3 ms·
>Rather than trying to force some particular vision of "the good life" on people, what if we tried to price transportation and other things appropriately? I ag
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
>Rather than trying to force some particular vision of "the good life" on people, what if we tried to price transportation and other things appropriately?
I agree with this at least.
>For example, get rid of the gas tax. Toll all state and federally funded roads...
Lets do this with public transit too. Ticket sales should cover the full price of the ride. People who walk and bike shouldn't have to subsidize public transit they don't use. They should pay a sidewalk toll instead. No reason to stop there though, lets remove tax breaks for dependents and use the money to pay for public schools. People who's kids aren't in school shouldn't be subsidizing the cost of other peoples kids. We should also bill people when they call emergency services so that the rest of us don't have to subsidize it. People who need emergency services shouldn't externalize the cost onto society, it should be priced in. Now that we've done all that let's figure out that these things are all too expensive for poor people and nowhere near cheap for the middle class. Next let's come up with some sort of voucher system so that these people can use them at reduced cost. After that we can figure out that it's cheaper to just make using all these public resources cheap/free than it is to administrate the pay per use and income based discount system we just created. /s
The point I'm trying to make is that public infrastructure is publicly funded for a reason. Having these things available to the population at near zero cost works out better for everyone than just making users pay for what they use.
- dbatten 8y agoYou've basically just described a libertarian economic philosophy. We can have an intelligent conversation about whether that's a good idea or not, but it's a very serious political philosophy that lots of very intelligent people subscribe to...
- wahern 8y agoLibertarianism may be a serious economic philosophy but it's a poor political philosophy. It completely ignores issues like path dependency, importance of culture and socialization, etc. Don't you find it odd that societies that exemplify the sort of globally optimal yet individually rational choices such as in Japan or Nordic countries have laws and norms more often than not in direct contradiction to Western Libertarian thinking? Libertarianism can only work if people have already strongly internalized a communitarian ethos. Without that ethos (internalized directly by the people or indirectly through its institutions) civilization cannot exist; basic game theory proves that. Pervasive non-kin selflessness is the defining characteristic that uniquely separates humans from every other species in existence.[1] The paradox is that we can get rid of coercive economic policies only once the Koch Brothers and Paul Ryans are replaced by hippies, or at least people substantially less motivated by bald self-interest. [1] We still don't understand how it arose, and so IMO all modern economic theories (libertarian or otherwise) are fundamentally handicapped unless and until we can throughly answer that question.
- dbatten 8y agoYes, this is exactly the sort of intelligent conversation we can have when we stop using sarcasm to dismiss serious positions we disagree with.