9 ms·
When a text can trigger a lynching: WhatsApp and incendiary messages in India
- wtmt 8y agoWhatsApp is really a multi-faceted platform in India. It's used by schools to send instructions to parents, used by parents in group chats, used by college students to discuss their classes, used for complaints to the authorities in some cases, used by authorities to broadcast messages to people in some cases...and it also happens to be the premier platform for spreading hoaxes, scams, junk forwards and fake news. I usually tell people not to believe anything that comes on WhatsApp, because that's how low the general quality of conversation on it happens to be when it's looked at in totality. The Indian government has been curbing free speech and attempting to increase its control on speech over time. People have been wrongly arrested and punished for liking something on Facebook, forwarding something on WhatsApp (that those in power don't like), etc. These incidents only serve to add more fuel to the government and many citizens who actually support higher control and monitoring of all conversations. In the last four years of this central government, the rhetoric of "you don't have to worry if you have nothing to hide" has been doing the rounds among many citizens who would otherwise not support such measures if some other parties were in power. It's as if they can't see the issues or don't want to see the issues. If not for the Supreme Court, which runs on its own pace and rhythm, India would've become an authoritarian "democracy". The only hope, IMO, lies with the judiciary. No political party is different on these lines. Whoever comes to power wants more control and power. Without better education and awareness (with even the so called educated people falling hook, line and sinker to fake news), there's not much hope. It's worrisome how much ammunition these incidents provide to the government to curb speech. P.S.: India has a restricted form of free speech, where vague terms like public order, affecting the sentiments of others on religious grounds, and such can be legally used to deny speech and also punish people arbitrarily. P.P.S: India doesn't yet have a data privacy law either. The very concept of privacy was laughed at for quite sometime, until August 2017 when a constitutional bench of the Supreme Court declared that the constitution, through various articles, does grant privacy as a fundamental right.
- walrus01 8y ago> P.S.: India has a restricted form of free speech, where vague terms like public order, affecting the sentiments of others on religious grounds, and such can be legally used to deny speech and also punish people arbitrarily. That's putting it mildly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_India https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-net/2017/india https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-net/2017/india https://www.engadget.com/2017/08/29/india-shut-off-internet-maintain-order/ https://www.engadget.com/2017/08/29/india-shut-off-internet-...
- strategyanalyst 8y agoFor a low income developing country, India has relatively higher freedom of speech that you'd expect.
- Karishma1234 8y agoIndia has no free speech whatsoever. Ironically 1st amendment of Indian constitution took that out. Unlike USA India does not have any right "against government". For example while American bill of rights mostly goes like this "Congress shall not pass any law restricting ....." All Indian rights have a bottom section that says. Indians have right to X. Nothing in this subsection will prevent government from passing any law that violates this section. All Indian constitutional rights are essentially "as long as government likes it".
- vthallam 8y agoBeyond your first 2 arguments I don't believe a thing you said is true or relevant. > The Indian government has been curbing free speech and attempting to increase its control on speech over time. Any specific examples please? > If not for the Supreme Court, which runs on its own pace and rhythm, India would've become an authoritarian "democracy" That's a very stretchy argument. India is not even 2% closer to authoritarian state and with 10's of political parties and a very strong democracy, I don't think we need to worry about that. > India has a restricted form of free speech, where vague terms like public order, affecting the sentiments of others on religious grounds Every country has that. Go say like "X religion is bad or the way things happen with Y religion people is crazy". You don't get to use your freedom of speech to incite anger in the masses. > India doesn't yet have a data privacy law either This is true. India should have a privacy law and I hope it comes sooner than later. But, India is just getting there in terms of digital penetration. So it will take time obviously. Just don't look at the West and feel bad.
- 794CD01 8y agoThe headline and article are written as if it's somehow outrageous that a text could do this, but when an old-school verbal shout can trigger a lynching, if anything, it would be a letdown if an electronic message couldn't.
- baxtr 8y agoExactly. This has nothing to do with the form of communication. The digital nature makes it merely public and accessible to a very large audience
- jklinger410 8y agoOr: When lynching can be triggered by a text. The incendiary culture of India.
- Karishma1234 8y agoRequest admin to flag this.
- dang 8y agoNationalistic battle is not allowed here. Please don't post like this again. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jklinger410 8y agoFor the record, I was merely making a play on words to illustrate how the title leads us to a certain conclusion. I have no opinion one way or the other on India. I find it interesting that much worse things are said about America on this forum. Not just from natives, but plenty of foreigners, and I don't see any silencing of that type of discussion here.
- Karishma1234 8y agoAs an Indian who runs several political groups this is at best shoddy reporting by foreign media. Often NGOS in USA use this kind of news reporting to generate more donations for themselves by showing this poverty porn to their rich donors. Lynchings do not get triggered by text. Indian people, even the poorest ones are not that stupid. Most often it is a case of genuine crime that the government fails to address. Recently two people of lower castes were badly beaten up for "using water of higher caste".[1] In reality the owner of the well was of even lower caste. The boys were swimming and pissing in the only well the entire region had of drinkable water. After several complains and requests the owner took matters into his own hands. For almost every single lynching that media reports as "whatsapp driven", the further detailed investigations point out either deep personal grudge, network of crimes such as cow thefts or pure political murder disguised as mob justice. I have not come across 1 single instance were people just killed someone for a whatsapp message. [1] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/2-dalits-caned-paraded-naked-in-maharashtra-for-swimming-in-well-of-upper-caste-man/articleshow/64595266.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-natio...
- thewarrior 8y agoWhenever any criticism of India turns up online a vocal and combative section always turns up dismissing all criticism as some bizarre media conspiracy. Eventually the thread gets flagged and it goes off the front page. What are you even trying to argue ? That the lynchings might have legitimate reasons ? Doesn’t change the fact that they are lynchings. Many parts of rural India are quite lawless and mob justice is the rule. You can be killed for the mere suspicion of having killed a cow. Now fake videos circulating via WhatsApp have worsened the problem. Even a cursory google search can find evidence of WhatsApp lynchings https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-44435127 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-44435127
- eklavya 8y agoA lot of noise/hatred/fear is also generated for all sorts of reasons by hiding facts and portraying a very particular picture. But what you are saying is also true. Do you think it's only India/Indians though?
- jeffdavis 8y agoFreedom of speech, like all freedoms, requires discipline and comes with costs. Sometimes those costs are tragically high, but freedom is worth it because the altenative is even worse. I wonder why this logic is rarely applied to the second amendment? Guns can be used for tragic purposes, but also allow vulnerable people to defend themselves when the police can't or won't. Nobody is really sure whether they can prevent the next tyranny, but we're pretty sure that tyrants or slaveowners don't want their subjects armed.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pavanred 8y ago> Freedom of speech, like all freedoms, requires discipline and comes with costs. Sometimes those costs are tragically high, but freedom is worth it ... I suppose its a good way to test one's position for consistency for such subjects. Apply the same argument of freedom/regulation to subjects like free speech, guns, privacy laws, drugs, throw in any other issue that's close to you etc.
- jeffdavis 8y agoEven supporters of gun rights don't really use this argument though. They seem to just say there is no real downside to guns, when obviously there is a downside, just like there is a downside for free speech.
- Semirhage 8y agoSpeech is an intrinsic quality of people, with purposes as diverse as thought and central to human expression. Guns are tools to kill something, and while they can in theory be used to kill or threaten to kill in a myriad of situations, they are still just killing machines. Most of human history hasn’t included them, they are not intrinsic abilities of nearly all humans, they’re not central to the ability to teach, learn, communicate, etc. That’s not to say guns aren’t important, or rights to guns shouldn’t be protected. It is saying however that comparing speech and guns makes apples and oranges comparisons look downright apt.
- Proven 8y agoWhen a person isn't allowed to bear arms she can get raped or lynched by two teens.
- OscarCunningham 8y agoNew communication methods can be used for the same things as old communication methods. This is not surprising.
- notadoc 8y agoAnother variation of toxic social media, 'fake news', and misinformation/propaganda, which is ubiquitous online and only growing. In the current internet environment, it's best to assume everything seen, found, rumored, or heard online is fake until proven otherwise.