3 ms·
Our medical ethics prevents us from directly studying consciousness in a way that would give us strong casual explanation. I'm unsure if we'd ever allow it actu
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
Our medical ethics prevents us from directly studying consciousness in a way that would give us strong casual explanation. I'm unsure if we'd ever allow it actually.
We might get around the edges, but until you can show you can directly turn consciousness off (and back on again probably) in vivo, in the same way we try to do with every other "effective" medical treatment, the strength of any proof is going to be inconclusive.
The closest we'll probably get is eventually creating some system which convincingly displays the characteristics that humans recognize as "Consciousness." Hopefully we can stop talking about it then.
- lisper 8y ago> until you can show you can directly turn consciousness off (and back on again But we can, and we do -- every day. That's exactly what general anesthetics do. It's also what happens during sleep.
- haskellandchill 8y agoHm really? Try more drugs, like ketamine. Dissociatives in general will give you an interesting perspective on these issues. Personally, I feel conscious in my dreams while sleeping. Also there are gradations of sleep state, such as the one where you don't get high quality sleep because you partially monitor your scary environment.
- sewercake 8y agoEvan Thompson explores these ideas further in his book 'Waking, Dreaming, Being' if you're so keen. A brilliant guy, who successfully integrates information from various cognitive disciplines, though he can be dry at times.
- vilhelm_s 8y ago"The only thing we know about consciousness is that it is soluble in chloroform" ---Luca Turin
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoYou seem to confuse observing that a phenomena happens with understanding it. A good friend of mine from college is an anethestist and we've had long conversations about this and he says that consensus is that nobody knows how their drugs work. They just have extensive history with the "dials" they use so to speak.
- lisper 8y agoI'm not saying that the existence of anesthetic technology means we understand consciousness. That's obviously not the case. I'm just pointing out that what the OP listed as the limiting factor on our understanding is already in hand.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoBeing able to turn off consciousness in a gross way is in no way equivalent to being able to prove that its origin is chemical. A complete chemical theory of consciousness would need to explain not just how general anaesthetics work - a field which is much less comprehensive than most people realise - but also how exactly LSD, psiloscybin, DMT, and other hallucinogens produce all the very specific and very different effects they do.
- kolpa 8y agoIs there proof that anesthetics and sleep cause loss of consciousness, or only that they cause amnesia (retroactive discontinuity of conscioussnes), which we perhaps mis-name "loss of consciousness"
- lisper 8y agoLoss of consciousness and amnesia turn out to be the exact same thing.