3 ms·
I sit squarely in the "insider" role here, and normally would be very interested in anyone who is proactively calling me up and saying "i want to work on your t
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
I sit squarely in the "insider" role here, and normally would be very interested in anyone who is proactively calling me up and saying "i want to work on your team" - but to avoid breaking any protocols / laws we would want the interviewee to come in the front door as usual.
All I suspect that is happening here is if I sign up as one of your insiders, you drop me interesting candidates and then they have to go through the normal channels. So I may be missing the point but if an individual reaches out through LinkedIn looking for a job that's a plus sign, of a recruiter does it, that's just the usual noise. What is being added?
Also, why are the interviewees paying? It cannot be to pay me (the insider) cos that breaks many ethical and probably legal rules. And if they are successful I am guessing you get a cut?
- 0898 8y ago> Also, why are the interviewees paying? It cannot be to pay me (the insider) cos that breaks many ethical and probably legal rules. Why?
- aeontech 8y agoBecause that’s equivalent to bribery?
- dchhugani 8y agoI respect that this is a new way of doing things, but would disagree. With The Lobby, they're not obliged to give you a referral, a job, an interview or anything of the sort. They only get paid for their time and insights. Our thesis is that the "insider" has in their head (even in the junior-most roles) incredible insight into what it takes to land a job they have, how to position their story, what recruiting timelines are like and more. This information is not available online always. Sometimes, it's never posted online at all. For the most competitive roles, you tell your team and they tell their friends and a pile of resumes come in before any "outsider" has a chance to figure out they're even hiring.
- dchhugani 8y agoTo reiterate part of the above comment, we think that this is really life-changing insight and advice. It's definitely free to ask people for help on LinkedIn or go through your network but think of how inefficient and random that is. If I don't happen to be a 2nd degree connection of someone at the company and group I dream of working in, and they don't answer my cold email - then what do I do? Further - if you have interviews coming up, people with friends on the inside have a HUGE advantage in how to prepare. We think that should be accessible, and it's a paid service because as much as I'd like, most people won't do this for free unless it's for a friend or family member. I was one of those people who'd spend hours helping for free, but I could only help people who wanted to work in my specific team. When time came to refer them to someone else, it was really hard to get busy people to agree to do this.
- dchhugani 8y agoThanks for the feedback. I should be a bit more clear - the calls today are not really meant as a way for you to refer the person to your company. We started that way, and learned it was both shady and really ineffective (i.e. what are the odds that if I choose to speak with someone at team A in Goldman Sachs that they will want to refer me, and that that referral will result in an interview or a job). Instead, today this is mainly coaching and practice. Later, we're aiming to get insiders to "Rate" the candidates they speak with and have the best-rated ones get sent over to 10,20,100 companies that we partner with as qualified leads. This helps candidates get noticed more and "credentialize" themselves because someone (or many) in the industry screened them over 30m calls and thought they were a good fit. This lets companies see an added signal that is not their resume, their school, their GPA, or their LinkedIn. It also helps companies discover diverse & non-obvious talent, something we know first-hand is an important issue to them. Even for the companies who don't care about diversity in the traditional sense, they need to diversify their pool because everyone is going after the same 2% of "good-on-paper" candidates from Harvard and Stanford, because no one can cost effectively vet candidates from the much larger rest. Interviewees pay because this is time-consuming and valuable insight from the insiders, and because otherwise we rely on altruism which we feel does not scale.
- slap_shot 8y agoI don't think you understand what this product is. Looking at your bio/comment history, I don't think you work in a field that this product is targeted to.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dchhugani 8y agoI should also add - when people call you up directly and say "I want to work on your team" the dynamic is incredibly different than when you use The Lobby. On the candidate side, this entire conversation is about impressing you and making you potentially like me. I'm not going to ask you real questions that I'd ask a friend on the inside on culture, compensation, recruiting process. And on your end, it's basically an interview. You're not really on the "candidate's side," you're evaluating them and judging everything they say while comparing that to other candidates you speak with.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoI think I get it. I would personally be more comfortable perhaps with a meet-up style arrangement - there will be 8 candidates and 2 or 3 "fintech insiders", and there is some speed dating style chats, and group style feedback. Otherwise, and I can read you are earnest and have thought about this, otherwise I just feel it is the wrong side of a very grey and vague line. The paying for one on one advice seems ... odd. But, and I suspect this is very important, I only have the perspective of a white well educated english speaking middle aged male with attendant confidence. If I was missing any of those I suspect that my perspective might chnage. If the university alumni team for any university / boot camp called and asked me to do the group style approach I would probably clear my diary. So I am not sure why the pay for advice part bothers me so much.
- dchhugani 8y agoI think I understand why it bothers you. I think if you heard one of the calls or how it happens you'd understand the magic behind them. Paid dynamic just makes it all about making it valuable to the candidate. It also lets the candidate say/ask anything in a 1-on-1 private & personalized dynamic. The problem with AMA's or meetup style things is again it's not as personalized or private. But those are things we want to tinker with as well.
- michaelt 8y agoAlso, why are the interviewees paying? It cannot be to pay me (the insider) It's a question of whether the insider is on your side of the table or the company's. There are some pieces of career advice that are, if not employer-hostile, then at least not entirely employer friendly. For example, will my strong foreign accent block me from promotion into the upper echelons of your company? Someone on the company's side of the table would tell me what the recruitment website says: "We're an equal opportunities employer and don't discriminate, communication skills are important of course" whereas someone on my side of the table might give a more frank response, like "Yes you're going to need to work on that"
- dchhugani 8y agoExactly right. Any kind of professional conversation is very different than a conversation designated to helping the candidate prep. The goals and motivations on both sides are fundamentally different.
- ShabbosGoy 8y ago> For example, will my strong foreign accent block me from promotion into the upper echelons of your company? The thing is, if people can’t understand you when you communicate, you will have major league issues with your team in my experience. I had a rockstar “10x” programmer on my team who was fired because his communication style was...let’s just say he wasn’t a fountain of unbridled optimism. He would yell at interns and generally treat people like shit, that was his communication style. The thing is, he is a genuinely nice person. It’s just that his negative view of the world seeped into his communication style, and rubbed a lot of people the wrong way. I’m not disagreeing with your original point, though. You can get unfiltered career advice that may or may not align with whatever ideals the company claims to have.