7 ms·
The "Fermi paradox" isn't meant to be an actual paradox in formal terms. It is simply asking basically "if the universe is teeming with life, where is it?" and
by vidarh 8y ago
The "Fermi paradox" isn't meant to be an actual paradox in formal terms.
It is simply asking basically "if the universe is teeming with life, where is it?" and by that raising both the question of whether or not the universe actually is teeming with life, and if it is, why aren't they here? It reduces to an actual paradox only if you assume an answer to one part (the amount of life) that isn't reasonably compatible with the second part (why we haven't seen evidence of it) without a reasonable explanation.
That it simply on average takes too long for us to have seen evidence yet is in fact one of the many suggested solutions.
But overall the point of the Fermi paradox is that the problem if why we don't see aliens is two-pronged: They might never develop, or just not have developed yet, to a sufficient stage. But it's also possible they do, but that something else prevents them from contacting us.
Thus the idea of "great filters" for example. E.g. maybe the universe is full of life, but it's exceedingly rare for it to survive long enough to be able to make contact without being destroyed. Maybe the odds of getting killed off by asteroids is too high. Maybe war takes out most that get to a certain level. Maybe someone out there takes pot-shots at anyone sticking their head out? Maybe some galactic events sterilises large swathes of space too often? (intense gamma bursts have been raised as one possibility)
As well as many other options. E.g. maybe we're quarantined? Maybe we're in a simulation, and simulating aliens just isn't part of the program?
- Izkata 8y agoPretty sure we already have one answer to the paradox: the dinosaurs, and how long they were around without any sort of civilization. Simply reaching intelligence has got to be one of the great filters.
- ekianjo 8y agoExactly. And the coming of humans as a dominant specie on Earth is pretty much coincidental (humans faced extinction several times, that we know) so there is absolutely no "fate" that leads to human-like intelligence.
- joshlemer 8y agoHowever, there are quite a few other species still around which are pretty intelligent (elephants, other great apes, whales and dolphins, octopi) so the development of intelligence may not be all that rare.
- tfha 8y agoBut none of them have the ability to pass learned knowledge through many generations the way that we can. For most species, what a mom can teach a kid is very limited, and special skills tend to be static between generations as opposed to continually building on each other
- Retric 8y agoDolphin teach skills across multiple generations. They don't have any real way to build civilizations or technology though. Really on it's own intelligence does not change much. You need both long term food storage and fire to really advance.
- seandougall 8y agoOpposable thumbs help an awful lot, too.
- maxwell 8y agoSeveral other species have opposable thumbs[1], and many mammals have elaborate long-term food storage. Other apes have been observed hunting with spears; basket making and song are also practiced by birds; cetaceans might have more advanced spoken language; sweat and bipedalism aren't common but aren't unique; etc. But no other (non-extinct) species can start a fire. 1. https://srfoundation.blogspot.com/2009/01/other-animals-with-opposable-thumbs.html https://srfoundation.blogspot.com/2009/01/other-animals-with...
- DenisM 8y agoHuman language is somewhat unique in that it can describe multitude of future outcomes, not just a present state of things. Turing complete if you will. This is a bit of a wild idea I have anyway, don’t judge me harshly. :)
- ghaff 8y agoIt's hard to truly grok just how long the dinosaurs were around. It's easy to say that, had life not almost been wiped out by an asteroid things would have worked out differently, but the dinosaurs had something like 200 million years and there's no evidence they developed anything approaching human-like intelligence.
- Keyframe 8y agoYou're saying that like humans (well, evolutionary predescesors) weren't around and evolving over that period as well.
- magduf 8y agoThey were, but mammals at that time were pretty simple and weren't doing that well against their dinosaur competitors. When the asteroid took out most of the dinosaurs, that's when mammalian life really took off, because they were able to survive the many years of lack of sunlight that ensued.
- zipwitch 8y agoWhat would such evidence look like? I don't think we can consider brain size definitive, since it's possible for humans with about ~10% of our normal brain volume to function normally. There seems to be no evidence for tool use, much less advanced technology, but again, what would these even look like after so many millions of years? I think about all we can say is that no prior species changed the planet in the same fashion we have.
- jakelazaroff 8y ago> It's hard to truly grok just how long the dinosaurs were around. One of the crazier things I've heard recently is that the time between the present and the Tyrannosaurus Rex [1] (68-66 million years) is less than the time between the T-Rex and the Brontosaurus [2] (156-147 million years ago, or 79 million years before the T-Rex). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyrannosaurus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyrannosaurus [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brontosaurus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brontosaurus
- pure-awesome 8y ago> The "Fermi paradox" isn't meant to be an actual paradox in formal terms. I think this is a misunderstanding of the use of the word "paradox". Informally, people use "paradox" like it means "contradiction" when in actuality it means "APPARENT contradiction". See, e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox > A paradox is a statement that, despite apparently sound reasoning from true premises, leads to an apparently self-contradictory or logically unacceptable conclusion. The Fermi paradox is indeed an apparent contradiction, whether or not it is an actual contradiction. The same holds for many, if not almost all uses of the word "paradox" in standard literature. For example, Zeno's Paradox is not a contradiction, we've resolved it (an infinite sum of decreasing values can add up to a finite number), and yet it is still a paradox. (For a more precise classification, see e.g. Quine's classification of Paradoxes)
- DennisP 8y agoThe point of the paper is that the Fermi paradox isn't even an apparent contradiction.
- ataturk 8y agoThe answer to all of the above is: The massive distances between places in the universe. We lack the resolution to see, but that doesn't mean it's not out there. Unless technology can somehow manipulate physics in order to open join-points between far flung places, it makes total sense why we can't get there and they can't get here.