3 ms·
Vegetables have about 100 calories per pound. (See http://www.beyondveg.com/billings-t/cal-par/calorie-paradox1c.shtml http://www.beyondveg.com/billings-t/cal-p
by dalke 16y ago
Vegetables have about 100 calories per pound. (See http://www.beyondveg.com/billings-t/cal-par/calorie-paradox1c.shtml http://www.beyondveg.com/billings-t/cal-par/calorie-paradox1... ). You can get higher by picking the right plants so let's say 300 calories per pound. At 6,000 pounds per year that's 1.8 million calories. At 2500 calories per person per day that's enough for two people for a year.
For a family of 4 that's at least twice the area, or 0.2 acres needed, and likely more as the web page says their max was 6,000 pounds. It also doesn't say which plant those were, nor what the moisture content was. After all, if a watermelon is 15 pounds then that's 400 watermelons, and each one gets 11 sq. ft, but most of that is water weight.
And as for the gardenpool, as best as I could tell, duckweed is 6 times more productive than corn, and tilapia at best consume 1.5 lbs to produce 1 lb of weight. Not all that weight will be edible, and corn isn't as productive as potatoes, but the numbers work out that it might be 2-3 times more productive than my potato number for the same area.
However, I think the numbers for duckweed yield are in pig waste water or something else with a lot of nutrients in it, and everything is here is under best conditions, which also means a lot of care taking. Which potatoes don't need.
BTW, the web site says 8 eggs per day, not 8 fish. It looks like it takes 5 months for tilapia to mature to eating weight, and 8 fish a day would mean stocking 1,200 fish at a time. What they don't say is, is duckweed the only food source for the fish or are they adding other feed?
They also mentioned that they need a swamp cooler to keep the temperature in check. Assuming that's 200W average over 24 hours, that another 4,000 kcal ("food calories"), or almost enough for two people. They get that off the grid, but if they needed to provide their own fuel source for heating and cooling (tilapia can't handle cold water) then that's another factor in the energy equation. Potatoes are hardy in northern, cool climates.
- DennisP 16y agoOops, yep, 8 eggs. They say "unlimited" tilapia but I imagine the limit there is how much of it they're willing to eat! The aquaculture idea is that wastes from the fish, and in this case the chickens, puts lots of plant nutrients in the water. Maybe not as much as pig waste water, I don't know. 200W doesn't sound like that much power...solar panels on the roof, where you can't grow crops anyway, and/or wind turbines could provide that. Those are local resources you can't otherwise use to produce food, sort of like exploiting another ecological niche. Potatoes are certainly convenient and productive, though I wouldn't want to subsist on them alone. Some people are growing them in tall boxes for easy extraction, and I was startled to see how much they claimed to produce. Re: 6000 lbs/year, that must be why they sell their stuff instead of eating it. This has been very interesting.
- dalke 16y agoWhich leads me to ask - what do the chickens eat? I see that gardenpool gives a timeline on the side. They didn't stock the pool with tilapia until May 2010. Their page at http://gardenpool.org/?page_id=242 http://gardenpool.org/?page_id=242 says "A tilapia matures from egg to harvest size (1.5 lbs) in only 6-9 months." It hasn't been long enough for the new spawn to reach edible size. How can they say "unlimited" when they don't have the experience to know if it's stable? I suspect they are being overly optimistic. Regarding 200W - I don't know what their swamp cooler needs, and they say they installed solar power. I picked 200W because that looks like a common size for portable home devices. Looking now, I think solar cells are about 20 sq ft for 200 W. Since they need to work during the night as well (though not as much), call it 40 sq. ft of otherwise unused space. I was thinking that that would go into the area calculation, but as that's about 0.1% of an acre, it's not a big contribution. And yes, I've found it interesting as well.
- DennisP 16y agoIn part they eat bugs but I wouldn't think that would be sufficient in such a contained area. It's not like they're set up in a swamp. Polyface Farms seems to feed their egg layers entirely on bugs, cattle droppings, and maybe a bit of greenery: "The Eggmobile is a 12 ft. X 20 ft. portable henhouse and the laying hens free range from it, eating bugs and scratching through cattle droppings to sanitize the pasture just like birds in nature that always follow herbivores as biological cleansers." http://www.polyfacefarms.com/products.aspx http://www.polyfacefarms.com/products.aspx Of course that's a much larger operation. They keep moving, so cleaned areas can recover. They've got forested areas nearby which play a part in the ecosystem. They claim higher overall productivity than conventional farms producing the same stuff, but nothing extreme. The peril of aquaculture is sometimes everything suddenly goes haywire and dies. Eventually the kinks get worked out and it's pretty stable, but the pool people may well have surprises in store. I do love the idea of a little self-contained ecosystem, almost like a space colony. I hope people do a lot more experiments along these lines. One idea from Marshall Savage's Millennial Project is edible algae, like spirulina. According to him it's absurdly productive in a small space, and the numbers from the "algae for fuel" people seem to bear that out. A turnkey system for producing it safely would be pretty neat, but I haven't been able to find much information. Everybody's talking biofuel. I wouldn't exactly want to subsist on algae but it could be great as a supplement in flour or stews, as fish feed, etc. How healthy it would be to eat large quantities seems to be a little uncertain, but supposedly it has a long history as a food.