3 ms·
The "ephemeralness" of the internet is still a huge, huge problem. We've only started to scratch the surface of the issue, and between censorship, "right to be
by toyg 8y ago
The "ephemeralness" of the internet is still a huge, huge problem. We've only started to scratch the surface of the issue, and between censorship, "right to be forgotten" and linkrot, it's already a complete shitshow.
We need a distributed and censorship-resistant conservancy system, because the Wayback Machine can only do so much (and it can trivially be censored). Unfortunately, it's not a money-making enterprise.
- throwawayjava 8y ago> We need a distributed and censorship-resistant conservancy system, because the Wayback Machine can only do so much (and it can trivially be censored). Unfortunately, it's not a money-making enterprise. Color me skeptical, but it seems like such a system would eventually need to seek out a business model and would turn into mugshotsonline.us writ large. Or "toxic yelp reviews of dubious origin" but for humans instead of businesses. And with all the perverse incentives. Censorship is bad, but profit-motivated society-wide forever-grudges against people in no significant position of power is also bad.
- rotexo 8y agoOnce I got doxxed by bloggers from one end of the political spectrum who thought I was a blogger from the opposite end (we have similar names, but the doxxers put out all of my info). Even after I got my info taken down, someone archived it and the archives got passed around on Twitter, prolonging the mess. Even now all that stuff shows up if you google my name. Should you care about what happened to me? I can’t really argue for it. But I can say that the dangers the above comment lists are real.
- rmorey 8y agohttps://ipfs.io https://ipfs.io
- icebraining 8y agoI don't think IPFS is uncensorable; if you have MITM on a user (like the Chinese government does), can't you just block any requests for a certain hash?
- erikpukinskis 8y agoIPFS+Tor would solve that?
- icebraining 8y agoChina is already blocking Tor; it was usable using the meek transport, which performed domain fronting to avoid censorship, but as Google and Amazon close that hole, it's probably quite hard to use Tor nowadays in China.
- zem 8y ago"ephemerality" is the common noun form, though "ephemeralness" is in the dictionary too.
- FussyZeus 8y agoThis is probably going to attract a lot of hate: why is conservancy such an important idea? I mean for a lot of websites, sure, I'd very much like to see that sort of thing backed up someplace but I've never once treated an Internet-based source as permanent. If I felt like it was something that would go away someday and that I would sorely miss, I downloaded it. I just don't understand and am curious where this idea comes from that the Internet must be archived. I don't necessarily disagree with it, but it seems like an expectation that's at odds with reality.
- toyg 8y ago> where this idea comes from that the Internet must be archived. Once newspapers finally kick the bucket (which is happening right now, in slow motion), all the information about our world will only be available in this ephemeral form - ready to be rewritten, manipulated or discarded by our rulers like China does now. Surely that is a terrifying thought, even if you haven't read 1984 or Fahrenheit 451...? The accountability that comes from historical records is one of the pillars of democratic societies. Losing it will plunge us in a very technological version of the Middle Ages.
- FussyZeus 8y agoAbsolutely, I guess I've just never viewed the Internet as a proper archive for that sort of thing precisely because it's so easily manipulated, censored, and changed.
- vfulco2 8y agothe faster decentralized, zero-trust, encrypted happens the better. Technology will always defeat the dark side