3 ms·
> It is not forbidden nor "stealing" to print out for personal use. Why do you think that? Are you talking about German or US copyright law? Can you cite the l
by dahart 8y ago
> It is not forbidden nor "stealing" to print out for personal use.
Why do you think that? Are you talking about German or US copyright law? Can you cite the law you're thinking of?
"[US] Copyright law does not contain any caveat that allows unauthorized parties to make personal copies of copyrighted products. However, under the doctrine of 'fair use,' individuals may be permitted to make backup copies or archival copies of some materials as long as certain conditions are met. Creating a copy of a copyrighted work for your own ease of use is likely to be considered copyright infringement. But if you are making a copy so that you may use a copyrighted product in case the original is stolen, damaged or destroyed, your conduct may fall within the doctrine of fair use."
https://info.legalzoom.com/copyright-law-making-personal-copies-22200.html https://info.legalzoom.com/copyright-law-making-personal-cop...
- kchr 8y agoSo your point is that a screenshot (one frame) of a movie that is copyright protected would be equivalent to reproducing the movie...?
- dahart 8y ago> So your point is that a screenshot (one frame) of a movie that is copyright protected would be equivalent to reproducing the movie...? No, my point is that "personal use" is not an exception to copyright law. Where did you read something about equating screenshots of movies with full movies? You are not allowed to copy entire movies and claim it's legal because it's only for "personal use". Screenshots are sometimes legal under fair use, mostly as long as you are making a parody or commentary. Screenshots of movies are sometimes illegal. If you somehow had access to the next Avengers movie, and you leaked a screenshot by posting it to reddit, you might well get sued under copyright law. Copying images from a web site falls into the same restrictions. It is not automatically legal to reproduce images from a website without permission, even for personal use.
- freehunter 8y ago>But if you are making a copy so that you may use a copyrighted product in case the original is stolen, damaged or destroyed, your conduct may fall within the doctrine of fair use That to me sounds like you can print something since web content can disappear at any moment.
- dahart 8y agoYou can try to justify it that way, but if you print it and then hang it on your wall, or in your office, to enjoy it as art, like @estsauver wants to do, then you might no longer be in the realm of fair use, you might even be squarely in copyright violation territory.
- lazyasciiart 8y agoYea, just get an old screen, hang it on the wall, and display the image directly from their site. tada!