4 ms·
"It’s one thing for theoretical physicists to chase the wrong theory about fundamental particles for 25 years with nothing to show for it but high-prestige publ
by mcguire 8y ago
"It’s one thing for theoretical physicists to chase the wrong theory about fundamental particles for 25 years with nothing to show for it but high-prestige publications. That’s fun."
Nothing to show for it? Nothing?
Supersymmetry is a very successful theory. Alzheimer's research had actually learned a lot. Sure, there are a lot of problems with how science is done, but there are a lot of problems work how anything is done.
If you go into science expecting that your theory is the perfect answer and that anything else is failure, you are going to be disappointed.
- Bartweiss 8y agoThose examples seriously undermined the article. If you want to be annoyed that an MRI of a dead fish gets publishable results, go ahead. I am too. But this very quickly took a detour into "sometimes hypotheses are wrong, therefore science is stupid". We haven't had 25 years of a wrong belief about Alzheimers, just 25 years of "shit, this is hard to understand". And given the history of non-scientific-theory medicine (we cured scurvy ~5 times before word got out), it still seems like a winning score. I know it's fair to criticize something without having a better solution, but it's still jarring to see science attacked on topics where it has a better track record than anything else ever devised.
- extralego 8y agoI agree, but I won’t not disagree. We are due a resurgence in responsible Hegelian dialectics, but it’s easier said than done. I think both arguments fail the test in this case.