7 ms·
So where are they along the project plan to useful fusion energy? Since that is not the end goal of this project, how far along the project plan for this device
by phkahler 8y ago
So where are they along the project plan to useful fusion energy? Since that is not the end goal of this project, how far along the project plan for this device are they?
I'm really well past the phase of being excited about milestones like "record for a stellarator". Put it in context, show where we are on the plan. Perhaps it's behind, but still moving forward - that's fine. Confirming things work as predicted is awesome and tells me they should be moving forward at a good pace right? So where are they on that gantt chart?
- maxxxxx 8y agoThey are still far away from a useful reactor. There are a lot of fundamental questions to be resolved.
- Semirhage 8y agoNowhere close, but as you rightly stated, that isn’t the goal of this experimental device. For what it is, which is an exploration of the dynamics of containing high temperature plasmas, it is a resounding success. What you’re asking is sort of like someone asking Babbage how close he is to a Pentium 90. Babbage still did some incredible and foundational things, and it was still a world away from playing Doom. There are a lot of issues outstanding for fusion to be a viable power source, and this reactor is simply exploring the dynamics of one of those issues. Putting aside hype and desperation, there is no chart yet. For a fusion plant to work and compete with any other plant, you need it to have good uptime, relatively low maintenance burdens in terms of downtime and costs, good output, a viable source of fuel, a fusion cycle that is safe and sustainable, and more. As of today the d-t cycle isn’t sustainable because it requires tritium, produces a lot of energetic neutrons that along with helium will undermine the reactor. The problem is that more viable fusion cycles occur at significantly higher temperatures and it’s a struggle to control plasma at d-t temps. The lack of control both quenches the reaction, and exposes parts of the reactor to plasma which erodes the material. Neutron bombardment causes the metal to become brittle, and helium infiltrates and undermines it too. So a reactor would be down for maintenance a lot, which would make it difficult to work as an economically viable source of power. As of today the tritium for the reaction has to be bred in fission reactors. There are theoretical plans to use a “blanket” impregnated with an isotope of Lithium to breed tritium within the fusion reactor, but so far no one has gotten it to sustainably work near necessary levels. As a result a fusion reactor today would require fission reactors, and it might make sense to ask why we don’t just stick to the far more mature and efficient fission technology. There are lots of other issues that aren’t as big or obvious as what I’ve described, but ITER and desperation hype aside, there are more unsolved problems than solved. So where this reactor is concerned, be excited for what it is away from the context of “fusion any day now!” hype. Appreciate the slow, but steady progress in the context of incremental research. If you want clean power in your lifetime, support fission plants.
- Certhas 8y agoMostly agreed, but: "If you want clean power in your lifetime, support fission plants." Not anti nuclear or anything, but you really want a large share of wind+solar. Less hard to handle waste and cheaper. Once we are approaching 80% wind+solar we can discuss how to best deal with the difficult remaining 20% (load shifting, expanded transmission grids, storage, CCX and Carbon2Gas gas plants and nuclear are all options that are possibly going to play a role).
- apendleton 8y agoThey're only cheap and low-waste if you don't have to worry about storage, and that needs to be solved well before the 80% point. Battery manufacture is pretty dirty, and even if the environmental issues were not a concern, it's not clear that enough raw materials (rare earths, etc.) exist in the world to move the entire power grid to intermittent sources plus battery storage. And so far, no alternative storage sources have proven themselves broadly viable (pumped hydro is probably closest but requires fairly specific climate and geography). Personally I'm with Bill Gates on this one: we basically need an innovation miracle to solve our energy and climate problems, but probably just one, and it can be in any of four or five different fields (renewables + storage, fission, fusion, biofuels, carbon capture, etc.). Success in any one of those spaces is far from guaranteed, so we shouldn't put all our eggs in one basket, and should be aggressively pursuing all of them in the hopes that at least one will pan out.
- adrianN 8y agoSolar thermal that stores energy in molten salt sounds like a cool technology that can drastically reduce the need for batteries. You could probably set up large solar thermal plants in the Sahara and power Europe via HVDC lines without needing many batteries.
- hutzlibu 8y agoYes, you could do that, also in the other deserts for other parts of the world. There is a big Initiative with that goal, desertec. But unfortunately it got very quiet around them.
- martinpw 8y agoThere is a chart here from the same site (which would have been useful for them to have included in the main article) which shows how this device theoretically compares with others and with the end goal: https://www.ipp.mpg.de/15144/zuendbedingungen https://www.ipp.mpg.de/15144/zuendbedingungen Unclear where in that shaded region the new result lies.
- cjhopman 8y agoWhy is it unclear? AFAICT, it lies outside the shaded region (just below the bottom left part). The scale is in the chart is a little unclear, but all the data is in the article.