4 ms·
The US has played nicer than most countries were they to enjoy its economic might and pre-eminence[1]. Few countries would allow their workforce to endure econ
by mc32 8y ago
The US has played nicer than most countries were they to enjoy its economic might and pre-eminence[1]. Few countries would allow their workforce to endure economic self-inflicted hardship while maintaining an economic advantage in negotiating trade. But the US has, over the years, put up with unfair trade from Japan, SKorea, China, Some of Europe in the name of "free trade". I don't begrudge allowing some disadvantage with regard some developing nations --but not developed nations.
For fair trade to work, it has to be bi-lateral. If you unilaterally do fair trade but your partner doesn't, you may do your principle good, but you're selling out your worker for principle.
Since Reagan, maybe before, the blue collar worker of America has seen their government give in and cower in the face of unfair trade saying, "we'll make it up in services" or "your goods will be cheaper". But what good does cheap do you when you have no job and no money? They never saw their lot get better. People wonder why people are now "working poor".
When I was in middle and HS, my bus drivers and janitors (they were not "cleaning engineers" just yet), were able to raise a family with decency. No way that happens now.
As Michael Moore poignantly, albeit ironically, said, finally, someone stood up to the corporations and said, "no more". I'll stop the hemorrhaging. One AFL-CIO in PA, the other day, endorsed a Repub. As an atheist, I have to say, Good God, what happened to the Dems? They sold out the American worker in favor of the multinational, transnational capitalists. If they don't watch out, they will lose labor to Repubs.
[1]Just look at how China manages its advantage in Africa, LatAM, etc. Japan in SEAsia, Russia with Former SU repubs., etc.
- gonvaled 8y agoNicer yes, but not nice at all: fake wars, dollar bullying and rules ownership (global IP and trade laws are made by US for US) has given the US a tilted playing field. The US is still by far the richest country. If it has blue collar problems maybe it should rethink the way richness and costs are distributed. Maybe the US led capitalism needs a rethink. And blamimg the world for this ideology is quite astounding: the US has pushed for it for over 60 years. And more: what do you have against 95% of the world"s blue collar workforce?
- mc32 8y ago>And more: what do you have against 95% of the world"s blue collar workforce? Nothing. But they are not mine. As they don't care about my blue collar sisters and brothers, nor do I care about theirs. People think redundant blue collar workers should retrain, get new skills. That's nice. Usually the service jobs don't pay as well and it's naïve to think 50 and 60 yos have the bandwidth to retrain and achieve similar status in a new career. EU and Japan enforce IP just as much as we do. They may be even be more stringent. If Trump is successful in this, he has a decent chance at making it possible for blue collar whites and blacks to achieve the potential Bruce Springsteen saw in them.
- gonvaled 8y ago> But they are not mine Well, trade war it is then. And it might not be so easy to win against 95% of the world. Specially seeing how unfairly the US has been acting internationally: trade disputes are minor issues compared to the military and monetary abuses done by the US.
- mc32 8y agoIf you want unfair monetary abuses, talk to the IMF/World Bank[1] and China's "loans" around Asia and Africa. I think we have retreated from military affairs compared to the Bush and Obama years (to the chagrin of Dem and Repub neo-cons). In trade, we've acted too fairly with the other developed nations. [1]https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/oct/09/the-world-bank-and-the-imf-wont-admit-their-policies-are-the-problem https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/oct/09/the-world-b...
- gonvaled 8y agoNo, I prefer to talk US bullying to anybody willing to swap the dollar for euros for example (Iranian Oil Bourse). And it is quite rich to say "we have reduced military affairs": the EU is suffering a massive migration crisis caused by the lie-based military intervention in Irak over 15 years ago, while the US refuses to take any of those migrants.
- brbrodude 8y agothat's what capitalists do, what did you expect? lol
- mc32 8y agoJapan is capitalist, so is South Korea, Taiwan, etc. Still, they do protect their blue collar workers without selling them out to transnational capitalists. I'm not an anti-capitalist, but I am for protecting your own workers in the face of international shenanigans.
- brbrodude 8y agoyeah they were protecting while USA corporations were expanding, too bad it doesn't trickle down that good. There was no disadvantage for the actual ruler, the profits. So.. Yeah, what was gonna happen happened. Also, no maternity leave, no paternity leave, no social safety net, no unions, no paid vacations, etc, etc, etc. How did it happen? It's not really that of a mystery, they just had a very long strip-tease on the workers, removing protection piece-by-piece, for the 'job creators'! you may not be anti-capitalist, but capitalism is anti-you. Anyway, I'm an anti-capitalist so that's my point of view.
- mc32 8y agoThose countries are a different culture. Some of these things are seen as personal failings. There is also more reliance on family than govt or charity --the tradition for charity is limited. To be frank, I like seeing the government doing something to protect against unfair trade practices. At the same time, I wish unions would go back to their roots and work to protect workers rather than their current raison d'etre which is to perpetuate itself. When was the last time Unions demanded their reps push back on unfair trade?
- gonvaled 8y agoYou, and most americans, seem to be fixed with deficit in goods, but at the same time do not even mention the massive trade surplus that the US has in services. By some measures, total deficit with the EU for example is fairly balanced. I assume that you are in favour for a rebalancing in services trade too?
- mc32 8y agoIf we are trading in services unfairly, sure. But we're likely not. Others will put up many different barriers to impede fair trade. The US does less of that nonsense, on balance.
- gonvaled 8y agoWhat about unfair technological lead due to government support? The internet is a DARPA spinoff. What about unfair IP rules due to overwhelming control of international organizations and standards? What about unfair tax dodging by US multinationals, not paying tax on profits in the corresponding countries by abusing an international tax system made by the US for the US?
- gwicks56 8y agoMore to the point, what about the "exorbitant privilege" the USA enjoys from having the worlds reserve currency? If other nations make a concerted effort to ditch this set up, the USA can no longer run massive deficits. Imagine the USA trying to run a balanced budget immediately.
- mc32 8y agoThat's over-stated. I don; think the US cares too much about that at all. In fact it encouraged the Euro.
- gonvaled 8y agoThat happened in the golden era of multilateralism, after the fall of the Berlin Wall and the Soviet Union. The US realized how unfair the situation was, and took some timid steps to start a rebalancing of the situation, allowing for the creation of a competing currency. It is not that the Euro was not a threat to the dollar, it is simply that the threat was minor then, and that it was plain and simple the right thing to do: renounce to unfair advantages in order to move to a more just world. The US continues to unfairly abuse the dollar as world currency, and dismissing this fact can be a costly misjudgment: fair for the world, but painful for the US.