4 ms·
The new regime began in earnest in 2011. The FDA is also now making it easier to obtain experimental drugs for terminal illnesses. There are some negative sid
by mc32 8y ago
The new regime began in earnest in 2011. The FDA is also now making it easier to obtain experimental drugs for terminal illnesses.
There are some negative side effects, but overall, so long as there is full disclosure of known issues (we may need to improve upon this) I think people are better served by having a wider choice of medicines to address their ailments. Pro publica, here, is not being pro public but more anti pharma for unknown reasons.
It’s distateful when public interest orgs transform into political orgs with agendas.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoPeople are better served by having a wider choice No, the consensus in medial ethics is that patient outcomes are the only thing that's relevant. "Choice" is an important symbol in American Civil Religion, but it's not relevant, we are talking medical ethics here.
- mc32 8y agoMy bad, by choice I meant a wider array of drugs whereby this larger array implies better matches of drugs to treat illnesses more effectively. Let’s say drugX works well enough on 85% of patients and drugY works well enough on 5% of patients. It’s better to have both drugs available than just the one that treats the majority of patients.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoI don't think it's so clear cut. First of all with these drugs it's actually impossible to say what percentage of patients our new drugY will work on or who they are. Instead they're going to be marketed to everyone. In fact the article makes the case that these faster approvals may actually slow down our ability to get this information: The FDA also increasingly allows drugmakers to claim success in trials based on proxy measurements — such as shrunken tumors — instead of clinical outcomes like survival rates or cures, which take more time to evaluate. In return for accelerated approval, drug companies commit to researching how well their drugs work after going on the market. But these post-marketing studies can take 10 years or longer to complete, leaving patients and doctors with lingering questions about safety and benefit. So what, there's going to be a 10 year period where patients are unable to evaluate what their best shot at treatment is? We often forget that markets and rational decision-making require good information to produce good outcomes. Allowing drugs into the market that are opaque and expensive isn't going to make things better for patients, it's going to make it worse.
- XalvinX 8y agoI didn't read the article (yet) but this quote "drug companies commit to researching how well their drugs work after going on the market" means (correct me if I'm wrong here) that drug companies get to use the market as guinea pigs ? Do you take it to mean that? Others? I mean, there is no way that can be true, is there? The FDA is allowing private, for-profit companies (many with an already checkered past) to utilize citizens as their motherfucking lab rats? Ummmmmmmm.....no way. Don't we (the people, right?) get to vote on this or something? This doesn't seem very just.
- XalvinX 8y agodownvoted? to those that did, have a nice death. and your family too.
- dang 8y agoI can understand why you'd feel so strongly about this, but that doesn't make it ok to post flamewar rants to Hacker News. Posting like this in particular will get you banned here. If you'd please (re-)read the site guidelines and post civilly and substantively only from now on, we'd appreciate it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- XalvinX 8y agoThanks for the friendly warning. I will try to be more civil. Still, I'm surprised that it would be okay for one poster to actively promote dangerous drugs and defend big pharma and their psychiatrist puppets in an equally emotionally tone.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DannyBee 8y ago"It’s distateful when public interest orgs transform into political orgs with agendas." Okay, so what exactly do you think public interest orgs are?
- mc32 8y agoI’d like to see them explore truth (or close enough) rather than other tangential ideologies. I expect them to work on behalf of the public, rather than being anti something without good reason.
- astrodust 8y agoPretty much every group can be defined in terms of anti-something. Environmental groups are anti-pollution, anti-global-warming, anti-whatever. They all believe they're working on behalf of the public in some form. Anti-tax groups are helping billionaires which will something-something trickle-down and help everyone!
- DannyBee 8y ago"I expect them to work on behalf of the public, rather than being anti something without good reason." Certainly you realize whether they are working on behalf of the public depends on your relative viewpoint?
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Okay, so what exactly do you think public interest orgs are? Public interest organizations represent the diffuse general public against concentrated power, e.g. when the EFF pushes back against Hollywood lobbying for retroactive copyright term extensions. The issue is to avoid an "us vs. them" frame, because not everything MegaCorp wants is against the public interest. There is a public interest in having access to more medicine. It's counterproductive to fight something that helps everyone just because it also helps MegaCorp.
- DannyBee 8y agoThe OP said was distasteful when they turn into "political orgs with a political agenda". The EFF is in fact, a political org with a political agenda. They don't pretend otherwise. Whether they are working on behalf of the public all depends on your relative viewpoint. Pretty much all of them believe they are working on behalf of the public, even the ones HN would classify as industry lobbying orgs, etc.
- rayiner 8y ago> It’s distateful when public interest orgs transform into political orgs with agendas. Public interest orgs all have agendas. They also often take just as much liberty with the truth as private organizations, because outrage bait drives donations. (E.g. I'm an ACLU member, but I unsubscribed from Anthony Romero's emails because of how often I'd read through some story to realize it was misleadingly presented.)
- DanBC 8y agoWe know from other places that experimental cancer drugs are 1) very expensive 2) don't provide any meaningful benefit 3) cause unpleasant side-effects and 4) may expose people to toxic side-effects. See, for example, the English results of the Cancer Drugs Fund. https://www.bmj.com/content/357/bmj.j2097 https://www.bmj.com/content/357/bmj.j2097