3 ms·
Should I just take down the docs and forget about this? Why wouldn't you do just that? It's their IP, and they asked politely (as politely as you're going to g
by mikestew 8y ago
Should I just take down the docs and forget about this?
Why wouldn't you do just that? It's their IP, and they asked politely (as politely as you're going to get out of a lawyer).
It feels wrong that a billion-dollar startup is threatening
What threat? The strongest word in there is "demand", and (IANAL) I believe that to be standard legalese for "could you not do that?" The implication, of course, is if you don't quit doing that, they'll sue.
so I didn't necessarily want to encourage this behavior.
What behavior is that? "Could you not distribute our IP/documents w/o our permission? 'k, thx." Because that's what Google's Legalese->English translator gives me.
I mean, if you think you have a legal leg to stand on, knock yourself out. But from where I stand (and keeping in mind that IANAL), it looks like you took their IP, passed it around, and now wonder why they're being mean. Perhaps try putting yourself in their place for a few moments?
- arkades 8y ago> What threat? The strongest word in there is "demand", and (IANAL) I believe that to be standard legalese for "could you not do that?“ Yep, they’re officially called “Demand Letters.” It’s legalese, not stormtroopering.
- mygo 8y ago> What threat? > if you don't quit doing that, they'll sue. I think you answered your own question. But there’s nothing inherently wrong about a lawyer protecting his client / employer’s IP. Sometimes lawyers have to make threats to do that. It’s within their rights to threaten (make demands). If they don’t enforce their trademarks they can even lose them. You don’t have to adhere to their demands, and if you think you’re in the right and have the financial resources you should probably lawyer up and stand your ground and see what the court ruling says. But from what I’ve seen Magic Leap is a very secretive company. Secretive organizations will want control of the distribution of information. It’s just how they operate. Apple will fire their best engineers with a single leak. IANAL but if being in control of every inconsequential piece of information is that important to them (even if it’s an API documentation that is distributed to developers), they’re not letting off on this.