6 ms·
No, those aren't real problems either. Problems are experienced by humans. Humans willing to pay money for solutions. Actual problems are things like "I want t
by wpietri 8y ago
No, those aren't real problems either. Problems are experienced by humans. Humans willing to pay money for solutions.
Actual problems are things like "I want to buy this candy bar," or "I want to fly to New York in August and I need to pay for the ticket." Those are problems Bitcoin, as "a purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash" [1], was intended to solve. It didn't.
As far as I can tell, the main problems blockchains "solve" are things like, "I would like to run a Ponzi scheme and not go to jail." Or, "I would like to hype something and make a lot of money off people." Or, "I would like my consulting company to bill a lot of hours." Or, "I would like to gamble on price fluctuations, and gold isn't volatile enough for me." But I wouldn't call any of those real problems in the sense of being things where solving them is positive sum for the society as a whole.
I would be happy to be proven wrong, of course. Blockchains are a cool technology. But I've spent nearly a decade asking for actual customer problems that are demonstrably solved better by a blockchain. I haven't found one yet.
[1] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- sjeohp 8y ago"I would like to pay/donate to an organization even though no major credit card will let me."
- wpietri 8y agoThanks. That's a plausible hypothetical. Could you name an organization like that? One that you are eager to donate to? How many people would like to donate to it? What's the total payment volume per year? The only organization I can think of that might be in that category is Wikileaks. But they take both credit cards and Paypal, so they don't qualify. Maybe Hamas or Al Qaeda? Except that those are illegal to donate to, so the market is not going to be large.
- TJSomething 8y agoI once backed crowdfunded hardware before crowdfunding services like Kickstarter were really a thing and they couldn't really get their credit card provider to accept the risk, so I had to use an international wire transfer for it. I guess cryptocurrency would be decent for that. That really just boils down to cryptocurrency being good for business models that are so new that they sound really risky. I'm not really sure that enabling such models is really a net good to society.
- darkmighty 8y agoLibrary Genesis/SciHub[1], and its various access portals[2]. Honestly LibGen+SciHub is doing more for humanity than almost any organization I know of. It's the next generation complement (not replacement) of Wikipedia -- truly opening the entirety of Man's knowledge to anyone. I don't oppose paying content creators, but I suspect the vast majority of people accessing this knowledge wouldn't do so under traditional publishing. This shows copyright is largely outdated, not serving society optimally as it should. As for Bitcoin and blockchains... my opinion is that they are extremely useful for efforts like those (and other niches like totalitarian states), if not much else. Perhaps paradoxically I also (controversially) think they should be outlawed and/or heavily regulated (outlawed but as a lightweight non-criminal offense). The potential for theft and money laundering is too large otherwise. In the limit where everyone used perfect secrecy coins, paying taxes would need to be largely voluntary. And I suppose we all know how well that would turn out. So I think cryptocurrencies are meant to be underground. It will always be possible to acquire some under the censorship conditions they are really useful for. So restricting their usage mainly curbs trivialized laundering. [1] https://sci-hub.nu/ https://sci-hub.nu/ [2] e.g. http://booksc.org/howtodonate.php http://booksc.org/howtodonate.php, it does support amazon gift cards too but I find that inconvenient
- wpietri 8y agoThanks! That's a good example. Very niche, so it's probably not enough to sustain a robust financial network. But I agree they could happily piggyback on a more general "light crime" cryptocurrency.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- spunker540 8y agoHow about “I want to buy a house without needing a bank as the middle man” or “I want to transact online without needing a credit card company intermediary taking fees” or “I want to cheaply send money to my family across the globe” or “I want to diversify with an asset that is truly global and not easily printable by some central government” or “my country’s currency is inflating like crazy and there arent enough usd accessible to safely convert”?
- madeofpalk 8y agoYou have the cash to buy a house without a bank? Go ahead. You don't need blockchain for that. Online transactions without fees? Bitcoin still has fees. I send money overseas cheaply, easily and instantly all the time. Without Blockchain.
- bramjans 8y agoWhat service do you use if I may ask?
- dmix 8y ago> I send money overseas cheaply, easily and instantly all the time. Without Blockchain. Really? I live in Canada and bill US customers for 6yrs and I've yet to find a solution for this that isnt awful. It's either slow, not practical for large amounts, very expensive, or requires tons of paperwork and special bank accounts not easily attained. So by all means please share your solution for this. It'd be a massive industry if you found one...
- Jommi 8y agoWhich service do you use? What are the fees? Between what countries?
- dmix 8y agoIt doesn't exist apparently. No reply to 3 people. He probably Venmo'd $5 to someone and thought it was a solved problem. Not a real solution to real significant cross-border money transfers.
- nostrademons 8y ago"Other people have money and I don't, so I'm going to redefine money as that which I have, and then I will have money and other people won't." I thought it was ridiculous too when I first heard about it, and then I realized that "other people have money and I don't" is perhaps the strongest motivation in history. The American, French, Russian, and Chinese revolutions all stemmed from that, as did WW2 and the Holocaust, as did the conquest of the Americas, as did the settlement of the American West.
- B1FF_PSUVM 8y agoThat's mostly wrong, if you take another look at it. The American revolution was rich aristocrats shaking off the power that the British ones had over them. The Russian revolution (October 1917) was a military coup that the Bolsheviks pulled off by subverting enough of an army tired of war - the democratic February revolution hadn't taken Russia out of WWI. The French revolution was a religious one - the encyclopedists had found a revelation, and by gosh they were going to islam the rest of the world with it. Etc.
- sacado2 8y agoFrench Revolution was also a way for the "bourgeoisie" (the riches, basically) to get the power that was still held by the aristocracy. So, actually people that had lots of money and thought they deserved to have more power.