6 ms·
How McKinsey Lost Its Way in South Africa
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- olivermarks 8y agohttps://asiancorrespondent.com/2011/10/what-drove-rajat-gupta-stray-greed-or-ego/#DP7SyYK1zBOO5bKE.97 https://asiancorrespondent.com/2011/10/what-drove-rajat-gupt... https://www.cnbc.com/id/41853809 https://www.cnbc.com/id/41853809 Many McKinsey partners were consumed by greed and exposed during the 2008 banking meltdown and aftermath. This NYT piece is essentially a pr whitewash despite all the details and acceptance of failings. There are plenty of good people lower down at McKinsey but people like Rajat Gupta did a lot of damage to McKinsey's credibility worldwide imo.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Rajat Gupta did a lot of damage to McKinsey's credibility worldwide This claim is correct, but I think we can reference better sources . The SEC complaint [1] "alleges that, among other things, Rajat K. Gupta tipped his business associate Raj Rajaratnam, Galleon Management’s founder and managing general partner, to confidential information Gupta learned in the course of his duties as a member of the Board of Directors of The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. The complaint alleges that Gupta disclosed material nonpublic information concerning Berkshire Hathaway Inc.’s $5 billion investment in Goldman Sachs in September 2008, and concerning Goldman Sachs’s financial results for both the second and the fourth quarter of 2008. Rajaratnam used the information he learned from Gupta to trade profitably in certain Galleon hedge funds" [2]. Somewhat pertinently, Gupta did not violate his responsibilities to Goldman Sachs as a McKinsey officer, but as a GS Board member. [1] https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/2011/comp22140.pdf https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/2011/comp22140.pdf [2] https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/2012/lr22582.htm https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/2012/lr22582.htm
- sonnyblarney 8y agoOk, I find this very problematic - along the lines of 'Hey, our country is massively corrupt and dysfunctional, and these Westerners came in and didn't do really anything really wrong or corrupt, there are other actors who are clearly to blame, but let's blame the Western Colonialists! This is a bad meme. First - don't trust McKinsey or any consultants to implement anything unless it's been done before and clear. They're smart people who make slides. Sometimes they have specific knowledge. Second - it seems as though they were a little aggressive on pricing, who can blame them? It's not their fault - whoever was on the procurement and oversight side on the fence is definitely the guilty/stupid/corrupt party on that one. There doesn't seem to be any indication that McKinsey cheated on that, I mean, literally they are even admitting 'maybe we could have charged less' like a self-aware faux pas? Would we expect that of any business anywhere? It seemed they knew there was some risk and tried to investigate it legitimately, and then backed away ultimately when things were known. So that's not so bad. And yet - it looks like there were obvious corrupt actors in this - Gupta's - surprise (!) who where knowingly and specifically trying to screw over the system! --> So why isn't this article about the Guptas? Shouldn't the headline be: "Indian-South African Gupta family swindles South Africa yet again?" The evidence in the article doesn't really indict McKinsey of anything other than 'knowing maybe they shouldn't have been getting into something risky'. Sure. But they're clearly not the bad guys, and not even 'knowing enablers'. The problems in this area have little to do with McKinsey.
- origen 8y agoSorry, McKinsey: - Partnered with a local provider (Trillian) after minimal/token due diligence (despite ample reason to be extraordinarily suspicious, and in contravention of internal policy), to win an unprecedentedly lucrative contract; - Even when the Gupta ownership connection to Trillian was revealed internally, refused to amend the terms of the engagement; - Only dropped Trillian when forced by public scrutiny; - And then tried to cover up the entire debacle, actively misleading investigators and journalists. What part of this has "very little to do" with McKinsey, exactly? It's quite clear that ethical and/or legal scrutiny was lessened, no doubt given the size of the potential prize on the other side.
- deleted 8y ago
- trhway 8y ago>Since President Trump took office, McKinsey has greatly expanded consulting for Immigration and Customs Enforcement through that agency’s office of “detention, compliance and removals.” Now ICE need the consultants for that! I wonder whether McKinsey had anything to do with that risk assessment software update discussed today?
- anonu 8y agoMy favorite McKinsey failure is the one where UBS (the Swiss Investment Bank) brought them in circa 2000 to understand how they could better expand in the USA. McKinsey said something along the lines of "Well - you guys have very little subprime mortgages exposure and we think this is the next hot thing - you guys need to move all your chips into subprime". Fast forward 7 to 8 years and the US was hit with one of the biggest financial crises ever. Caused by what? Sub-prime debt. UBS had some of the biggest debt writeoffs - maybe 2nd to Citi. Source: There is a post-mortem report that UBS released after the financial crises that explains how they got there.
- mikorym 8y agoI think the article is relevant in addressing the private sector's partial accountability in the general scene of corruption and exasperation in South Africa. It is not that McKinsey could be blamed for Eskom's general inefficiencies but rather that it shares responsibility in the lack of a managerial and efficiency turnaround at state companies like Eskom. The general rhetoric is to blame the government (perhaps correctly), but the present article I think does not attempt to singly shoulder responsibility on McKinsey. It shows how government inefficiency may lead to a general free-for-all or at least a atmosphere of being exempt from justice in the private sector as well. My summary on the matter would be that many South Africans have the desire to build towards a more economically competent country and that complications in bureaucracy and malevolent actors complicate this. This is a country where anyone rather easily can weaponise different kinds of racism or partiality that degenerates into a debate about whom we should blame. In preventing this particular counter productive and frequent exercise perhaps it is useful to remain as objective as one may be in identifying responsible parties, letting them be held accountable in the corresponding legal framework, and from there focusing on actual problems such as the state of disrepair of Eskom run power stations. It may well be that action by private companies would catalyse the process towards an efficient and economically sound South Africa. However, what this articles shows is how an internationally respected private firm fell into the same traps that local politicians do.
- jessaustin 8y agoAlso troubling was the fact that McKinsey had won the contract without competitive bidding. One finds this nugget more than halfway through longish TFA. This really buries the lede. Without a competitive bid process, a public organization is at the mercy of its stupidest and most corrupt officials. When a tiny town in the middle of nowhere wants an abandoned building torn down, they don't call the mayor's cousin. They open an RFP, and the only way the mayor's cousin gets the job is if her bid is the least expensive for the town. Perhaps developing nations can't be expected to have any officials who know how such things should work (!), but every McKinsey employee damn well ought to have known that a giant secret contract is necessarily corrupt.
- hectormalot 8y agoDon’t really agree with the idea that everything should be tendered. Tenders are a poor fit for complex situations where the complete path is not clear. To use your analogy: what if the tender included selecting the building to tear down as well as demolishing it? Without further specification, the winner of the tender could have an abnormally low price, be incentivized to pick the easiest building to demolish, and leave the rubble on site because you forgot to define what demolish actually means. In coding terms: if you can do it waterfall then you can probably tender it, otherwise I’m not so sure.
- jessaustin 8y agoIt wasn't an analogy. This literally happens every day. All towns have a process in place for selecting which local hazards to demolish. Of course for more involved requirements it may be good to break the process into more than one step. It's possible that no one knows what's wrong with the public power utility. If you have to hire McKinsey because corruption, negotiate a simple fee for them to run an actual RFP process for an actual management consulting engagement for you. One of the requirements for that RFP will be that theirs cannot be the only viable bid. If they can't get a bid from another firm that has consulted for publicly-owned utilities, they don't get their RFP fee either.
- known 8y agoWhich caste is looting India? https://www.quora.com/Which-caste-is-looting-India/answer/Adarsh-Sapoota https://www.quora.com/Which-caste-is-looting-India/answer/Ad...
- monique212 8y agoI have actually experienced a lot in my relationship, my husband never cared about me and I always did everything to make him happy. I have tried so many ways to find out what was distracting him but nothing worked. I am really glad enriquehackdemon11@gmail. com +16282035722 was able to handle this mess for me I am really excited. they also have refund policy if you are not satisfy with their work nice job thank you so much