everything can be delivered, usually for free or a low fee. This is possible because of the density. If you want the 20 bags, you order the 20 bags and it can come today, Sunday at 10am, whatever floats your boat. Same for anything else. That's not even counting what Prime or Prime Now can get you.