6 ms·
Yes, it is a serious theory, taken seriously by serious scientists, and seriously investigated by them. It can be hard to tell through the popular science stor
by jerf 8y ago
Yes, it is a serious theory, taken seriously by serious scientists, and seriously investigated by them.
It can be hard to tell through the popular science stories, where the author is typically unable to relay anything about this research without adding "woo woo" sounds and wiggling their fingers, but it's a real theory.
One thing that may be worth remembering is that in the real theory, the "simulation" is not necessarily running on "a supercomputer just like what we have, only way bigger", which is actually a silly idea for various reasons, and we also do not know that the simulation is literally simulating every particle and every cubic inch of space in the most accurate possible way (i.e., for all we know, far away galaxies could just be a few megabytes in size, rather than fully simulated to the nth degree). The "Great Simulator" is not required to run anything remotely resembling our physics. What seems an absurdly large computation may be smaller than it appears, and may not be an absurdly large amount of a universe running on fundamentally different physics.
(Occasionally when I'm bored, I noodle around with a theory of cellular automata in which the universe has infinite computation power by virtue of being able to split a cell in half or quarters, that then runs at double-speed relative to the outside. If this is done recursively the universe has arbitrary computation abilities relative to the "top level". I've never worked it into anything usable, but I think it can give a flavor of why we should not be sure that our simulation host is necessarily as staggered by the computation as we would be. We are not even capable of saying that they aren't running an exponentially-expensive quantum approximation algorithm with the entire universe actually arbitrary-precision integers under the hood. The staggering amount of computation that represents may not bother them at all.)
It is not a theory that is, strictly speaking, falsifiable thanks to Church-Turing equivalence, but there are ways in which it could potentially (to any arbitrary degree of confidence you may want) be confirmed if it is true. To take one degenerate case, if the Great Simulator broke silence and starting wildly breaking the laws of physics to get our attention, that would certainly put a lot of probability mass on the "we're a simulation" theory. There are less extreme cases we could conceivably pick up on, that just fits into an HN comment nicely.
- olavk 8y ago> It is not a theory that is, strictly speaking, falsifiable, So in what ways is it a "serious theory"?
- jerf 8y agoWell, along with the religion case that whatshisface points out, there's also the problem that any theory of the nature of the universe has this problem. The problem here is not with the theory of the universe per se, but the fundamental limits of science itself. Despite what seems to be a popular opinion, we are not actually obligated to curl up into a ball on the floor and cry about our inability to know anything just because science can't be definitive on some point. We just need to be aware of the limits of our knowledge. We have no choice; even in just our day-to-day lives, we are required to make all kinds of decisions for which science is either quiet, insufficiently informative, or (and this one may really hurt to think about too much) simply wrong.
- olavk 8y ago> Despite what seems to be a popular opinion, we are not actually obligated to curl up into a ball on the floor and cry about our inability to know anything I have no idea what you are referring to here. Can you be bit more specific about what viewpoint or philosophy you are satirizing?
- rbanffy 8y ago> So in what ways is it a "serious theory"? People defend it with a straight face?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- da_chicken 8y agoWell, it's a little more complicated than that. It's only not falsifiable because nobody has devised a test. It's a hypothesis without an experiment. That doesn't mean that people aren't trying [0]. If it is a simulation, you're not going to clip through the wall by running against a corner and jumping for an hour. The thing is, we don't know where this line of reasoning would even lead. I mean, people used to think that light had to travel in little packets through luminiferous aether [1] and look where that investigation led: Einstein, special relativity, atomic weapons and power, nuclear medicine, etc. Let's say the universe is fundamentally indistinguishable from a computer simulation. What consequences does that have? What does that say about the types of math that can be used to describe the universe? Or, perhaps better, the types of math that shouldn't be used to describe the universe? What does that say about our ability to model a portion of the universe and therefore predict outcomes? Does it have implications for stochastic processes? Indeed, where is the stochasticism coming from? Is everything predictable or is there some fundamental randomness? On the other hand, what if we can show that the universe is distinguishable from a computer simulation. What does that mean for our understanding of the universe as it exists? Does it reveal a fundamental aspect of reality that we have missed, or a limitation of our mathematics, or a fault in our computer models or design, etc.? We're dogs learning calculus here, and the universe isn't obligated to make sense. Even if we can never find a useful test for this hypothesis, the line of thinking itself potentially leads us into new areas of discovery. [0]: https://gizmodo.com/5950832/how-to-tell-if-the-universe-is-a-computer-simulation https://gizmodo.com/5950832/how-to-tell-if-the-universe-is-a... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminiferous_aether https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminiferous_aether
- whatshisface 8y ago>It is not a theory that is, strictly speaking, falsifiable, but there are ways in which it could potentially be confirmed if it is true. It's worth noting that most religions are in exactly the same situation.
- madaxe_again 8y agoThe great simulator doesn’t even need to be great. It only needs to be good enough to simulate heavily time-dilated reality for one individual. A highly detailed, highly realistic first person game only needs to simulate the immediate draw of the player character to be useful - you don’t have to draw every NPC’s worldview - they just need basic path finding, at best.
- om3n 8y agoYou are referencing solipsism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solipsism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solipsism
- madaxe_again 8y agoI’m well aware of solipsism, but there’s nothing to say that a convincing simulation couldn’t be purely solipsistic.
- perl4ever 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/They_(Heinlein) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/They_(Heinlein)
- samirillian 8y agoWait, why isn't it falsifiable? Edit, oh, duh. Yeah, my main take is that there should be evidence for it being a simulation, and in lieu of said evidence it should be assumed untrue
- thraway180306 8y agoOf course it is falsifiable. If you can't specify in what way you recover physics from your simulation and what computation actually occurs in your simulation then, apart from the word "simulation" making no sense, you don't have any theory to either formulate or test at all. There, falsified for you. In particular cellular automata fit that description. It has been beaten to death since the 80's and leads nowhere, unless of course anybody counts Wolfram a (new kind of) scientist. Same problem we have in quantum gravity. We just can't recover known physics from anything at all, any combination of theories at all it seems. That includes all known instances of computation, it just blows up. Also, Church-Turing has nothing to do with basic problems here, in particular because eventual simulating computation would be unlike computation we know (which again, makes the word lose any meaning here).
- olavk 8y agoThat is not what falsifiable means. Falsifiable means that an experiment can be devised which could result in observations which contradict the predictions of the theory.
- thraway180306 8y agoFalsification is a philosophical issue. Some say it's important. Some could live without. See Feyerabend. None of that matter if there is no theory in the first place. Much was tried. 't Hooft got as far as holographic principle. And there's still no theory at all.