8 ms·
I remember the outrage when Zuckerberg bought Insta for $1bn. The Internet was filled with bubble-theorist. Say what you want about Zuckerberg but the guy was
by csomar 8y ago
I remember the outrage when Zuckerberg bought Insta for $1bn. The Internet was filled with bubble-theorist.
Say what you want about Zuckerberg but the guy was well ahead of his time and could see how things would evolve and what tick with people brains.
- ionised 8y agoIt's a shame he couldn't put that vision to a better use than advertising.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoAdvertising is a very legitimate way of making money, lots of it. Now tracking people all over the web and other shady things, are a different story.
- coldtea 8y ago>Advertising is a very legitimate way of making money Yes, just not a way to make something that improves our lives. Or even if you manage to make something that improves our lives, advertising is an incentive to pervert it and hold it back (e.g. you create a social network so people from all over the world can meet, then ads make you cripple it, force feed BS to them, milk them with spam, exploit their private data, and so on...)
- J5892 8y agoHow would you monetize it without ads? Instagram would have died an early death if you had to pay for it, and hiding certain features behind a pay wall would alienate 90% of the users.
- coldtea 8y ago>Instagram would have died an early death if you had to pay for it That would be a bonus. >hiding certain features behind a pay wall would alienate 90% of the users Only before they have conditioned differently from an industry that has been legally allowed to trade private information for ad money.
- ionised 8y ago> Instagram would have died an early death if you had to pay for it I honestly don't think that would be a loss for humanity.
- PerfectElement 8y agoI was able to build a legitimate business that improves people's lives. In order to make my product discoverable, I had to spend some money on advertising (not on Facebook in particular). There was no other reliable way to reach my target audience. I have also bought many products from other businesses that have made my life better. In most instances, I have only become aware of these products because these businesses have spent money on ad campaigns.
- coldtea 8y ago>I have also bought many products from other businesses that have made my life better. In most instances, I have only become aware of these products because these businesses have spent money on ad campaigns. That could have been a valid argument in 1970. Today we have the internet. Instead of advertising it's not perfectly possible and easy to have other means of discoverability: a) professional product reviews - a review site visit or Google search away b) actual user reviews -- an aggregator site or Google search away c) the product makers marketing material on their own website d) blogs from people using the product e) forums with people exchanging advice/complaints about the product f) videos of people unboxing, using, showcasing, etc the product g) the specs of the product, product manual, photos, etc online h) online communities around a product category i) for digital products, one could also try a trial/time limited/shortened /watermarked version of them j) for products we encounter physically on some shop's shelves and want to know more about them, a quick Google search or QR Code can take us to the product page (and/or all of the above) Unlike advertisement, none of these give an unfair lead to the maker than can spend more campaign money. What's best, most of these add informational value (like scores, real world complaints, professional reviewing, etc) that ads, by definition, don't have. We literally have more ways than ever to discover products, and to find the best products. Advertising is just random producers (random quality wise: just the company with the bigger pockets) shouting to make their wares stand out.
- mateo411 8y agoI like how you brought up all of those examples for means of discovery. However, I think that almost all of those are a form of advertising. Perhaps the forum where people are giving advice would not be advertising. If any of these are on the internet, then people there will be pixel trackers, and people are going to measure the distinct number of impressions. I don't think this is a bad thing.
- 394549 8y ago> Say what you want about Zuckerberg but the guy was well ahead of his time and could see how things would evolve and what tick with people brains. Did he really predict that, or did he just see an upcoming potential competitive threat and buy it? I feel bad for the founders of Instagram. They could have been the next Zuckerberg(s) (as Instagram seems to be taking over as Facebook seems to be starting to fade), but instead they're subordinates in Zuckerberg's empire.
- EpicEng 8y agoYou "feel sorry" for two people in their mid-twenties who made anywhere from $100M to $400M selling their 15 month old company (while making the other 11 employees rich along the way.) Ok. Beyond that, why do you assume the valuation would be exactly the same had they not sold to FB?
- balls187 8y agoIt was cash & stock deal, so presumably the 100M-400M could be worth more given FB stock price.
- murukesh_s 8y agoyea, nothing to feel sorry about. What could anyone do with a few millions (or billions more) if they are already rich by half a million.. unless you are trying to climb the Forbes leaderboard.
- EpicEng 8y ago>if they are already rich by half a million.. unless you are trying to climb the Forbes leaderboard. That would be half a _billion_ and, generally, I don't "feel bad" for people who don't attain their dream of climbing the Forbes leader board (assuming that is even a goal for these two.)
- xkjkls 8y agoExactly. To be honest Instagram's hypergrowth probably couldn't have been sustained if the company didn't end up getting access to some of Facebook's engineering talent and hiring pipeline. Having 11 people try to manage a site of that scale is just asking them to keep doggypaddling to avoid drowning.
- obelix_ 8y agoGive it some time. Kim Kardashian has a 110 million followers. After the Russians (or whoever...maybe just that "400 pound dude in the basement") get her to become the next president I am waiting to see what boywonder shows up and says to Congress. We know what he and his exec staff thought about fake news before the election. Now who here thinks fake imagery is not a thing? Just take a look at the content produced by the top 100 accounts. There is going to be a special place in history for the damage boywonder has done. People will have to invent new terms to describe it. Nothing like it has happened ever before.
- johnchristopher 8y agoThe new term will be `zuckerbergism` if the whole thing can be pinpointed to him but I'd bet it's going to be something along the lines of `the social age`.
- misiti3780 8y agoor he just got very lucky. it only seems like he was "ahead of his time" because the story worked out - when you look at other acquisitions like say Oculus or Parse, I would argue it seems quite the opposite.
- austenallred 8y agoIf you spend $4 billion on acquisitions and one of those becomes worth $100 billion that is a win no matter how you slice it.
- misiti3780 8y agoof course it is win, no one is saying it's not a win, what im suggesting is there is a much higher probability that MZ got really lucky than assuming he some sort of clairvoyant genius.
- skinnymuch 8y agoWhatsapp has over 1.5B users now. Facebook paid for it mostly with stock back in 2014. That was a solid buy. Oculus while not a huge success was also only bought for a few billion. Not a bad loss. Parse wasn’t bought for that much. It might’ve not been a loss either. When two of their bigger acquisitions are slam dunk successes or just successes, that’s a pretty good record.
- drb91 8y agoWhat makes you attribute this to Zuckerberg instead of Facebook?
- throwaway2048 8y agoHe did not consult the board (nor did he need to as he controls a majority of stock, but its customary), it was clearly a personal choice by him.
- samsonradu 8y agoWell it might have played differently. If Facebook hadn't bought it then Facebook would have competed against it and that's not an easy fight. Look at Snapchat.
- xkjkls 8y agoIs Snapchat the best example? Snapchat is getting killed. Also, as it was made that Instagram only had 7 employees when they were purchased, that's actually one of major reasons why the acquisition worked so well. 7 employees for an application of that scale is not "swift and agile", it's criminally understaffed. After the Facebook acquisition, Facebook was able to easily redirect some of their hires to work on Instagram which allowed Instagram's original workforce to actually be able to worry about things other than just keeping their heads above water. It's definitely not ridiculous to credit some of Instagram's success to the acquisition itself.
- fabricexpert 8y agoIf you're not pushing revenue (i.e. you don't need a sales team, ads team), you probably aren't going to need that many engineers to run something like IG. The original feature set was pretty basic, and it only ran on iOS for quite some time.
- xkjkls 8y agoYeah, but 7 engineers at that growth rate means your entire team is just going to be devoted to beating all of the scaling fires. That leaves little time for other product improvements that might enable more growth. FB was pretty slow to monetize Instagram, and they still had hired 100s of people pretty quickly after the acquisition.
- mygo 8y agoIt’s quite possible to run a high-traffic app with a small staff if you have the right engineering talent and developed the infrastructure thinking about scale from the start. Before facebook bought Whatsapp they only had 5 employees. But they had the best engineers for the task at hand. In fact they’re famous for handling 2 million TCP connections on a single server due to much of their engineering decisions (including choice of tech stack). And it’s not like they weren’t generating revenue. Before facebook acquired them, their $1 fee earned them $1billion the first 9 months.
- thanatropism 8y agoTo be fair, the whole thing could still prove to be the mother of all bubbles. For one: we still don't really really understand network effects. There's huge value to being Facebook (you're forced to be there because all your friends are there and most nowhere else), but people also switch platforms for reasons that are not excellently understood. And when I say bubble I don't mean this or that company -- Silly Valley big money is basically all bet on network effects. (I.e. Instagram is worth $100B under the premise that I can't build an Instagram killer (that actually kills it) in a short period of time. And jeez, it's not fundamentally different from Geocities + Frontpage, just has better UX)
- xkjkls 8y agoIt also depends on your investment timeline here. Facebook and other social media properties have historically traded at super low multiples compared to other companies with similar growth/profits. Facebook is trading at 15x it's projected 2020 earnings. That's extraordinarily low compared to any other tech giant. I'd say the risks of one-day being usurped are already substantially factored in.
- thanatropism 8y agoThis is actually an excellent point, thanks for bringing it to my attention.
- austenallred 8y agoI mean I spend $100,000/month advertising on Facebook and Instagram, so it depends on what your definition of “bubble” is
- mac01021 8y agoWhat kind of product/service are you selling? Have you seen much indication that that has been money well spent?
- austenallred 8y ago
- theandrewbailey 8y agoThat's when I started using the word "instagram" as shorthand for "billion dollars". A while ago, Facebook bought Oculus for two instagrams. (It kind of makes sense: one for each eye in their VR headsets.)
- rmk 8y agoSimilar to John Chambers, who used to run Cisco. He bought a tiny switching company called Kalpana (and a few others) for ~200MM back in 1994. Cisco dominated the switching market for a long, long, time as a result. It still accounts for nearly a third of Cisco revenues even today (~45 B total revenue in 2017).