8 ms·
Europe's first solar panel recycling plant opens in France
- the-pigeon 8y agoThis seems odd to me. Solar panels should last at least 30 years but we've been finding most just keep working, potentially for decades longer. While the power they produce degrades with time, it's not enough to be worth junking the panel. Basically no solar panels should be recycled unless they are completely non-functional or faulty. My guess is this plant will be dealing almost entirely with damaged panels and not end of life panels. Or they hope to trick people into recycling perfectly good but old panels, which is not eco-friendly at all.
- sounds 8y agoI don't think it's a trick. While I don't know the details about this plant, I've noted that a large number of solar panels are removed (and then disposed of) while they have some useful life left. To be clear, I'm not saying people junk panels that are still producing. But just for panels generating a standard "bucketed" wattage, a very small amount of damage can lead to a "defective" panel. By removing the silicone and/or glass, the still-usable parts can be recycled into what you might call a "remanufactured" panel. Or, if the cells have been in service for a very long time, by taking apart the panel, the cells can be recycled as high-purity stock. (In other words, ground up and used to make new solar cells.) None of this makes economic sense until it is being done at huge scale. Therefore, I expect this is plant is mostly an experiment, expecting that as the deployment of panels continues to grow exponentially, having a viable (and proven) recycling plant will grow in value proportionally to the panels.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI have a solar panel that was hit by a falling rock (we're not sure how but it spiderwebbed the glass on the panel). I am a single sample but given the high number of solar installs, and the potential for mechanical damage (rocks, hail, etc) It seems like there might be sufficient material to support a recycling plant. That said, most commercial installations price out the replacement as part of the life cycle management of their solar infrastructure. They will 'recycle' perfectly good solar panels like they recycle perfectly good computers. If you are running operations for a large physical plant this helps you spread the maintenance over time and avoid times where there is more repair work to do than you have staff to do it with.
- caf 8y agoJust like end-of-lease computers, it would seem to make the most economic sense just to auction off those replaced panels as working units (albeit slightly degraded).
- planteen 8y ago> This seems odd to me. Solar panels should last at least 30 years but we've been finding most just keep working, potentially for decades longer. What installations do we have data on that have been running since 1970 or so? You say they should last at least 30 years but may keep working decades longer. > While the power they produce degrades with time, it's not enough to be worth junking the panel. It's not surprising to me that they will fail, even before 30 years. I mean, they are outside, subjected to weather and thermal cycling. They are going to get hit by lightning, hail, and lots of freeze/thaw cycles. Almost everything degrades in that environment. Even the panel support structures themselves will get crooked on that time scale from soil moisture changes.
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoSoil moisture changes? Most panels are mounted on metal rails on roofs, presumably the structure isn't shifting so much that the roof's geometry is changing. Otherwise, yes, obviously exposure to the elements is hard on everything, though humans successfully maintain structures that are hundreds of years old.
- planteen 8y agoI was talking about solar farms. I've started to see a few of them scattered around Colorado. The structure looks like something dug with a fence post hole digger. Old fences definitely show their age around here (as in they are crooked) due to expansive soils. Or maybe its mostly due to freeze/thaw in the ground.
- caf 8y agoThe 1970s was when solar PV started to be used for RAPS (remote area power supplies), so there's a reasonable number of installations out there of that era. I wonder if any surveys of those have been done.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- walrus01 8y agoI agree we should have some recycling capability. One of the things I think it will be used for is cheap panels that have failed entirely through encapsulation failure. If you follow the german photovoltaic industry there have been several large-scale grid feeding power plants that turned in all of their panels to the manufacturer for warranty replacement because the encapsulation failed. If you have a PV panel that isn't physically damaged and its encapsulation is still fine - it still has value even at 25 years of life... I'd happily buy a pallet load of used, physically fine condition 360W panels that when put on a STC flasher "only" produce 320W, at a very cheap $/watt price.
- StanislavPetrov 8y agoA solar panel purchased 25 years ago may be still technically functional but far, far less efficient than a modern solar panel.
- caf 8y agoSure, it's obviously not worth much - but the question is whether it's worth more as a less efficient but working panel, or as raw recycling feedstock material.
- walrus01 8y agoIt's worth nothing that the economics of the labor to remove "old" solar panels, transport them, recycle them, and install new panels may not make sense. Current technology monocrystalline silicon stuff can be guaranteed to have 80% of its original STC (standard test condition) power output after 25 years. Usually at which time the panels will be long since paid off and whatever power they are making for the roof owner is free money. 80% of original test-conditions rated power is still a lot - if you were to theoretically install a 40kW rated array composed of about 112, 360W panels, that would still be a 32kW array after 25 years.
- magduf 8y agoThat depends on how much more efficient the new panels are, and how much they cost. You only have so much roof area, so if you can generate enough power with the new panels over the old ones to more than recoup the costs, it's worth it.
- vkou 8y agoWe only have so much roof area, but we have almost no shortage of non-roof solar farm area.
- dogma1138 8y agoSolar farms are just as much of an eye sore as coal plants. I’m all for renewable energy but I don’t want huge solar plants everywhere either.
- walrus01 8y agoYou actually think this is as ugly as a coal power plant? I just don't know what to say. http://apsolarracking.com/images/ground-large_13.jpg http://apsolarracking.com/images/ground-large_13.jpg
- clon 8y agoPerspectives can differ. One of the greatest soaring sites in Europe (Aspres in the French Alps) is fighting for survival against a solar farm. An irreplaceable loss, given the topology in the area. Which is also why a flat plateau at the top of a mountain is suitable for solar production. Economics wise of course a small bunch of glider pilots will not stand a chance against the inevitable economic needs of the area. So yes, a solar farm can be a land wart, depending on where you stand. No panels visible here, but they are marching towards sacred ground: https://goo.gl/maps/8kagR6UNXXG2 https://goo.gl/maps/8kagR6UNXXG2
- polskibus 8y agoDoes anyone know what is the way to deal with dust and bird poo? I can imagine that the panels get dirty over the years which reduces their efficiency more than standard wear (less sunlight reaching the important layers). Is that accounted for in the numbers? Is there a study that provides insight on the maintenance required to run PV plant over 30yrs?
- Kenji 8y agoA whole lot of rain will pour down on those panels every year. You should be fine unless you live in a really dry and dusty area. Or if you have trees overhead which leave sticky leaves on your roof.
- dver 8y agoInvolved in large scale, long term solar testing in the past: I was almost always better to let the rain clean the panels in the field, even in some pretty dusty and arid climates. The deciding factor was usually the labor cost of the cleaning. (Think very depressed labor prices) Even then the risk of damage from the cleaning ops might sway away from manual cleaning.
- ISL 8y agoSoap and water?
- NegativeLatency 8y agoWater and a soft brush on a stick would probably work
- kdmytro 8y agoRain?
- gwbas1c 8y agoUpvoted. I watched my panels turn yellow from pollen a few weeks ago. It all washed away in the rain. Granted, I live in an area where we get rain on a regular basis.
- mlindner 8y agoPointless. Solar panels have nothing hazardous in them and anything worthwhile in them cannot be recycled without extensive processing.
- dd36 8y agoI am pretty sure these guys resell used panels in bulk. Not sure where they get them. http://sunelec.com/home/ http://sunelec.com/home/
- bunkydoo 8y agofdsfgdsfgsdfgdsf
- bunkydoo 8y agoasfasfasdfasdfasdfasd
- bunkydoo 8y agosociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Nulla leo eros, laoreet vel aliquam sed, tincidunt ut libero. Nulla efficitur lobortis magna quis dignissim. Quisque ac felis tortor. Quisque efficitur risus dolor, accumsan suscipit neque tincidunt id. Suspendisse eu tortor a est vestibulum facilisis sed quis nulla. Quisque vel nisi at metus dignissim mollis. Vestibulum ac lobortis eros. Nam imperdiet, tellus at maximus sagittis, ante erat euismod ipsum, vel dignissim leo augue et nulla. Aenean tempor faucibus nulla, in facilisis diam dictum quis. Nulla ac velit commodo, ullamcorper erat ut, malesuada urna. Fusce porta tellus velit, sed finibus velit tempus bibendum. Integer sem justo, consectetur non vulputate eu, tincidunt id est. Sed vel urna tortor. Morbi nibh ex, mollis id nisi ut, lacinia aliquam ante. Nulla viverra tortor nec scelerisque malesuada. Phasellus erat velit, ultrices ut aliquet eu, fermentum ac neque. Maecenas bibendum, sapien et mattis ultrices, libero ipsum blandit est, sollicitudin auctor purus augue
- timmy-turner 8y agoI wonder which technology they are using to remove the silicon and metal films from the glass. Two guys that used to work in the same shared office space had developed a process to do exactly that. They stumbled opon it while experimenting with extremely bright and powerfull UV flash lights (couple of kilowatts for the fraction of a second). These powerful UV-bursts then remove films from surfaces due to the tensions introduced by the sudden heating. Building the first prototype in one of the guys basement involved some insane EE-hacking on their part such as manufacturing flash tubes to their own specs and building high voltage transformers to drive the flash tubes. Last info I had was that they got founded and are trying to scale their process, opening a small experimental plant. The only alternative to their technology that I know of is either throwing away the glass or melting everything and then recoup all elements. The former produces lots of waste and the latter needs huge amounts of energy.