3 ms·
You should read the actual ruling if you want details, but the two issues you mention are unrelated. Here's what the actual ruling said on the second issue: "S
by kenjackson 16y ago
You should read the actual ruling if you want details, but the two issues you mention are unrelated.
Here's what the actual ruling said on the second issue: "Second, the court determined that iParadigms’ use of each of the plaintiffs’ written submissions qualified as a "fair use" under 17 U.S.C. § 107 and, therefore, did not constitute infringement. In particular, the court found that the use was transformative because its purpose was to prevent plagiarism by comparative use, and that iParadigms’ use of the student works did not impair the market value for high school term papers and other such works".
And it goes into detail about how their use satisfies the standard pillars of fair use.