3 ms·
I'm always amazed at the people who can drop a hundred lbs in a year. "I just changed my diet to 1500 calories and bam, the weight fell off." Not that it isn't
by bluedino 8y ago
I'm always amazed at the people who can drop a hundred lbs in a year. "I just changed my diet to 1500 calories and bam, the weight fell off."
Not that it isn't that simple, because it is. But, because for most people who are 100lbs overweight, they have a very unhealthy relationship with food. They stress eat, binge eat, binge drink, purge...
I guess it's kind of like the people who can just all of a sudden quit smoking, cold-turkey one day. Maybe they weren't addicted to nicotine in the first place?
- koolba 8y ago> Not that it isn't that simple, because it is. But, because for most people who are 100lbs overweight, they have a very unhealthy relationship with food. They stress eat, binge eat, binge drink, purge... I've tried explaining this to people who claim, "But X barely eats and doesn't lose any weight.". While there may be some variation in body efficiency and metabolism, if a person isn't losing weight over an extended period of time then they're eating more than they're burning and they're probably doing it when you can't see them.
- RandallBrown 8y agoSaw a video about two women, one overweight and one skinny. They ate together regularly and the skinny woman would always eat much more food. They followed both around and while it was true that the skinny woman ate more at meals, that was also pretty much the only time she ate anything. The overweight woman was snacking all day long. When I was working on losing weight, I very loosely did the calorie counting thing and realized that the milk and cookies I would occasionally make after dinner was like 700 calories. Before I would just think about my meals with almost no thought about the extras.
- vidarh 8y agoI think a lot of it comes down to what made you decide to change. 10-12 years ago I decided to get in shape, and I calorie counted and exercised every day for the next 2 years, and stuck to the gym for a decade. Now I'm struggling to get back into it again after letting my weight creep up. What made me start the first time was a really scary moment of getting up and nearly blacking out (not getting up to fast and getting dizzy; I'm talking things just went properly black in a way I've not experienced before or since) and having distorted vision for 20 seconds or so after I sat back down. Couple that with persistent knee pain that made my doctor look at me for about 10 seconds before giving me an exercise sheet for old people (when you're in your 30's and get handed a sheet of exercises where the pictures are of people 60+ it's not a good sign). Get the right motivation and it gets a lot easier to stick with it. Different life events made me start to slip a couple of years back, and at the moment I find it hard to be motivated in part because I still feel healthier than I did last time, and I'm far stronger than I was, and feeling like I'm in a better position makes it so easy to justify that one extra helping of food. I'm not saying that to diminish the effort it takes to stick with it, but just to point out that even for the same person, the right catalyst (or lack of one) can mean the difference between sticking through it all the way through and not even getting started. Also keep in mind survivor bias - not many of us will write about how we hoped to drop a hundred lbs but failed 5 lbs in. 10 times in a row.
- cirgue 8y ago> But, because for most people who are 100lbs overweight, they have a very unhealthy relationship with food. They stress eat, binge eat, binge drink, purge... One of the points of tracking calories/ gamifying the process of loosing weight is specifically to break those associations and reward mechanisms. If you're counting the calories you consume and constantly have a reminder of what your sacrifice of not eating will get you (eg measurable progress toward weight loss), then it is easier to alter your relationship with food.
- axisK 8y agoIn my case you're 100% spot on with the unhealthy relationship part. I lost around 45kg in slightly less than a year and gained most of it back in the 2 years after. For the most part, it's due to really bad habits built up over years. Addictions are interesting things to break - I suspect they're also very different based on the person. I smoked for close to 10 years before going cold-turkey from 3 packs a day yet the nicotine cravings I had doesn't come close to how badly I crave sweet stuff most of the time.