4 ms·
> Complying with the spirit of a law doesn't mean complying with the statue of it. With GDPR, it's the latter that's a pain in the ass. I've never understood w
by derefr 8y ago
> Complying with the spirit of a law doesn't mean complying with the statue of it. With GDPR, it's the latter that's a pain in the ass.
I've never understood why people try to comply with the text of a new law that doesn't have case-law under it yet, rather than the spirit.
Surely, the first time anyone gets sued for noncompliance of the text of GDPR, when they are compliant with the spirit under which GDPR was issued, case-law will be created that "bends" the interpretation of the text more toward the spirit?
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> I've never understood why people try to comply with the text of a new law that doesn't have case-law under it yet Continental Europe uses civil law [1]. Case law is less relevant than it is in the U.K. or United States. More broadly, people try to "comply with the text of a new law" to avoid becoming the precedent. (Even if you prevail, it's distracting and expensive.) > Surely, the first time anyone gets sued for noncompliance of the text of GDPR, when they are compliant with the spirit under which GDPR was issued, case-law will be created that "bends" the interpretation of the text more toward the spirit? Surely? Based on what? For anyone with material revenue, that basis will be legal advice. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_law_(legal_system) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_law_(legal_system)
- Mirioron 8y agoBecause SMEs can't afford a legal case.
- sfifs 8y agoTo avoid becoming the precedent should prosecutors choose to make an example of them.