4 ms·
> The objective of fusion research is to develop a power plant favourable to climate and environment. Like the sun, it is to derive energy from fusion of atomic
by epistasis 8y ago
> The objective of fusion research is to develop a power plant favourable to climate and environment. Like the sun, it is to derive energy from fusion of atomic nuclei
While plasma containment seems like an essential step towards fusion-based energy, is fusion-based energy a desirable goal?
Right now, fission-based nuclear energy is only used as a heat source for steam-driven turbines. It's a fantastically complex and expensive way to make heat.
Is fusion energy on Earth going to do something similar? And if so, is this source of heat actually going to be cheaper than using the sun as a distant fusion reactor? (Which is what drives both solar and wind energy on Earth.) It seems quite doubtful that fusion could ever be cheaper than solar or wind energy, the tech-to-energy ratio just seems massive in comparison.
So if it's not Earth where fusion energy will be useful, how about in space? Here on Earth, the Carnot cycle is used to convert heat into useful mechanical energy, then finally electrical energy, which is usually the true goal. But the Carnot cycle requires dissipating massive amounts of heat; just as much energy is dissipated as heat as gets turned into electricity. And heat dissipation isn't such an easy thing in space, is it?
I feel like I'm missing some rather large puzzle pieces here. Without them, fusion does not really seem like an engineering goal towards a good energy source, just engineering research into better containment of difficult materials. Could somebody help enlighten me?
- rohit2412 8y agoJust a layman. But wind and solar have big limitations. They are available only in a limited amount only under certain conditions and their variability isn't under our control. And if you think energy storage would solve all this, batteries aren't cheap. We would like to have an infinite source of energy that we can control on demand.
- rock_hard 8y agoOh, but a fusion power plant is gonna be cheap?
- jnxx 8y ago> They are available only in a limited amount only under certain conditions and their variability isn't under our control. If one connects wind turbines to an electrical grid in a larger area, the variability averages out. Battery storage is being discussed. But what is probably more economical is that a significant proportion of energy usage is somewhat flexible in time. Take hot water generation. It is expensive to store the amount of electricity to bring 100 liters of water to boil, but it is very easy to store 100 liters of hot water for a few days. Heating and cooling make a very big proportion in modern energy use. And this isn't a new idea at all - all of human history, our energy management was around making use of a surplus of energy, like food, for times when less was available, and using storage.
- kemiller 8y agoThere are other potential ways to extract electricity from a plasma. Since plasma is high-energy charged particles, you can extract voltage directly from their kinetic energy. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_energy_conversion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_energy_conversion
- epistasis 8y agoAha, that's exactly the term I was missing! Thank you so much. In particular, the gamma radiation energy capture in that Wikipedia article addresses another somewhat undesirable aspect of fusion in a really great way.
- jcfrei 8y agoNot an expert by any means but I think the benefits of fusion power lie in the future: Namely as a power plant for interstellar exploration. The energy received by the sun might be enough to power infrastructure on earth but planets and space ships further away might need their own power source.
- pfdietz 8y agoBeamed propulsion would be far better for interstellar travel.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- azernik 8y agoThe hope is that fusion will, indeed, be less complex and expensive than fission. This is for a few reasons: 1. The fuel is much more common and easier to handle - uranium and plutonium are a pain to extract/transmute, handle, and package. 2. The radioactive contamination is limited to induced radioactivity in the structural materials of the reactor core; there aren't the safety concerns of radioactive neutron moderators and the like that you see in a fission reactor. Preventing the release of those materials in the case of accident is one of the big drivers of fission plant costs. 3. The core itself is fail-off, again reducing the cost and complexity of safety measures. 4. They are not dual-use (civilian/military) to the extent of the fission supply chain. 5. By comparison to the rather indirect method of using solar panels and wind turbines to extract energy from solar radiation, steam turbines are a simple and efficient way of extracting energy from a fusion reaction. The Sun is enormous, but a fusion reactor would be right here and we can extract energy from one with well-understood, efficient technology.
- jnxx 8y agoSuch things are often claimed. But every single statement here is false: ad 1) Nuclear fusion as we know it does not rely only on deuterium, it needs tritium. Tritium needs to be produced by uranium fission, and after having a hypothetical fusion power plant running, by a breeding process. The technology of that breeding process is today completely unsolved. 2) Fusion reactors, if they aver will exist. will be large and will have a very large neutron flux. The will have breeding blankets which need to be several meters in size. Anything within these structures will be activated by neutrons. That means common materials such as carbon steel can't be used, because the carbon would become highly radioactive. Also, the neutron radiation weakens all known materials so that the structures will probably need to be periodically replaced. This alone will probably lead to a higher amount of nuclear waste than uranium fission plants. 3) It is correct that the fusion reaction will stop to operate when the core is damaged. But this does not mean that the plant is safe then. It will contain substantial amounts of tritium and other radionuclides. By the way, you may have seen nice photos of scientists in white coats which stand in the vacuum vessel of a a fusion power plant. Except that, if there were actually fusion to happen in these devices, nobody could enter them before they have been decontaminated in a time-consuming and expensive process. Consequently, in experiments such as ITER, no fusion happens at all. In addition, a fusion plant will be very complex, and especially it will work with extremely large magnetic fields which have by themselves a tremendous energy content. If there is any electrical or structural failure, it is likely that the whole structure just blows apart. And it will not safe to be standing nearby. 4) As said, tritium is a key ingredient in the fusion technology that is aimed for, and it also happens to be a key ingredient of thermonuclear weapons. In addition, the required breeding technology is also highly relevant for military uses, because if you can breed tritium from lithium, you can also breed weapons-grade uranium and plutonium. 5. Steam turbines are not physically simpler than wind turbines. Apart from that wind power converters, as well as photovoltaic energy converters, can come pretty close to the physically possible optimum, there is another problem: Large steam turbines need cooling for thermodynamical reasons. Lots of cooling. The amount of cooling required for today's uranium fission plants is already a problem. For one, they cannot be built in arbitrary places - they need to be at rivers or at the coast. As the fukushiuma plant has shown, having a nuclear plant at the seaside can be a bit risky. But cooling by rivers also has costs, heating up a river to much messes up its ecology. Also, France often has energy problems in the summer, and the reason is that the rivers are too hot to cool its numerous nuclear plants. Here another article on further problems of nuclear fusion - see the article of Michael Moyer. http://energyskeptic.com/2014/why-fusion-is-still-30-years-away/ http://energyskeptic.com/2014/why-fusion-is-still-30-years-a... As a closing remark, I am not saying that fusion power plants are impossible. Sometimes, technological break-troughs happen, similar to the advances which made airplanes and aviation possible. But today, we don't even know what is required to make it possible. We are in a similar position like people from 1800 were in respect to aviation. And also, we have more urgent problems to solve - we need clean energy within the next decade, not in the next century. And fortunately, we do have the technology for that, we just need to put it in march.