5 ms·
Just as a data point, I don't believe I've gotten a fake from Amazon.
by skybrian 8y ago
Just as a data point, I don't believe I've gotten a fake from Amazon.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> Just as a data point, I don't believe I've gotten a fake from Amazon. You almost certainly have, though you may not be able to tell the difference if you don't actively look for it.
- Bartweiss 8y agoThis is one of the things that gets missed when people talk about Amazon and fakes. It's not just about the cost of keeping nonfunctional fakes out of the product stream, it's about the higher costs of legitimate products. Obviously, the USB drive stuffed in an SSD case is a fake. But that's not the only kind of fake going - printing "Seagate" on off-brand disks happens too, probably with much higher frequency. And cracking down on that would not just be harder, it would be a way bigger threat to Amazon's margins. Hopefully the PillPack supply chain stays separate or separately monitored, but this wouldn't surprise me either - most cheap online pharmacies are selling real medicine at lower margins, possibly with worse quality control.
- sah2ed 8y ago> You almost certainly have, though you may not be able to tell the difference if you don't actively look for it. The gp merely asked for anecdotal data, nothing rigorous. By disagreeing, you are indirectly implying that the commenter is somehow incapable of telling fakes from the real deal. How does anyone reliably tell fakes apart?
- bpicolo 8y agoIn my experience, it's been because the fake one breaks down in just a few days and I end up ordering a new one, after which point I notice the important differences between the two :(
- samatman 8y agoThis is not a useful data point, because there is a much larger set that this doesn't meaningfully contribute to.
- skybrian 8y agoHacker news comments are hardly a random sample, and yet here we are.
- GurnB 8y agoTry buying a PS4/PS3/Xbox controller. There is a good chance it is a good looking fake. Apple accessories are another hit or miss target.
- deminature 8y agoEven if you're buying directly from Amazon, or does this only apply to marketplace sellers?
- treis 8y agoThe problem is that inventory from different sellers is commingled unless the seller pays extra. So Amazon's controllers are in the same bin as the ones from Real Good Fakes Inc. Even if you buy from Amazon the actual product you get might have been supplied by Real Good Fakes.
- jhenkens 8y agoIs it not still shown as "Fullfilled by Amazon" but all grouped under the same product page? I presumed "Sold by Amazon.com" meant procured, shelved, and shipped directly via Amazon.com, none of this third party fulfillment crap.
- treis 8y agoIt is. The issue is that for the "shelved" step there is only one shelf per piece of inventory. So once it is one the shelf there is no guarantee about the origin. Amazon does allow sellers to pay extra to keep their inventory separate. I don't know if the stuff Amazon sells is kept that way, but there's no guarantee it is.
- mehrdadn 8y agoI want to know this too. "Fulfilled by Amazon" to me sounds very different than sold by Amazon.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]